I just placed an order for dinner for the family, hands down the best panini‘s we’ve ever eaten in our lives! Amazing food! Thank you Palermo pizza!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steven N
Ordered here last week for a family dinner, got a variety of entrees from pizza, salad, soup and sandwiches. Everything was hot and fresh, I would definitely go back and try some of their pasta and pizza options. If you need a reliable quick bite so far this pizzeria seems like the go to in the area. Will be visiting again soon thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joseph
Decent neighborhood pizza place. Avoid their L&B slice. It looks good, but isn’t.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
Danielle La Massa
BUGS IN MY FOOD ! if i could give no stars i would i had an order of 2 salad slices a franchese slice and 2 regular slices and there was 2 huge black bugs and the owner said she would refund me for one piece when i’m telling her o don’t know which slice it actually came from and she’s beyond nasty and rude and said we should call the health department i said i don’t want any of this food because i don’t know what bug it is im not trying to get sick and the way she’s treating me is insane it won’t allow me to add videos to show the other bugs. DO NOT EAT HERE THEY ARE SO MEAN AND RUDE & not clean it looks like that bug was marinated. 35$ for 5 slices of pizza and im treated like a dirtbag with the owner telling me not to come back when it’s evident they have a bug infestation and are taking it out on me it’s not fair it’s not okay to be treated the way i was just treated & i recorded the entire phone call so if anyone wants to hear it i’m sure you’ll all be mortified with the disservice and disrespect while taking no accountability for their actions. what a shame. i wouldn’t come back just because of the way i was treated SHE YELLED AT ME AT THE TOP OF HER LUNGS. i’m so embarrassed and hurt by her words
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Debora Morale
My go to pizzeria! Love the pizza.
Patrick Rooney
They have some great pizza here and I had one of the best sausage Parmesan heroes I’ve ever had in my life ! I just updated my review. I’m sitting with one of the best plates of calamari I’ve ever had It’s hard to get this right and Angelica just hit another home run but she hit the ball out of the park with this one !!!! October 3 2025 tried the mussels and linguine a pallet extravaganza, unbelievable sauce probably the best I’ve ever had ! I have a lot of reviews on Google but I have to keep updating this one because it just keeps getting better and better this was an absolutely amazing meal !!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nikki Marie
I got garlic bread. It was raw garlic & not toasted or anything. the worst garlic bread I've ever had,😩
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Edward Deighan
Had the chicken francese with fresh mozzarella and artichokes panini- wow. Delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
SINYDJS
This is a great spot on Staten Island If you like old school 70s-80s brooklyn style pizza this is in my opinion one of the best spots on the Island
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Diana M.
Upside down slices are great. Service is awesome and their salads are delicious too!
Food was cold staff didn’t care. Thought Jersey pizza would be a slam dunk guess the knicks Must be in town!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
surgical reconstruction
Just did my 3rd catering order from Palermo’s on Page Ave, Staten Island. The food is ridiculous. Everytime, my guests raved over the food. Did 3 foot hero’s of chicken cutlet with vodka sauce and their grilled chicken with pesto. The Frutta di Mar is a must have. There’s so much succulent seafood in that dish that they have to Saran Wrap it, for fear it’ll pop out. First time I’ve ever found myself eating Caesar's Salad like I’m eating a steak. Outrageously delicious. One gripe - no meat dishes for catering. Was hoping for a steak pizzaiola. I get it, keeping steak on the menu is expensive, and may not be worth it business wise. But I could only imagine how delicious a steak pizzaiola would be if you made it! This place is by far the best to cater from on the south shore….and I’ve ordered from so many. Really amazing food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Deana Conner
An hour and a half for delivery on a Tuesday and the pizza was not hot. This isnt the first time. You call and get the standard answer. Too many pizzerias on Staten Island to be waiting this long from a place thats 10 minutes away and has average pizza.
I just placed an order for dinner for the family, hands down the best panini‘s we’ve ever eaten in our lives! Amazing food! Thank you Palermo pizza!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered here last week for a family dinner, got a variety of entrees from pizza, salad, soup and sandwiches. Everything was hot and fresh, I would definitely go back and try some of their pasta and pizza options. If you need a reliable quick bite so far this pizzeria seems like the go to in the area. Will be visiting again soon thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Decent neighborhood pizza place. Avoid their L&B slice. It looks good, but isn’t.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
BUGS IN MY FOOD ! if i could give no stars i would i had an order of 2 salad slices a franchese slice and 2 regular slices and there was 2 huge black bugs and the owner said she would refund me for one piece when i’m telling her o don’t know which slice it actually came from and she’s beyond nasty and rude and said we should call the health department i said i don’t want any of this food because i don’t know what bug it is im not trying to get sick and the way she’s treating me is insane it won’t allow me to add videos to show the other bugs. DO NOT EAT HERE THEY ARE SO MEAN AND RUDE & not clean it looks like that bug was marinated. 35$ for 5 slices of pizza and im treated like a dirtbag with the owner telling me not to come back when it’s evident they have a bug infestation and are taking it out on me it’s not fair it’s not okay to be treated the way i was just treated & i recorded the entire phone call so if anyone wants to hear it i’m sure you’ll all be mortified with the disservice and disrespect while taking no accountability for their actions. what a shame. i wouldn’t come back just because of the way i was treated SHE YELLED AT ME AT THE TOP OF HER LUNGS. i’m so embarrassed and hurt by her words
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
My go to pizzeria! Love the pizza.
They have some great pizza here and I had one of the best sausage Parmesan heroes I’ve ever had in my life ! I just updated my review. I’m sitting with one of the best plates of calamari I’ve ever had It’s hard to get this right and Angelica just hit another home run but she hit the ball out of the park with this one !!!! October 3 2025 tried the mussels and linguine a pallet extravaganza, unbelievable sauce probably the best I’ve ever had ! I have a lot of reviews on Google but I have to keep updating this one because it just keeps getting better and better this was an absolutely amazing meal !!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I got garlic bread. It was raw garlic & not toasted or anything. the worst garlic bread I've ever had,😩
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Had the chicken francese with fresh mozzarella and artichokes panini- wow. Delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is a great spot on Staten Island If you like old school 70s-80s brooklyn style pizza this is in my opinion one of the best spots on the Island
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Upside down slices are great. Service is awesome and their salads are delicious too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Food was cold staff didn’t care. Thought Jersey pizza would be a slam dunk guess the knicks
Must be in town!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Just did my 3rd catering order from Palermo’s on Page Ave, Staten Island. The food is ridiculous. Everytime, my guests raved over the food. Did 3 foot hero’s of chicken cutlet with vodka sauce and their grilled chicken with pesto. The Frutta di Mar is a must have. There’s so much succulent seafood in that dish that they have to Saran Wrap it, for fear it’ll pop out. First time I’ve ever found myself eating Caesar's Salad like I’m eating a steak. Outrageously delicious.
One gripe - no meat dishes for catering. Was hoping for a steak pizzaiola. I get it, keeping steak on the menu is expensive, and may not be worth it business wise. But I could only imagine how delicious a steak pizzaiola would be if you made it! This place is by far the best to cater from on the south shore….and I’ve ordered from so many. Really amazing food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
An hour and a half for delivery on a Tuesday and the pizza was not hot. This isnt the first time. You call and get the standard answer. Too many pizzerias on Staten Island to be waiting this long from a place thats 10 minutes away and has average pizza.
Food is amazing quality in every bite always
Delicious
Loading...