Sal & Lloyd's Pizza Place

BEING A PATRON FOR BOTH Sal AND HIS SON, WHAT ELSE CAN i SAY FOREVER BEST PIZZA IN S.I., NY, HANDS DOWN !

Best pizza in S.I.

Best pizza place on the island!! The service is outstanding and the dinner entrees are amazing! They give you so much for a great price and it’s so so delicious! It’s just like homemade! These guys are genuine and really treat you like you’ve been a neighborhood friend for a long time especially Rosario. Good people with personality! You won’t be disappointed.

It would’ve been good if it wasn’t like eating pizza off of a wet paper towel. Very floppy, very undercooked.
The stuff on the pizza was good, just too soggy.

The best pizza and the best ravioli ever and price is reasonable

Caesar salad came with red onions tomatoes olives cucumbers with a vinaigrette. Don’t know who needs to hear this but fresh tomato shouldn’t be on a pizza.

Never posted a score like this for a pizzeria.
I'm sorry, but horrible.
The Sicilian pie was not of fresh dough. Couldn't be, it was too thin, too heavy, too doughy. Sauce had no flavor. It was a if the dough had been sitting a long time or they reheated a pie that was already made earlier. On top of that, they forgot to add the toppings that I had ordered online for $4, which also makes me think it was already made.
Hot multiple sandwiches only had the filling in the middle, zero on either end of the sandwich, again no flavor at all.
Place needs a reno bad.
I went here for the first time due to its close location to where I was visiting. I was embarrassed when we sat to eat with my relatives.
Again, I'm sorry, but very disappointing.

101% Traditional NYC Pizza. I have been going here for 30 years, and the only difference is the street fighter arcade game is missing. He makes this Sicilian eggplant pizza with fried eggplant medallions, ricotta and mozzarella.

Vegetarian options: Makes a ton of meatless pizza options with all sorts of vegetables. The Sicilian Eggplant pizza is unreal.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza

Burned pizza and buffalo wings. I dont know why the seller would sell this to a customer. The wings were especially not edible and I threw them away. Ruined family dinner. First time and last time

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

The workers were nice and kind. The pizza was also great.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

I grew up in Brooklyn all my life and ate at the best pizzerias around back in the day Mamma Mia's on Bath ave New born on stillwell ave, Lennys on 86street, Da vinci and on18th ave But for Staten Island this is the best pizza on the Island no Joke! I have tried them all and hands down this is the best Napolitan style pizza (round slice) on the Island. The chesse , the sauce, and the crust this pizza has it all . This is the real deal Round slice.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

just ordered some takeout for delivery , arrived fast , hot and most of all delicious . I ordered a Shrimp arm hero with a cheese calzone. Just had the Shrimp part it was amazing the sauce and shrimps could be tasted with the bread. The sauce was very good not overwhelming trying to coverup like most places and the bread was toasted to perfection.b Thank you guys look forward to making this my spot to eat for my Italian fix. Ty

Food: 5

Service: 5

The best. Love this place and the staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best pizza on staten island hands down..Loif

Great pizza place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5