The Bagel Box
5840 Amboy Rd, Staten Island
(718) 966-6097
Customers' Favorites
Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese
Bagel Box Bacon Cheeseburger
Bagel with Butter
Everything Bagel
Egg and Cheese
Chicken Cutlet
Dozen Bagels
French Toast
Bakery
Roll
Breakfast
Bagel
Please specify bagel of choice
Bagel with Butter
Please specify bagel
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Please specify bagel
Bagel with Peanut Butter and Jelly
Please specify bagel
Bagel with Cream Cheese and Jelly
Please specify bagel
Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese
Please specify bagel
Bagel with Lox
Please specify bagel
Bagel with Cream Cheese and Lox
Please specify bagel
Roll
Bialy
Mini Bagel
Please specify
Mini bagel with butter
Dozen Bagels
Please specify bagels and include 1 free of choice
Dozen Minis Bagels
Please specify bagels and include 1 free of choice
Muffin
Apple Turnover
Folded and stuffed pastry dough.
Plain Croissant
A flaky French pastry.
Flavored Croissaint
Crumb Cake
2 Eggs
Bacon Egg & Cheese
Please specify bagel of choice or roll
Egg Whites
Please specify roll or bagel of choice
Egg Whites with Bacon and Cheese
Egg without yolk.
BLT
Bacon, lettuce, and tomato.
Please specify either roll or bagel of choice
Bacon on a bagel
Boiled and baked round bread roll.
Bacon and American cheese
Boiled and baked round bread roll.
Bacon and Cream Cheese
Boiled and baked round bread roll.
Grilled Cheese
Made to order with American cheese
Western Omelette Breakfast
3 Eggs, ham, peppers, and onions.
Served with toast
American Omelette Breakfast
3 Eggs, bacon, ham, and cheese.
Served with toast
Spanish Omelette Breakfast
3 Eggs, peppers, onions and jalapenos.
Served with toast
Hot Chocolate
Coffee medium
Coffee large
Coffee XL
Iced coffee
Bialy with butter
Box of joe
Includes cups, milk, Splenda and sugar on side
Nutella croissant
Bacon & cheddar omlet
3 pancakes
Served with side of syrup
3 Chocolate Chip pancakes
Served with side of syrup
French toast
3 pieces french toast served with syrup and butter on side
Belgian waffle
Served with butter and syrup
Potato egg and cheese
M&M pancakes
3 large pancakes with m&ms
Reese's pieces pancakes
3 large pancakes with Reese's pieces
Breakfast platter #1
3 eggs any style with ham, bacon or sausage with home fries
Breakfast platter #2
Pancakes or French toast with 2 eggs any style with either ham sausage or bacon
Oreo pancakes
3 large pancakes with oreos
Brioche bacon egg & cheddar
Bacon egg and cheddar on a brioche bun
Buffalo chicken cheese lettuce tomato
Breakfast Sandwich specials
Egg Whites, Lacey Swiss Cheese and Spinach
Egg Whites, Jalapeno Pepper Jack Cheese and Avocado
Let's Be Healthy
Egg whites, spinach and turkey
Jersey Style
Taylor ham, fried eggs & cheese
Leo's Trio
Ham, sausage, bacon, fried eggs & cheese
The BIG BOY!
Ham,bacon,sausage,turkey, fried eggs& cheese topped with a hash brown
The waffle BLT
Bacon,lettuce & tomato on our homemade Belgian waffle. Served with side of syrup
The Paesano
Scrambled eggs, chorizo, jalapenos and mozzarella
Bagel box grilled cheese
Bacon, cheese & tomato on a sour dough Panini
Hot Honey Bacon Egg & cheese
The HoneyBee
Cream cheese & bacon drizzled with honey
Deli Specials
Chicken Salad
Lb of homemade chicken salad
Macaroni Salad
Lb Cold pasta salad made with macaroni noodles.
Potato Salad
Lb of Cold dish made from seasoned potatoes.
Egg Salad
Lb of Chopped eggs that have been mixed with seasoning and mayo.
Tuna Salad
Lb Cold salad with shredded tuna.
Coleslaw
Lb of Cabbage salad.
Fresh Lox
Lb of Cured or smoked salmon.
Scallion Spread
Lb of scallion cream cheese
Vegetable cream cheese
1lb vegetable cream cheese
Lox cream cheese
1lb lox cream cheese
Walnut raisin cream cheese
1lb walnut raisin cream cheese
Lox and Cream Cheese Deli Special
Cured or smoked salmon.
Chicken Cutlet by the lb
Roasted Peppers
1lb Homemade roasted peppers
Oreo cream cheese
Bacon cheddar jalapeno cream cheese
Cinnamon toast crunch cream cheese
Butter finger cream cheese
Chocolate chip cream cheese
Antipasto salad
Pickle
Pickled cucumber that has been preserved in vinegar or brine. 1 piece.
Add a bag of potato chips
Premium Boar's Head, Combos
Combo 1
Deluxe ham, bologna, and American cheese.
Half pound of each.
Combo 2
Deluxe ham, oven gold, turkey, and Swiss cheese.
Half pound of each.
Combo 3
Roast beef, oven gold, turkey, and American cheese.
Half pound of each.
Combo 4
Cappy ham, salami, and provolone.
Half pound of each.
Combo 5
Salami, pepperoni, and mozzarella.
Half pound of each.
Add 6 rolls or bagels of choice
Please specify
Loaf of Italian bread
Premium Meats and Cheeses
Deluxe Ham
Cappy Ham
Cooked meat from the upper part of a pig's leg.
Bologna
Finely sliced sausage.
Liverwurst
Ovengold, Turkey
Maple Honey Turkey
Cracked Pepper Mill, Turkey
Salsalito, Turkey
Blazing Buffalo, Chicken
Poultry.
Salami
Cured sausage.
Sopressata
Prosciutto di parma
Pepperoni
Roast Beef
Cooked over dry heat.
Pastrami
Smoked and cured beef.
American Cheese
Swiss Cheese
Lacey Swiss Cheese
Provolone Cheese
Mozzarella Cheese
Muenster Cheese
Jalapeno Pepper Jack Cheese
Cheddar Cheese
Lunch & Late Munch Sandwiches
Chop Cheese
Chop meat peppes, onions & cheese topped with lettuce tomato
The Jacob
Pastrami & Swiss topped with 2 fried eggs
Roast Beef Supreme
Hot roast beef, caramelized onions fresh mozzarella and brown gravy
Italiano
Ham, salami, pepperoni, prosciutto,provelone, lettuce, tomato & roasted peppers
Peter Luger Steak Sandwich
Roast Beef, Fresh Mozzarella, caramelized onions topped with Peter luger sauce
Philly Cheesesteak
Sliced steak with peppers onions & cheese
Ruben
Pastrami with melted Swiss & sauerkraut topped with Russian dressing
The Melt
Chicken cutlet, Bacon,cheddar topped with tomatoes on our sourdough pannini
Princes Bay
Grilled or fried chicken with fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers & balsamic glaze
Buffy Jack
Buffalo chicken, pepper jack cheese lettuce, tomato, jalapenos topped with our homemade chipotle sauce
Chicken wings
Lb of Fried chicken wings
Chicken empanada
Beef empanada
Beef patty
Beef patty with cheese
The flounder Melt
Fried flounder with melted pepper jack cheese topped with lettuce tomato and drizzled with our homemade big boy sauce
Blazin Buffalo
Buffalo chicken, mozzarella cheese, topped with lettuce tomato with a side of blue cheese dressingl
The cordon Bleu sandwich
Fried chicken cutlet topped with ham and swiss.
Turkey club
Turkey, bacon, American cheese topped with 🥬 ,🍅 and 🥑
Bagel box BBQ
Boar's head BBQ chicken, fresh mozzarela, lettuce and tomato topped with BBQ sauce.
The Pepper Jack
Cracked pepper turkey, pepper jack cheese topped with lettuce tomato and homemade chipotle mayo
The Terminator
Roast beef and turkey topped with fresh mozzarella and gravy
Chicken wings
1lb Chicken wings with hot sauce and blue cheese on the side.
Buffalo chicken eggrolls
Philly cheese steak eggrolls
Spicy chicken tinga
Shredded chipotle chicken topped with fresh mozzarella, avocado, lettuce, tomato & a black bean spread
Ham cheese lettuce tomato
Turkey and cheese lettuce tomato
Roast beef and cheese lettuce tomato
Salami and cheese lettuce tomato
Bologna and cheese lettuce tomato
Pastrami and cheese lettuce tomato
Chicken cutlet
Fresh mozzarella roasted peppers balsamic glaze
Tuna lettuce tomato
Egg salad
Chicken salad
Chicken tinga
With lettuce tomato fresh mozzarella and 🥑 with a black bean spread
Breakfast Family Specials
Package #1
1 dozen large assorted bagels with LB cream cheese, 1/2 lb of butter and Box of Joe(qt of milk included)
Package #2
2 Dozen large assorted bagels with 1lb cream cheese, 1lb butter and Box of Joe(qt of milk included)
Paninis
P1. Chicken Cutlet
Chicken Cutlet with fresh mozzarella, homemade roasted peppers and balsamic glaze on sourdough bread
P2. Grilled Chicken
Grilled chicken broccoli rabe with fresh mozzarella
P3. Prosciutto di Parma
Prosciutto Di Parma with fresh mozzarella & roasted peppers on sourdough bread
P4. Roast Beef
Roast Beef with fresh mozzarella , caramelized onions and gravy on sourdough bread
P5. OvenGold Turkey
OvenGold Turkey with bacon, avocado, provolone & pesto
P6. Hot Pastrami
Hot Pastrami with Swiss cheese, pickles & mustard on sourdough bread
P7. Tuna
Tuna with avocado, lettuce & tomato on sour dough bread
P8. Boars Head Ham
Boars Head Ham with Swiss cheese and mayo on sourdough bread
P9. Fresh Mozzarella
Fresh Mozzarella with tomato, basil, extra virgin olive oil & balsamic glaze
P10. Prosciutto & arugula
Prosciutto di Parma with fresh mozzarella, arugula, roasted peppers, fig spread & balsamic glaze
P11. Italiano
Prosciutto di Parma, salami, sopressata & provolone on sour dough bread
P12. Mortadella
Mortadella with provolone and mustard on sourdough bread
P.13 chicken tinga
Chipotle chicken. Topped with lettuce tomato 🥑 fresh mozzarella with a black bean spread
Burgers
Bagel Box CheeseBurger
1/2 lb Angus beef topped with American cheese, lettuce, tomato & pickles with our own big boy sauce on a brioche bun
BagelBox Bacon CheeseBurger
1/2 lb Angus beef topped with boars head bacon, lettuce, tomato pickles & big boy sauce on a brioche bun
BagelBox Grilled Cheeseburger
1/2 lb Angus beef with American cheese on an upside down brioche bun
BagelBox BBQ Burger
1/2 lb Angus beef with bacon, crispy onions straws & BBQ sauce on a brioche bun
BagelBox Brunch Burger
1/2 lb Angus beef topped with boars head bacon, pork roll, American cheese, fried egg, hash brown & our big boy sauce on a brioche bun
BagelBox Shrooms Burger
1/2 lb Angus beef topped with mushrooms and Swiss cheese on a brioche bun
Beverages
Gallon of milk
1/2 gallon of milk
Quart of milk
Quart tropicana
12oz orange juice
12oz apple juice
Cream of land chocolate milk
Nesquick chocolate
Nesquick strawberry
Nesquick vanilla
Quart half and half
Quart French vanilla creamer
Quart hazelnut
Green monster energy drink
Celsius energy drink
C4 energy Drink
Can pepsi
Can coke
20oz pepsi
20oz diet Pepsi
20oz coke
20oz diet coke
20oz Dr pepper
20oz fanta orange
20oz mountain dew
20oz selzter
32oz gatorade
Please specify blue, yellow, orange and red
20oz gatorade
Specify blue, yellow, orange or red
Vitamin water
Please specify flavor
Large Starbucks frappacino
Choices are mocha, caramel or vanilla
Snapple
Choices lemon, diet lemon, peach, diet peach or raspberry
Gallon of water
1.5l water Poland spring
Small Poland spring
Small essentia water
1.5l essentia water
8oz red bull
12oz red bull
20oz redbull
Photos
+26 photos
+25 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I only stopped in for a quart of half & half for my morning coffee because with all the holiday shopping, I forgot to get my half & half & I had run out. The store had a large variety of hot & cold foods situated in a display case. All the food looked great. Some of the staff there were cooking in the back & preparing sandwiches & take out foods for the customers in the store. I had to wait just a couple of minutes to be rung up because the guys working,...
November 2025
Friday morning we ordered the French Toast bagel bacon egg and cheese with maple syrup. The sandwich was off the charts! I highly recommend that you try this sandwich. Not only is their food delicious, their customer service is top notch and prices are very reasonable. The store is so clean you can eat off the floor. The staff is amazing and super friendly. Chris, the owner, is the most generous guy to the community which makes the integrity of the store that much more worth the...
October 2025
My wife recommended Bagel Box, saying their sandwiches are excellent. I tried their Bagel & Lox, and it was fantastic. The next day, I went back to pick up another one for work. Their bacon, egg, and cheese sandwiches were also amazing.
October 2025
You May Also Like
Domenico's Pizza & Pasta - 5838 Amboy Rd
![]()
Pizza, Italian
Cucumber Sushi & Salad Bar - 5834 Amboy Rd
![]()
Sushi, Japanese, Sushi Bar, Asian Fusion, Vegetarian
New Island - 27 Seguine Ave
![]()
Chinese