Went to celebrate a Birthday and had a disappointing experience. 3 of our 4 entrees were served and our server said nothing of the 4th entree. We waited quite a while until finally asking our server who replied “yes, it’s coming. I put all the orders in at the same time. We just have to wait”. There was never an apology and we waited at least 15 minutes for the final entree to be served. There were only 4 other tables so it was not because it was busy. Then, when it was time for the check, there was another issue to which we waited a long time for the credit card receipt. The manager had to print the receipt which took a some time. Once he was done, he left it for our server to bring back to us instead of walking it over. He already knew there were multiple issues so this sort of upset me more than the earlier issues. A good manager would have walked the receipt over and apologized for the multiple issues. The food was good, as always, but the experience tonight sadly will have me choose a different restaurant next time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 2
mariam Si
Placed an order and went to pick it up, but it was mistakenly given to another customer. I had to wait for a new order to be prepared. Unfortunately, the server, Amanda, seemed unbothered, did not apologize, and made no effort to offer a discount or anything to address the inconvenience.
When I finally received the food, the pizza was excellent as usual—10/10. On the bright side, the male server who greeted us and the chef were both kind and professional. The atmosphere was beautiful, but the service from Amanda was disappointing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
B T
That was not Neapolitan. That was jar sauce on bread.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
RJ
Great pizza, very good menu, lots of great Italian classics. Very good gluten free options.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm, Penne Alla Vodka
Monica Guevara
My little treat on a good or bad day is the spicy vodka pie ?. My favorite pizza on the island.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sonia De la cruz
Best pizza in Staten Island. Very good service. Good atmosphere. Angelina was very helpful since me and my family sitdown. Highly recommended
Logan Kaczmarek
Used to be a good place for quality pizza. A year ago a pizza was $19.00 fast forward to fall of 2024 the exact same pizza is $28.00. I'm not good at math but a $9 increase over the span of 12 months is radical and has absolutely drove my business elsewhere. ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Round House White Pie
J G
I’ve been here in the past & absolutely loved it. My view completely changed after my latest visit this evening. Firstly, the host/waitress nodded to the table, once sat, it took 20 minutes to get tap water served. The fried artichokes were totally bland & the Morty pizza was as well. There was very little pesto & the Mortadella tasted closer to Oscar Meyer Bologna. Don’t even get me started on the martini .. Will NOT be back.
Bob Dole
Not your traditional NYC pizzeria, it's kind of a hybrid of New York style pizza combined with what you'd find in Naples. The pizza here is phenomenal with some great combinations like the pep in your step pizza (which I'd highly recommend if you like spicy), but even the plain cheese pizza is great on it's own.
They also offer other upscale food options that you don't typically get from a neighborhood pizzeria, as well as a full bar and great cocktails. There's a level of quality they're going for and it shows in the final product, this place is even listed in the Michelin Guide as a recommended place to eat and the honor was well deserved.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm, Fried Calamari
Robert Stubblefield
Jessica was a smokin hot waitress who was so friendly. We were served top tier pizza and drinks everytime! We had such a great time we had to come back every day during our stay. The service was amazing, we felt like family even while a thousand miles away from home. The food was great and each day we tried a different pizza. Each one had a special touch and was absolutely delicious! We tried all their pizzas and ate each one with a fork they were so fresh and delectable. Can’t recommend enough. Best staff, best owner, best pizza, best environment!
Pasta was al dente, pizza was piping hot and delicious, Italian draft beer was the icing on the cake!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Raheim Costa
EVERYTHING WAS INCREDIBLE. I have never had pizza so good or such amazing service. Tanja, Bridget, Erica, Amanda, Ang, Jess, and Annie were so incredibly detail oriented and beautiful. Please someone give these incredible ladies A RAISE!! They deserve the world.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patricia Nordin
Our first time here was ok. Our Calamari appetizer was good, but my golden beet salad was not great. The mix was off tasting, and the olive oil used was overpowering. I should have sent it back . But powered through it. We ordered a round pizza and got the large square instead( more expensive) which at that point was too late to send back, as it would have been a long wait for what we originally ordered. Not to make a fuss, we kept it but ate all but 4 slices. A waste. Not returning.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Marina Bluv
We love this pizza place. Pizza is delicious each time. Service can be a bit better. We’ve been here a few times and it takes a while to even get menus. Otherwise no complaints.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Round House White Pie, Olivia Pizza, The Jimmy Pizza
Ian Sinclair
Always an incredible meal at Seppe. Amazing pizza, great drinks and excellent service.
Went to celebrate a Birthday and had a disappointing experience. 3 of our 4 entrees were served and our server said nothing of the 4th entree. We waited quite a while until finally asking our server who replied “yes, it’s coming. I put all the orders in at the same time. We just have to wait”. There was never an apology and we waited at least 15 minutes for the final entree to be served. There were only 4 other tables so it was not because it was busy. Then, when it was time for the check, there was another issue to which we waited a long time for the credit card receipt. The manager had to print the receipt which took a some time. Once he was done, he left it for our server to bring back to us instead of walking it over. He already knew there were multiple issues so this sort of upset me more than the earlier issues. A good manager would have walked the receipt over and apologized for the multiple issues. The food was good, as always, but the experience tonight sadly will have me choose a different restaurant next time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 2
Placed an order and went to pick it up, but it was mistakenly given to another customer. I had to wait for a new order to be prepared. Unfortunately, the server, Amanda, seemed unbothered, did not apologize, and made no effort to offer a discount or anything to address the inconvenience.
When I finally received the food, the pizza was excellent as usual—10/10. On the bright side, the male server who greeted us and the chef were both kind and professional. The atmosphere was beautiful, but the service from Amanda was disappointing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
That was not Neapolitan. That was jar sauce on bread.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Great pizza, very good menu, lots of great Italian classics. Very good gluten free options.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm, Penne Alla Vodka
My little treat on a good or bad day is the spicy vodka pie ?. My favorite pizza on the island.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza in Staten Island. Very good service. Good atmosphere.
Angelina was very helpful since me and my family sitdown. Highly recommended
Used to be a good place for quality pizza. A year ago a pizza was $19.00 fast forward to fall of 2024 the exact same pizza is $28.00. I'm not good at math but a $9 increase over the span of 12 months is radical and has absolutely drove my business elsewhere. ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Round House White Pie
I’ve been here in the past & absolutely loved it. My view completely changed after my latest visit this evening. Firstly, the host/waitress nodded to the table, once sat, it took 20 minutes to get tap water served. The fried artichokes were totally bland & the Morty pizza was as well. There was very little pesto & the Mortadella tasted closer to Oscar Meyer Bologna. Don’t even get me started on the martini .. Will NOT be back.
Not your traditional NYC pizzeria, it's kind of a hybrid of New York style pizza combined with what you'd find in Naples. The pizza here is phenomenal with some great combinations like the pep in your step pizza (which I'd highly recommend if you like spicy), but even the plain cheese pizza is great on it's own.
They also offer other upscale food options that you don't typically get from a neighborhood pizzeria, as well as a full bar and great cocktails. There's a level of quality they're going for and it shows in the final product, this place is even listed in the Michelin Guide as a recommended place to eat and the honor was well deserved.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm, Fried Calamari
Jessica was a smokin hot waitress who was so friendly. We were served top tier pizza and drinks everytime! We had such a great time we had to come back every day during our stay. The service was amazing, we felt like family even while a thousand miles away from home. The food was great and each day we tried a different pizza. Each one had a special touch and was absolutely delicious! We tried all their pizzas and ate each one with a fork they were so fresh and delectable. Can’t recommend enough. Best staff, best owner, best pizza, best environment!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pep in Your Step Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Pasta was al dente, pizza was piping hot and delicious, Italian draft beer was the icing on the cake!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
EVERYTHING WAS INCREDIBLE. I have never had pizza so good or such amazing service. Tanja, Bridget, Erica, Amanda, Ang, Jess, and Annie were so incredibly detail oriented and beautiful. Please someone give these incredible ladies A RAISE!! They deserve the world.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our first time here was ok.
Our Calamari appetizer was good, but my golden beet salad was not great. The mix was off tasting, and the olive oil used was overpowering. I should have sent it back . But powered through it.
We ordered a round pizza and got the large square instead( more expensive) which at that point was too late to send back, as it would have been a long wait for what we originally ordered. Not to make a fuss, we kept it but ate all but 4 slices. A waste.
Not returning.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
We love this pizza place. Pizza is delicious each time. Service can be a bit better. We’ve been here a few times and it takes a while to even get menus. Otherwise no complaints.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Round House White Pie, Olivia Pizza, The Jimmy Pizza
Always an incredible meal at Seppe. Amazing pizza, great drinks and excellent service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...