Sammi made us the most stunning and delicious cake. She was easy to work with, responded in a timely manner, and delivered the cake on-time. The photo speaks for itself - we will be getting all out future cakes from Sammi!
Andrea Armitage Connors
The chocolate chip cookie that I sampled at the New Dorp Restaurant Crawl was the best I have ever had! Can't wait to get more!
Al Lugo
Sammi did a great job with our wedding cupcakes. All the guests loved them.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jineen ibrahim
Will not get custom cakes from anywhere else! Every flavor I’ve tried so far has been delicious and Sammi is very reasonably priced!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Margo Hamner
I used Sammi Sweetz for my daughter's Bridal Shower dessert table and it was an excellent experience. Sam was very attentive. She checked in with me several times to check on colors and flavors. When the order arrived everything was beautiful and best of all the desserts were absolutely delicious. I will use Sammi Sweetz for all my dessert needs going forward!
Jenna Musumeci
Sammi has been my go-to cake baker for over two years now, and each time I’m in awe of how beautiful (and delicious…) her cakes are. She’s truly the best!
Tervina Eskander
Sammi made us a beautiful Baptism cake. it was delicious and our guests were very happy.
Rosalie Almonte Castillo
This bakery offers a heavenly selection of sweets, cakes, and an exceptional level of customer service. They were more than happy to accommodate special requests and went above and beyond to ensure that I was happy. Whether you're looking for a treat for yourself or a show-stopping cake for a special occasion, this bakery is sure to exceed your expectations. Their dedication to quality, attention to detail, and outstanding customer service make it a truly exceptional establishment.
Dung Du
Great muffins. Very nice people working there. Will definitely go again.
Alex Rybakov
The absolute best bakery on the island. So much so that they run out of stuff before I can make it there. Even the stuff that is not sold out is amazing!
Sammi made us a beautiful engagement party cake and dessert tables. Everything was absolutely delicious. Our guests were very impressed. Thank you for helping us make our day so special!
Rose Ghiz
Amazing place staff is amazing and Samantha the owner sat with me for a long time to go over details for an event. The desserts are fresh and delicious
Donny DFINE
This is my go to spot right here. Everything is delicious and fresh. Customer service on point. Class act ??
G G
She’s always late, never on time for her orders. Quality is disappointing.
cathy balsamo
I have had the pleasure of designing each of my family's cakes for over 7 years now with Samantha. Whether it be a birthday, retirement, anniversary, etc., the cake is a showstopper! I have had the macaroons which are "the best" my daughter and friends have ever had, cupcakes, pignoli cookies (plate always empty!) as well as other holiday-themed favorites from the storefront. Samantha's talent in cake decorating goes beyond saying. You will see the perfection on every flower, gorgeous snowflakes gingerbreads, & attention to detail on the trimming. I have ordered Naked Strawberry shortcake, chocolate peanut butter filled , cannoli filling, the list goes on. A trip to this storefront will not disappoint. I wish her all the best in her new venture!
Sammi made us the most stunning and delicious cake. She was easy to work with, responded in a timely manner, and delivered the cake on-time. The photo speaks for itself - we will be getting all out future cakes from Sammi!
The chocolate chip cookie that I sampled at the New Dorp Restaurant Crawl was the best I have ever had! Can't wait to get more!
Sammi did a great job with our wedding cupcakes. All the guests loved them.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Will not get custom cakes from anywhere else! Every flavor I’ve tried so far has been delicious and Sammi is very reasonably priced!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
I used Sammi Sweetz for my daughter's Bridal Shower dessert table and it was an excellent experience. Sam was very attentive. She checked in with me several times to check on colors and flavors. When the order arrived everything was beautiful and best of all the desserts were absolutely delicious. I will use Sammi Sweetz for all my dessert needs going forward!
Sammi has been my go-to cake baker for over two years now, and each time I’m in awe of how beautiful (and delicious…) her cakes are. She’s truly the best!
Sammi made us a beautiful Baptism cake. it was delicious and our guests were very happy.
This bakery offers a heavenly selection of sweets, cakes, and an exceptional level of customer service. They were more than happy to accommodate special requests and went above and beyond to ensure that I was happy. Whether you're looking for a treat for yourself or a show-stopping cake for a special occasion, this bakery is sure to exceed your expectations. Their dedication to quality, attention to detail, and outstanding customer service make it a truly exceptional establishment.
Great muffins. Very nice people working there. Will definitely go again.
The absolute best bakery on the island. So much so that they run out of stuff before I can make it there. Even the stuff that is not sold out is amazing!
Restaurantji Recommends
Sammi made us a beautiful engagement party cake and dessert tables. Everything was absolutely delicious. Our guests were very impressed. Thank you for helping us make our day so special!
Amazing place staff is amazing and Samantha the owner sat with me for a long time to go over details for an event. The desserts are fresh and delicious
This is my go to spot right here. Everything is delicious and fresh. Customer service on point. Class act ??
She’s always late, never on time for her orders. Quality is disappointing.
I have had the pleasure of designing each of my family's cakes for over 7 years now with Samantha. Whether it be a birthday, retirement, anniversary, etc., the cake is a showstopper! I have had the macaroons which are "the best" my daughter and friends have ever had, cupcakes, pignoli cookies (plate always empty!) as well as other holiday-themed favorites from the storefront. Samantha's talent in cake decorating goes beyond saying. You will see the perfection on every flower, gorgeous snowflakes gingerbreads, & attention to detail on the trimming. I have ordered Naked Strawberry shortcake, chocolate peanut butter filled , cannoli filling, the list goes on. A trip to this storefront will not disappoint. I wish her all the best in her new venture!
Loading...