Nonna's Pizza Great Kills

Dirty, pizza was burn underneath, looks like oven was not cleaned at all, even though 4 people at the front glued to there phones

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

The pizza is fabulous,BUT, there is nowhere to sit. A few stools. You have to eat it in the car or take it home

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 5

We traveled miles just to eat here because we saw it on a pizza review of the 5 burrows.
Some of the best pizza I've eaten all of my trips through the burrows. I highly recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Some of the best pizza on SI! Staff is always friendly and treats you like family. Whether it’s the bagel store or the pizzeria? They rock!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best place ever!! All the way from VA I was there ever morning for my bagley & coffee & Pizza too next door !!! A very lovely family 😊

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

First time ordering, not impressed. Pizza tasted microwaved, burned edges, very thin crust, too crunchy. Delivery service was quick, very nice delivery staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Didn’t even get to order some kinda racists over here.
To reiterate, I walked into this store and went to look at the QR code on their register and I am then harassed by multiple workers shouting that I am taking a picture of the cashier. Clearly, I’m not welcome, so I step outside and they’re shouting “you don’t want pizza?!?”. They then shouted to their strange friend who was waving around a blue plastic light saber outside, “that guy just took a picture of her” and I am met by the weird stares . The audacity of the manager to say he knows the menu is in front of the register and still have employees harassing potential customers. If you want to be defamed or weird stares by light saber wielding people when you simply want pizza, try this spot I guess. I can only assume this has something to do with my race or because I didn’t wish to speak with people who behave so unprofessionally.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

I stopped by to check the menu and scanned their QR code near the register. I didn’t talk to anyone or take any photos, yet a staff member suddenly accused me of photographing the cashier. I thought it was a joke at first, but it wasn’t. Even after I left, they kept repeating the false claim to customers and people outside. The experience felt racially motivated and very unprofessional.

One of the better Pizzerias in Staten Island...

Nonnas has the best pizza on Staten Island

Nonna’s Pizzeria is a standout, and a big part of that is thanks to Franny and his team. He’s warm, welcoming, and friendly. From the moment you walk in, you feel like family!

They offer every kind of slice you can imagine, and everything I tried was fantastic. I had the vodka slice, a deep dish pepperoni, and ordered the white clam pie - which I’ve never seen offered anywhere else. It’s absolutely incredible: savory, lemony, and full of flavor.

On top of that, I highly recommend checking out their bagel store next door, freshly baked bagels every morning, and just as impressive as the pizza.

Nonna’s is a hidden gem that I’m so glad I found, and I’m already planning to make it a part of my weekly routine. Whether you’re picking up, ordering out, or grabbing a slice to go, don’t miss out on this place.

Food is horrible...

Best pizza ever!!!

I never leave reviews but I feel it’s necessary. Ordered the fried calamari and it’s fishy, frozen and literally not chewable. You can choke attempting to eat it. Their pizza is thin but not in a good way — like air. Overpriced for absolute junk!

I ordered a regular slice ; it was so thin I'm STILL in shock .. if u don't believe me go try it for urself. I also ordered a white slice that appeared to have some other meat on there ; Also very thin and little ricotta. It seems best to just order some ziti a bigger meal to get ur moneys worth. ( how do u skimp on flour smh )