consistantly consistant!!! owners are hands on.really cool employees who take pride in what they do. pizza is top notch. Michael is open to making stuff not on the menu. veal meatballs in the vodka sauce will make you stutter. always fresh.
Richard Del Toro
Awesome place! Went in for the first time and we treated like family. The food was excellent catered to all our request and more. My mom is gluten free and Mike was able to comply with her order. My wife wanted meatballs on her pizza, Done as well. There was nothing they couldn't do. They also gave us some samples of new things they were working on and it was all awesome. I hope those samples become a menu item. Sorry it's a secret. Lol. Everyone will have to wait. Thank you for an awesome first time experience.
Lori B.
The two times I have ordered from there I was very disappointed. The first time I ordered a salad there were barely any lettuce leaves on the plate and they charged $12 ! (no meat only arugula) The second time I ordered a lunch special. I specifically said I do not want roasted red peppers and roasted red peppers were on it. One piece of prosciutto was on the panini. The bread was stale and it was cold. The side salad also was lacking. There were hardly any lettuce leaves in there. The restaurant smells like dirty wet mop. I will not return.
Kathy Ayres
We visited yesterday from outside Philadelphia. The beef meatballs are amazing!! So delicious - could have eaten a dozen! We got the sampler too - can’t wait to try the rest! We got our order to go and it was packaged so well for our trip back to PA. Meatballs heated up well in the oven - super fresh and tasted so good.??
Matthew Dunn
Went in for lunch and got the Buffalo Chicken Panini and it was awesome. The chicken was really good and the buffalo sauce wasn't too over powering. I got a half of one with fries and it was plenty. The people on the job site say that everything they ever had from here was really good!
Chris Dickinson
Been interested in ordering from here since the reviews are good and it’s in the neighborhood so finally gave it a shot and it delivered. The owner personally delivered my food and introduced himself which I really appreciate. I ordered the veal,pork,beef meatball parm hero with vodka sauce and I loved every bite. I never order delivery because I hate when the food sits in the packaging but I’m currently laid up with an injury so I had to. Everything was perfect, bread was crispy, meatballs are delicious, and the vodka sauce is great. Not much else you can ask for. Will definitely order again.
Matthew Smith
Just finished eating there and took some for home! The food was spot on! The environment was friendly and clean! The meatballs were on point the pesto was fresh and that vodka sauce is unbelievable this is the new go to! I’ll see you for Christmas Eve Michael’s will be doing my catering for sure!
Gerardine Piscopo
I recommend Michaels Pizzeria & MeatBalls the meat Balls are Delicious ?
Carmelo DeFranco
Absolutely the best meatballs on Staten Island!Mike’s makes a great sauce and lots of different meatballs to choose from.
OMG! I died and went to meatball heaven! Amazing meatballs and such a wonderful tasting sauce. I totally recommend Michael's Meatball Shoppes. I included a pic because I want you to see just how appetizing they look. There were 3 now it's down to 2. Won't be long before those are gone too.
Alexa MG
I always get the vegetarian meatball parm w marinera lunch special when I can. Always delicious and consistent. Great service and fast! ?
Paul Ivanac
I had the meatball sampler every meatball was delicious. Mike the owner was very friendly.
Eliot Ocasio
Great place great people. I always enjoy Michael's Meatball shop. Spaghetti with stuffed meatball, Italian bread topped with mozzarella and garlic. The sauce is great. Thanks for bringing this to our neighborhood.
Jonathan Weinberg
We ordered meatballs for lunch from Michael's Meatball Shoppes yesterday, and it was so good we ordered again today. We've tried the Stuffed Meatballs and the Sausage & Cheese Meatballs so far. Both were fantastic. There are still at least 2 more varieties I am excited to try, particularly the Chicken Meatballs w Marsala sauce. I am very excited to have discovered this place!
consistantly consistant!!! owners are hands on.really cool employees who take pride in what they do. pizza is top notch. Michael is open to making stuff not on the menu. veal meatballs in the vodka sauce will make you stutter. always fresh.
Awesome place! Went in for the first time and we treated like family. The food was excellent catered to all our request and more. My mom is gluten free and Mike was able to comply with her order. My wife wanted meatballs on her pizza, Done as well. There was nothing they couldn't do. They also gave us some samples of new things they were working on and it was all awesome. I hope those samples become a menu item. Sorry it's a secret. Lol. Everyone will have to wait. Thank you for an awesome first time experience.
The two times I have ordered from there I was very disappointed. The first time I ordered a salad there were barely any lettuce leaves on the plate and they charged $12 ! (no meat only arugula) The second time I ordered a lunch special. I specifically said I do not want roasted red peppers and roasted red peppers were on it. One piece of prosciutto was on the panini. The bread was stale and it was cold. The side salad also was lacking. There were hardly any lettuce leaves in there. The restaurant smells like dirty wet mop. I will not return.
We visited yesterday from outside Philadelphia. The beef meatballs are amazing!! So delicious - could have eaten a dozen! We got the sampler too - can’t wait to try the rest! We got our order to go and it was packaged so well for our trip back to PA. Meatballs heated up well in the oven - super fresh and tasted so good.??
Went in for lunch and got the Buffalo Chicken Panini and it was awesome. The chicken was really good and the buffalo sauce wasn't too over powering. I got a half of one with fries and it was plenty. The people on the job site say that everything they ever had from here was really good!
Been interested in ordering from here since the reviews are good and it’s in the neighborhood so finally gave it a shot and it delivered. The owner personally delivered my food and introduced himself which I really appreciate. I ordered the veal,pork,beef meatball parm hero with vodka sauce and I loved every bite. I never order delivery because I hate when the food sits in the packaging but I’m currently laid up with an injury so I had to. Everything was perfect, bread was crispy, meatballs are delicious, and the vodka sauce is great. Not much else you can ask for. Will definitely order again.
Just finished eating there and took some for home! The food was spot on! The environment was friendly and clean! The meatballs were on point the pesto was fresh and that vodka sauce is unbelievable this is the new go to! I’ll see you for Christmas Eve Michael’s will be doing my catering for sure!
I recommend Michaels Pizzeria & MeatBalls the meat Balls are Delicious ?
Absolutely the best meatballs on Staten Island!Mike’s makes a great sauce and lots of different meatballs to choose from.
Pizza taste so good and amazing ...
Restaurantji Recommends
OMG! I died and went to meatball heaven! Amazing meatballs and such a wonderful tasting sauce. I totally recommend Michael's Meatball Shoppes. I included a pic because I want you to see just how appetizing they look. There were 3 now it's down to 2. Won't be long before those are gone too.
I always get the vegetarian meatball parm w marinera lunch special when I can. Always delicious and consistent. Great service and fast! ?
I had the meatball sampler every meatball was delicious. Mike the owner was very friendly.
Great place great people. I always enjoy Michael's Meatball shop. Spaghetti with stuffed meatball, Italian bread topped with mozzarella and garlic. The sauce is great. Thanks for bringing this to our neighborhood.
We ordered meatballs for lunch from Michael's Meatball Shoppes yesterday, and it was so good we ordered again today. We've tried the Stuffed Meatballs and the Sausage & Cheese Meatballs so far. Both were fantastic. There are still at least 2 more varieties I am excited to try, particularly the Chicken Meatballs w Marsala sauce. I am very excited to have discovered this place!