Just went here for the first time and it was delicious! Great bagels, fast and nice service, with a nice atmosphere inside. I got a half a dozen and they gave an extra to me for free. Definitely come here if you're in the Staten Island area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sal
I’ve had bagels from all 5 boroughs, NJ, PA, CT…, these are bagels. I understand there’s good and bad, but these are what I’d call a NY Bagel. I’m not knocking that. But- the inside has little to no appeal and the employees are just about clueless. You ask them questions simply about cream cheese availability and they have no clue. They are so distracted that they won’t even give you back your change… would I go back? Absolutely not. And trust me I love good bagel shops and even travel from Staten Island to queens… this place I guess is good if your some Brooklynite who loves to be obnoxious and claims this is the best place out of the 4 total they tried. I guess you can say this place is the armpit of the south shore. The plus side was it was 9.50 for 3 bagels with cream cheese.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
S M
Begals are great, service sucks. Takes you 30 minutes to get your order when busy. And, also takes 30 minutes to get your order when its slow. The staff are always arguing with each other. Just not managed correctly. Shame, because their begals are so
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Egg and Cheese Sandwich
Nicole Z.
I've always loved Mikey's bagels. Recently the older women who works there is so so so nasty and rude I could not believe it. She was cursing to someone then I got my bagel she was so rude if she does not like her job or people she shouldn't be working there. After dealing with her nasty attitude I will never go back there. It's ashame because this has always been mine as well as my families favorite bagel store.
Jenna W.
This is the fourth bagel place I have tried in Staten Island and this is by far my favorite. The bagels have a nice chew and actually have flavor! They aren't small and one with cream cheese enough to fill you up!
Rachel Bronko
Best bagels in NYC. The staff always treats you like family! We love Mikeys Bagels!
Peter ibrahim
Service was Great, had much better bagels on the island.
willis smith
Good food and Customer Service.
Lisa Kroeger
Best bagels in Tottenville!
Million Miles
I've only been here once but the quality, great taste, and friendly customer service/care is of the high enough level in which it guarantees my return to purchase and experience more.They have absolutely fantastically tasty French Toast Bagels.Stop in and give one a try.Toasted with cream cheese!
very very good service best breakfast i have ever had, so chocked about the fluffy good pancakes and i will definitely come back and recommend you to visit !!! you won’t regret it!
Samantha Taranto
Great bagels and friendly service. The bagels are always fresh and well prepared. The owner is very friendly and welcoming. Quick service and always delicious thank you ?
Jesse K.
This spot opened up when I was going to the middle school down the block and is still my go to when I'm back visiting home, 13 years later. Bagels are always perfect and so are the sandwiches. They renovated not too long ago too so it's very nice and clean inside. Super quick service too.
Christina Avenoso Martucci
Delicious bagel and egg sandwich, staff was very friendly and service was quick. Coffee is good too!
Christopher C.
They put a new cook on the grill on Father's Day. Waited 15 mins for a single sandwich and had to leave. Other people were waiting before me and still were waiting
Just went here for the first time and it was delicious! Great bagels, fast and nice service, with a nice atmosphere inside. I got a half a dozen and they gave an extra to me for free. Definitely come here if you're in the Staten Island area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’ve had bagels from all 5 boroughs, NJ, PA, CT…, these are bagels. I understand there’s good and bad, but these are what I’d call a NY Bagel. I’m not knocking that. But- the inside has little to no appeal and the employees are just about clueless. You ask them questions simply about cream cheese availability and they have no clue. They are so distracted that they won’t even give you back your change… would I go back? Absolutely not. And trust me I love good bagel shops and even travel from Staten Island to queens… this place I guess is good if your some Brooklynite who loves to be obnoxious and claims this is the best place out of the 4 total they tried. I guess you can say this place is the armpit of the south shore. The plus side was it was 9.50 for 3 bagels with cream cheese.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Begals are great, service sucks. Takes you 30 minutes to get your order when busy. And, also takes 30 minutes to get your order when its slow. The staff are always arguing with each other. Just not managed correctly. Shame, because their begals are so
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Egg and Cheese Sandwich
I've always loved Mikey's bagels. Recently the older women who works there is so so so nasty and rude I could not believe it. She was cursing to someone then I got my bagel she was so rude if she does not like her job or people she shouldn't be working there. After dealing with her nasty attitude I will never go back there. It's ashame because this has always been mine as well as my families favorite bagel store.
This is the fourth bagel place I have tried in Staten Island and this is by far my favorite. The bagels have a nice chew and actually have flavor! They aren't small and one with cream cheese enough to fill you up!
Best bagels in NYC. The staff always treats you like family! We love Mikeys Bagels!
Service was Great, had much better bagels on the island.
Good food and Customer Service.
Best bagels in Tottenville!
I've only been here once but the quality, great taste, and friendly customer service/care is of the high enough level in which it guarantees my return to purchase and experience more.They have absolutely fantastically tasty French Toast Bagels.Stop in and give one a try.Toasted with cream cheese!
Restaurantji Recommends
very very good service best breakfast i have ever had, so chocked about the fluffy good pancakes and i will definitely come back and recommend you to visit !!! you won’t regret it!
Great bagels and friendly service. The bagels are always fresh and well prepared. The owner is very friendly and welcoming. Quick service and always delicious thank you ?
This spot opened up when I was going to the middle school down the block and is still my go to when I'm back visiting home, 13 years later. Bagels are always perfect and so are the sandwiches. They renovated not too long ago too so it's very nice and clean inside. Super quick service too.
Delicious bagel and egg sandwich, staff was very friendly and service was quick. Coffee is good too!
They put a new cook on the grill on Father's Day. Waited 15 mins for a single sandwich and had to leave. Other people were waiting before me and still were waiting