Nonna's Pizza Great Kills

27 Brower Ct, Staten Island
(718) 227-8108

Recent Reviews

Lydia C.

This place is waaaaaaay overpriced. I was driving by and decided to try it. This was my first and last time. I ordered a half pepperoni pie, knots, mozz stix and 20 oz soda. $46. WHAT??? My brother owns and pizzeria. His price wouldn't been around $33. The pie alone was $22.50. I could get the same pie elsewhere for $18-19. 6 garlic knots for $5 - again what? They only gave me 4, they were TINY and had way too much garlic and not much else for seasoning. The mozz stix were your run of the mill frozen mozzarella sticks. Nothing to rave about. I think they were $13.95. Some people may say well if the food is good then it's worth the price. It was just decent. The crust on the pie had good flavor but the sauce was overly sweet. And the pie was small. It was def not a standard size large pie. I would def never go back and wouldn't recommend this place to anyone. Village Maria is a block away. Their pizza is much better and definitely priced better.

Jennifer Bonner

Nonna’s customer service is outstanding. Ordered two pies for my classroom and one was a little too well done for the kids liking. I called and Nonna’s sent us two pies when they didn’t have to. The delivery was quick and the pizzas were delicious. Thank you!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brendan McCool

Great atmosphere. Crispy pizza. Elite customer

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kellie Armendariz

Man that's good pizza!! The dough the sauce the cheese! All top notch ??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza, Sicilian Slice, Regular Slice

Justin Ragozzino

Great pizza. Awesome staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Julian Ramos

Great pizza fast

Food: 5

Service: 4

Nicole Z.

Pizza had no taste was so thin isn't fell apart and rice ball was as horrible. Much better pizza places out there

Sam C.

My family decided to try this pizzeria and happy that we did. The sauce was too sweet for me but the crust was outstanding. Service and ambience were good. Will definitely be there again.

Matthew C.

Full disclosure...We ordered a traditional cheese pizza for pickup and live roughly 10 minutes away. This pizza was truly outstanding for what it offers. The crust was the deciding factor for me...I haven't had a beautiful crust like that since New Haven, Connecticut. The sauce was on the sweet side and the cheese was fairly light. I am so happy I tried this pizzeria & I cannot wait to come back.

julia koniosis

Have been eating their pizza since they opened. Everything has gone down in quality. I’m done

Gee G.

Nonna,s on page ave. Big disappointment. Pizza was burnt cold and the sauce was too sweet. Never again

Mourad Agamy

Make sure you double check your pie before you leave the pizzeria. I ordered online an old fashion 18 in pie that I've gotten dozens of times before and ended with regular 16 pie. I called and asked what happened and they said they don't make the old fashion pie anymore. Very confusing and I feel like I was lied to ended up paying more for something I didn't want.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Helen K.

Love this!! Vodka pie was the best thing i have ever eaten. The delivery was fast and theh were polite at the door.

kod jason

Great pizza .great service.hands down...should try it....you wont regret it.....(interesting oven)

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buratta Slice, Regular Slice

Tara Frawley

I ordered pizza from here last night because I used to love their food however last night the pizza was awful!! I asked for it thin and well done and it was neither it looks like a blind person made my pie and the cheese was basically off the

Food: 1

Load More