Pastry Lovers Choice

370 Van Duzer St, Staten Island
(917) 830-0146

Recent Reviews

Antoinnette Donegan

All the desserts and food are super yummy. And great customer service

Ava S. Johnson

Great food with great customers service and if you love coffee this is the place that won’t disappoint!

Michelle L.

We were at The Coupe across the street and we said to the bartender we really wanted cookies, but the Coupe doesn't serve dessert. He then unbeknown to us walked across the street to Pastry Lovers Choice and brought us back some of their chocolate chip cookies and brownies free of charge. We tried going inot o the shop first but their gate was partially down. The cookies and brownies were some of thee best I ever had. I would definitely make a stop there for some sweets in the future.

Jasi Robinson

The place is very clean and the service was excellent. I enjoyed the food very much. Please consider coming here for food especially on a Sunday.

Niccose S.

Forget the fact I waited OVER AN HOUR AND HALF FOR DELIVERY. I ordered chicken and waffles, shrimp and grits for Sunday brunch. WORST EXPERIENCE EVER! The chicken had BLOOD in it. COMPLETELY DISGUSTING! Waffles was soggy and seemed to be made with some weird custard batter. Grits was okay, but the SHRIMPS TASTED LIKE MOP WATER Called for a refund and received every excuse in the book from OWNER SAHERA THREATS. Blamed the delivery guy for waffles being soggy, also claimed chicken was checked prior to plating, but obviously not well enough because chicken was undercooked. I guess this is what I get ordering food from a pastry shop. Waste of my time and money. First and last time doing business with them.

Sherri Hunt

Great prices, great vibe, great service, great people. I always have a great time when I go. Even greater experience seeing my family get treated with such great service. Love it <3

Jason Muniz

I just visited this place for the first time yesterday and i really enjoyed my visit. The shop is clean and has a few tables to sit down and enjoy your coffee/pastry. All of the reviewers that have said that they have the best apple turnovers are absolutely right! I'll definitely be back to try some of their other offerings.

Maggie Howard

Great place great fellowship

Theresa Weick-Jacaruso

Where do I even begin?!... From start to finish Sahera was an absolute professional, worked with me to design the perfect cake which was delicious, as well as the cookies and the prices are on point. I can't say enough good things. I've made a new friend. She is delightful and goes out of her way for you. My party was next door from her bakery so she brought it right over when we were ready. All the guests loved it! I will only go to her from now on for all my party needs.. I can't wait to try her food too! Shop local and support small business owners

Mariana Howard

Not only does this place have great coffee and sweets, the FOOD is incredible! If you love real Southern-style dishes, do NOT sleep on this place. Creamy shrimp & grits with cheese and seasoned fried chicken and waffles are the truth! Better get in on this before word gets out about Sunday brunch and there's a line waiting to get in!

Evelyn Obertnaya

I just went there for the first time. They have the best apple turnovers ever.

Mary Ellen Strype- Hansen

Delicious Brunch and awesome staff! Cute and cozy

theo pellon

Persuasion and ingredients matter at is bakery like no other.

Jasmine Rodriguez

Omg their cupcakes where so delicious. A little over pricey for 6 cupcakes but they where so delicious.

Wilhelmina Sparrow

The owner is rude and talks bad about her customers and tells their children bad things about the parents that are untrue and is fighting for custody in family for one of her customers children after destroying the family by a encouraging the oldest daughter to have an inappropriate relationship with the community pastor who is known to be a possible pedefiler

Load More