I ordered a Vegan Cheese Veggie pie which was absolutely amazing! My Aunt, my Mom and I agree that it is the best pizza on Staten Island! We give it 5 stars! We highly recommend this pizzeria restaurant 💚🌱🤩🍕
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Fina
I’ve been going to Sunset Pizza for just over 40 years now For an excellent slice, that is always consistent, All their other foods Or also amongst the best With the one stand out being in my opinion, there sausage and pepper roll. Amongst the best best I’ve ever had!. There is zero reason for me to wanna go anywhere else
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
April
Sunset is one of the many local pizzeria’s in our area, but the hospitality shown makes them stand out from all the others. It’s more than being friendly and having great customer service, you feel like part of the family, a very welcoming atmosphere. Running a neighborhood business the way I remember it growing up. I had gone to other pizzeria’s in the area regularly and I didn’t feel my business was appreciated, however Sunset doesn’t lack appreciation. They even called their customers this holiday season to share their catering specials. We are loyal customers and will continue to visit Sunset and order in from them. Thank you for keeping that old school feel and showing your customers you appreciate them.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patrick Miller
Pizza is amazing and I really love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mathew Kenny
Lovely place and great service and food was amazing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
SavageGenetx
Terrific food and the staff and owner are personable and kind!! We need more places like this
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tommy Esposito
Vito has been the best for the last 40+ years great food great environment
Dawn Damato
I went here Wednesday around 6pm. My first time here. Ordered the Cesar salad, a square slice and a regular slice. They had 1 old square slice left. I took it. The regular slice wasn’t even warmed up. I was disappointed with the Cesar salad. The romaine lettuce is not chopped small. A glob of dressing is placed in the center of the salad. Not mixed in. I tried the regular slice today, it was not good. I threw the square slice out. I’m sorry to the owners. However, I expected better food. No napkins or plastic utensils were given.
George Costanza
I never leave reviews but don’t waste your money. Vodka pie sucked. Barely any sauce it was so dry. Live maybe 5 min away and it came ice cold. Plenty of other better choices in same area.
Roman Khinich
We catered a party at my house and the food was delicious. Everyone at the party said it was the best pizza and hero’s on the island.
One day after work this week I decided to stop by my local pizza place that I haven't been to in a long time. I was talking to an old friend of mine and she was telling me that this pizza place has gone down hill as far as food quality and service.I didn't want to believe that so I had to try it out for myself. I was truly disappointed in the quality I felt as if it wasn't worth what they were charging me. Their prices have skyrocketed as well. I can also definitely agree with another review about the man who is making the food wasn't sanitary at all.One last thing Id like to say is I would appreciate reading actual responses from the owner instead of AI generated.
R B.
I go to this place once in awhile the pizza is good the rolls are good. Today what I did not like to see was the guy wearing black shirt with a picture on it wearing burgundy shorts and a black hat and beard making a pizza pie and picking at it and eating from it while he's making the food. Also touching his lower area maybe his shorts string and then touching the pie again and then eating from it. Not very sanitary.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Joseph Cola
I’ve been going to this pizzeria for many years now. I used to enjoy going here until it felt like I was getting ripped off. I believe they make up prices on a daily basis. Because I ordered a chicken parm hero last week in person, and it was 14 dollars. Then just yesterday I ordered one again but this time over the phone, and it was Apparently $15.50 I did not place that order! I check there website and Menu in the store, and it says 14 dollars so the following day I go in person and order and it’s back to 14 dollars this isn’t the first time something like this has happened to me here. They do the same thing when it comes to getting a side dressing. Some days it’s 50 cents then others it’s a dollar. It’s just unfortunate because I’ve been going here for years, and it’s my local pizzeria, and it no longer feels family like(It hasn’t for the past year now). I Strongly believe this is due to employees, not being properly trained and the constant workers that go through this place. The food is usually a hit or miss. I also believe this is because theres always someone new making and preparing the food it when I look behind the counter.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
mr con
Wings were undercooked had a really bad texture with pizza was amazing and service was great. The wings are very dry too.
I ordered a Vegan Cheese Veggie pie which was absolutely amazing! My Aunt, my Mom and I agree that it is the best pizza on Staten Island! We give it 5 stars! We highly recommend this pizzeria restaurant
💚🌱🤩🍕
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’ve been going to Sunset Pizza for just over 40 years now
For an excellent slice, that is always consistent,
All their other foods Or also amongst the best
With the one stand out being in my opinion, there sausage and pepper roll. Amongst the best best I’ve ever had!.
There is zero reason for me to wanna go anywhere else
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sunset is one of the many local pizzeria’s in our area, but the hospitality shown makes them stand out from all the others. It’s more than being friendly and having great customer service, you feel like part of the family, a very welcoming atmosphere. Running a neighborhood business the way I remember it growing up. I had gone to other pizzeria’s in the area regularly and I didn’t feel my business was appreciated, however Sunset doesn’t lack appreciation. They even called their customers this holiday season to share their catering specials. We are loyal customers and will continue to visit Sunset and order in from them. Thank you for keeping that old school feel and showing your customers you appreciate them.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is amazing and I really love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lovely place and great service and food was amazing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terrific food and the staff and owner are personable and kind!! We need more places like this
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vito has been the best for the last 40+ years great food great environment
I went here Wednesday around 6pm. My first time here. Ordered the Cesar salad, a square slice and a regular slice. They had 1 old square slice left. I took it. The regular slice wasn’t even warmed up. I was disappointed with the Cesar salad. The romaine lettuce is not chopped small. A glob of dressing is placed in the center of the salad. Not mixed in. I tried the regular slice today, it was not good. I threw the square slice out. I’m sorry to the owners. However, I expected better food. No napkins or plastic utensils were given.
I never leave reviews but don’t waste your money. Vodka pie sucked. Barely any sauce it was so dry. Live maybe 5 min away and it came ice cold. Plenty of other better choices in same area.
We catered a party at my house and the food was delicious. Everyone at the party said it was the best pizza and hero’s on the island.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great people, great food
One day after work this week I decided to stop by my local pizza place that I haven't been to in a long time. I was talking to an old friend of mine and she was telling me that this pizza place has gone down hill as far as food quality and service.I didn't want to believe that so I had to try it out for myself. I was truly disappointed in the quality I felt as if it wasn't worth what they
were charging me. Their prices have skyrocketed as well. I can also definitely agree with another review about the man who is making the food wasn't sanitary at all.One last thing Id like to say is I would appreciate reading actual responses from the owner instead of AI generated.
I go to this place once in awhile the pizza is good the rolls are good.
Today what I did not like to see was the guy wearing black shirt with a picture on it wearing burgundy shorts and a black hat and beard making a pizza pie and picking at it and eating from it while he's making the food. Also touching his lower area maybe his shorts string and then touching the pie again and then eating from it.
Not very sanitary.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I’ve been going to this pizzeria for many years now. I used to enjoy going here until it felt like I was getting ripped off. I believe they make up prices on a daily basis. Because I ordered a chicken parm hero last week in person, and it was 14 dollars. Then just yesterday I ordered one again but this time over the phone, and it was Apparently $15.50 I did not place that order! I check there website and Menu in the store, and it says 14 dollars so the following day I go in person and order and it’s back to 14 dollars this isn’t the first time something like this has happened to me here. They do the same thing when it comes to getting a side dressing. Some days it’s 50 cents then others it’s a dollar. It’s just unfortunate because I’ve been going here for years, and it’s my local pizzeria, and it no longer feels family like(It hasn’t for the past year now). I Strongly believe this is due to employees, not being properly trained and the constant workers that go through this place. The food is usually a hit or miss. I also believe this is because theres always someone new making and preparing the food it when I look behind the counter.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Wings were undercooked had a really bad texture with pizza was amazing and service was great. The wings are very dry too.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Loading...