Millie's of Staten Island

Best meatballs and happy hour bar menu

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Coal-Fired Pizza, Chargrilled Oysters, Margarita Pie

We decided to stop at Millie’s in Staten Island
( Bricktown) after shopping. We were served by Jason ! He was PHENOMENAL!!! So attentive and friendly! We haven’t experienced service like that in such a long time. We felt so comfortable!!! Thank you Jason 🙏🏼 Food was absolutely delicious : from app to iced espresso at Jason’s recommendation! Absolutely Perfect ! Btwn service ( Jason) and food, we will be going on a regular basis. Menu has so much to choose from and everything looks amazing: not the usual everyday items ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Went today was excited about menu food was cold asked staff for help was giving none. Pretty bummed out thought pizza in Jersey would be good!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Me and my wife went here for date night. We each ordered a drink, which came out on time. We ordered a pizza with no mushrooms, and the veal Milanese with salad. They brought out a pizza with mushrooms on it, and then brought out veal parmesan with linguine, so they messed up both things we ordered. We decided it was all good and we wouldn’t send anything back, but we did tell our waiter. We ordered a second round of drinks around 7:45. Around 8:05, the waiter came back to us finally, and asked if we needed anything else. We said we hadn’t received our drinks. He apologized and said they’d be right out, and I requested the check. He returned with no drinks and only the check. We never got them. Unfortunately they completely messed up 3/4 things we ordered. The food was good but we were disappointed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 1

We have been here 6 times in the last few months. The Food has been pretty good but the service is hit or miss. Just me and my wife, party of two, and if there is a larger table in the room the wait staff will ignore you. If its mostly 2 tops service seems decent, not exactly great but decent. When larger parties are there, your invisible. Had to get up more then once to find who I think is the manager to get our waiter, or to give us the check. One time after the tables seemed re-arranged, a male waiter, young with black curly hair kept banging into our chairs and table. Staff is pretty young and doesn't seem to experienced. Too bad, pizza and salad are very good.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3

Ava our waitress was absolutely amazing. She made sure we were good throughout our whole experience.

Good food and good service

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

The bartenders and wait staff are awesome.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Waitress was fine food was not. Fig and goat cheese pizza very disappointing chix parm did not have authentic taste very commercial food sorry to say

We went for a late lunch on a Sunday and Millie's was bustling. Food and service were exceptional. Shout out to Evangeline. Portions are large enough to share and the fresh mozzarella salad is a must get. Note to non-locals, Millie's is in an isolated neighborhood at the south end of the Staten Island. So you may encounter some regulars peeking over at you—for no other reason than to check out the new folks.

I haven't been here in a while. The food was very good. Amir was there. Very nice man. Will come back.

Highly recommend this place the chicken parm amazing Dolores my waitress fabulous food delicious prices very good atmosphere definitely will be back..

Everything was Phenomenal, Friendly atmosphere!! The staff all came over and made sure you continued to have fresh clean plates, Utensils. From the GM to the waiters & waitress and even the busboys all worked together to make it so pleasant and nice for everyone dining there. I believe other establishments should tske notes from them because this was my second time there and i got to tell you this is the BEST place to go to on Staten Island

No more prix fixe menu was a disappointment. Took a long time before someone came over, but the food was delicious and the server was very nice.

The server was not very attentive to us And she only had one other table.. Would have had a few more drinks.. Our main course came out in a span of over 5 minutes.. mine you it was 3 entree's No the most professional server.. Noise level is a bit loud for a restaurant that was 30% occupied..