A really solid pizza spot. Like everyone says, you can judge a good pizza by ordering a plain pie and that what we always do and it’s always a very good NY slice.
Bring cash so you don’t have to pay the credit card fee.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dushantha Kannangara
When I called to place an order for delivery, the cashier girl confirmed my address and mentioned that it would take 20 minutes for the delivery. After waiting for 60 minutes, I called again to check on the status of my order. The cashier then informed me that my order was ready for pickup. I am unsure how they manage their business with this team.
Service: 1
Stacy Paul
Best buffalo pie. When I used to order the delivery drivers were the best but now I go in to pick up since I moved. Every time I’m on the island I make sure to bring pies home.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Timothy Watt
One of the best pizza places in SI
Romeo Pagan
Truly kind workers. Treated me with respect, got my order on point. The wraps here are like no others and their pizza is absolutely astonishingly good. Loved the customer service there and the conversations we had. Made me feel right at home and now hold the #1 spot for food on the island in my opinion. Thank you Village Maria Pizzeria!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anthony S
This place just joined the ranks of all the other chain pizzerias and $2.00 delivery charge, REALLY!! Had 2 pies delivered on a Friday, pizza was off, not sure what it was, but not the same as we have had in the past. Maybe new owners or different ingredients. Will not return or order any longer.
Eric Irvine
Food is amazing, people there are amazing. In my honest opinion, this is a true NYC Pizzeria. Give it a try!
Been going here regularly for years. Best staff & great food. Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andriy Lit
There are some types of pizza that are only delicious in this place.
William Wildey
Ordered from Grubhub (at hotel)asked for utensils got nothing. Meatballs were definitely substandard I always considered New York to have the best Italian food in the world this is more like Pittsburgh
Amazing. I mostly order delivery and everything is always hot, fresh, on point and delicious. Always follow directions and send extra sauces/ketchup without asking. Love this place for everything from pizza to wraps to even pasta. Best fried chicken cutlet ever!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Real Madrid
Ordered food from uber eats, and for the second time they miss items. When I called to speak to complain to manager, the person that responded on the phone said that it was on the driver and that they won’t pass me the manager. I will never order from this place again, and I will leaving one star review on all the platforms
Vinnie Siena
Pizza sauce is horrible first time there and last. Maybe you should experiment with ingredients and come up with a better sauce. Had to add this comment all the 5 stars are probably family and friends that write those reviews. Read the one stars and two stars those will be the truth about this place. I’ve owned pizza shop and this place is not a place I would go again. And for people being friendly is BS I was ignored until I ask for a slice I have to say horrible slice. Good luck if you eat here
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Evgenii Nazarenko
They said “need to wait 3 minutes” instead i waited 30 minutes
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
caroline shchegol
I ordered extra extra extra cheese pizza. That's how my daughter likes it. Then when it was delivered it isn't what we got. They charged me 31$ and it wasnt worth that much. So I called and they told me that they cnt do it like that. Meanwhile they charged me for triple extra cheese. And also the pizza is so salty that u barely can eat it.
A really solid pizza spot. Like everyone says, you can judge a good pizza by ordering a plain pie and that what we always do and it’s always a very good NY slice.
Bring cash so you don’t have to pay the credit card fee.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
When I called to place an order for delivery, the cashier girl confirmed my address and mentioned that it would take 20 minutes for the delivery. After waiting for 60 minutes, I called again to check on the status of my order. The cashier then informed me that my order was ready for pickup. I am unsure how they manage their business with this team.
Service: 1
Best buffalo pie. When I used to order the delivery drivers were the best but now I go in to pick up since I moved. Every time I’m on the island I make sure to bring pies home.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of the best pizza places in SI
Truly kind workers. Treated me with respect, got my order on point. The wraps here are like no others and their pizza is absolutely astonishingly good. Loved the customer service there and the conversations we had. Made me feel right at home and now hold the #1 spot for food on the island in my opinion. Thank you Village Maria Pizzeria!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place just joined the ranks of all the other chain pizzerias and $2.00 delivery charge, REALLY!! Had 2 pies delivered on a Friday, pizza was off, not sure what it was, but not the same as we have had in the past. Maybe new owners or different ingredients. Will not return or order any longer.
Food is amazing, people there are amazing. In my honest opinion, this is a true NYC Pizzeria. Give it a try!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Garlic Knots, Vodka Sauce
Been going here regularly for years. Best staff & great food. Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
There are some types of pizza that are only delicious in this place.
Ordered from Grubhub (at hotel)asked for utensils got nothing. Meatballs were definitely substandard I always considered New York to have the best Italian food in the world this is more like Pittsburgh
Food: 4
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
Amazing. I mostly order delivery and everything is always hot, fresh, on point and delicious. Always follow directions and send extra sauces/ketchup without asking. Love this place for everything from pizza to wraps to even pasta. Best fried chicken cutlet ever!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered food from uber eats, and for the second time they miss items.
When I called to speak to complain to manager, the person that responded on the phone said that it was on the driver and that they won’t pass me the manager.
I will never order from this place again, and I will leaving one star review on all the platforms
Pizza sauce is horrible first time there and last. Maybe you should experiment with ingredients and come up with a better sauce. Had to add this comment all the 5 stars are probably family and friends that write those reviews. Read the one stars and two stars those will be the truth about this place. I’ve owned pizza shop and this place is not a place I would go again. And for people being friendly is BS I was ignored until I ask for a slice I have to say horrible slice. Good luck if you eat here
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
They said “need to wait 3 minutes” instead i waited 30 minutes
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I ordered extra extra extra cheese pizza. That's how my daughter likes it. Then when it was delivered it isn't what we got. They charged me 31$ and it wasnt worth that much. So I called and they told me that they cnt do it like that. Meanwhile they charged me for triple extra cheese. And also the pizza is so salty that u barely can eat it.
Food: 2
Loading...