Really good food, nice people, nice place in general. Only thing is delivery takes a bit long but definitely recommend getting food from here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Samuel Jay
Wasn’t bad but not
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Allen C.
I've been coming here for several years, usually ordering whole pie's togo, occasionally hot hero's, and pasta dishes. Service is very prompt and generally whether ordering hot pie's or hot hero's via phone, a time estimate of 15-20 minutes is generally accurate. Food is always nicely heated to perfection to share some nice slices of pie, hero's, or pasta after picking up and waiting in car for 10 minutes. Whole pies: Go to is half chicken bacon ranch and half meat supreme. Pizza's have a great mixture of cause, cheese, and the breading/crust/thickness is usually just right. Have also enjoyed their chicken parm, chipotle bacon ranch, and buffalo chicken. Other: All hot hero's are great, their chicken franchese is delicious with an excellent sauce/taste. The chicken is so tender and it meshes well with the crispiness of the outside bread. The veal cutlet gives a similar vibe. Chicken pocket is pretty solid/standard
J N.
These owners need to make things right for their loyal customers. My girlfriend and I were loyal customers at Mario's Restaurant in East Setauket, NY, for over 10 years. About a week before New Years Day, Mario's sold my girlfriend's parents a $100 gift card that they bought her for a holiday gift. 1 week later, Mario's closed without warning and never reopened. Now, we were unable to use the gift card. We tried calling Mario's, but the phone just rings. We then tried emailing Mario's but never received a reply. Finally, we tried calling Stony Brook Pizza, as it is owned by the same owners, but they would not make good on the gift card. We feel cheated. I implore the owners to read this and make good on the gift card. I'm not asking for money back, but something should be done to help your reputation by reaching out to those who were so loyal to you over the years.
Jesse Turcios
My favorite Pizza place!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Raaf E.
Fast friendly Service, the portions are HUGE, and THE MENU is relatively inexpensive! I ordered chicken parm, with pasta could of fed my whole family... will be eating for days! Also Best garlic knots I have tasted in years, What more can you ask for?
Kevin B.
Stopped in today for a couple of regular slices. The pizza was very good. Nice crust light sauce and tasty cheese. The guy behind the counter was great. Service with a smile. Many places today forget that concept. Sat down at one of the tables. The place was nice and clean. Will definitely go back.
Andrew Rein
One of the best slices I've ever had and the service was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken, Special Pizza, Rigatoni Vodka Slice
Kim Olofson
Awful delivery supposed to be non contact but the guy banged so hard multiple times I answered door told him this was a non contact delivery he said ok here is your pizza then he through it never using then again!! Spoke to them they said he delivered the way he was supposed to ?♀️ if that’s how your supposed to deliver then they will lose business
I love this place, it's my go to for pizza, it just sucks I moved to Florida. When I visit, rest assured I will be stopping here. The best pizza , service and food around.....
This is a nice, quiet pizza place near Stony Brook Road. Its sauce and cheese were terrific. They were able to cook the pizza well done, just the way I like it. The service is quite fast, we received our pizza within 10 minutes of ordering. The only downside is, their toppings were a bit limited. Overall, this was a nice little pizza joint.
Shaunni Mclen
Always perfect pizza. Nice atmosphere, and great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Buttermilk's Chicken
Pizza always amazing but tonight’s Pan pie was absolutely the best !! Great food, great staff and terrific delivery service !!Thank you ! Charlie &
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robert Friedman
The worst pizza in The Three Villages.The best is Brancinelli's in Hauppauge.
Not bad but not great. OK for what's on the area.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
Really good food, nice people, nice place in general. Only thing is delivery takes a bit long but definitely recommend getting food from here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wasn’t bad but not
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
I've been coming here for several years, usually ordering whole pie's togo, occasionally hot hero's, and pasta dishes. Service is very prompt and generally whether ordering hot pie's or hot hero's via phone, a time estimate of 15-20 minutes is generally accurate. Food is always nicely heated to perfection to share some nice slices of pie, hero's, or pasta after picking up and waiting in car for 10 minutes. Whole pies: Go to is half chicken bacon ranch and half meat supreme. Pizza's have a great mixture of cause, cheese, and the breading/crust/thickness is usually just right. Have also enjoyed their chicken parm, chipotle bacon ranch, and buffalo chicken. Other: All hot hero's are great, their chicken franchese is delicious with an excellent sauce/taste. The chicken is so tender and it meshes well with the crispiness of the outside bread. The veal cutlet gives a similar vibe. Chicken pocket is pretty solid/standard
These owners need to make things right for their loyal customers. My girlfriend and I were loyal customers at Mario's Restaurant in East Setauket, NY, for over 10 years. About a week before New Years Day, Mario's sold my girlfriend's parents a $100 gift card that they bought her for a holiday gift. 1 week later, Mario's closed without warning and never reopened. Now, we were unable to use the gift card. We tried calling Mario's, but the phone just rings. We then tried emailing Mario's but never received a reply. Finally, we tried calling Stony Brook Pizza, as it is owned by the same owners, but they would not make good on the gift card. We feel cheated. I implore the owners to read this and make good on the gift card. I'm not asking for money back, but something should be done to help your reputation by reaching out to those who were so loyal to you over the years.
My favorite Pizza place!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fast friendly Service, the portions are HUGE, and THE MENU is relatively inexpensive! I ordered chicken parm, with pasta could of fed my whole family... will be eating for days! Also Best garlic knots I have tasted in years, What more can you ask for?
Stopped in today for a couple of regular slices. The pizza was very good. Nice crust light sauce and tasty cheese. The guy behind the counter was great. Service with a smile. Many places today forget that concept. Sat down at one of the tables. The place was nice and clean. Will definitely go back.
One of the best slices I've ever had and the service was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken, Special Pizza, Rigatoni Vodka Slice
Awful delivery supposed to be non contact but the guy banged so hard multiple times I answered door told him this was a non contact delivery he said ok here is your pizza then he through it never using then again!! Spoke to them they said he delivered the way he was supposed to ?♀️ if that’s how your supposed to deliver then they will lose business
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
I love this place, it's my go to for pizza, it just sucks I moved to Florida. When I visit, rest assured I will be stopping here. The best pizza , service and food around.....
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad, Buffalo Chicken Pizza Grandma Pizza, Hero, Buffalo Chicken, Garlic Knots, Buffalo Knots, Margherita Pizza
This is a nice, quiet pizza place near Stony Brook Road. Its sauce and cheese were terrific. They were able to cook the pizza well done, just the way I like it. The service is quite fast, we received our pizza within 10 minutes of ordering. The only downside is, their toppings were a bit limited. Overall, this was a nice little pizza joint.
Always perfect pizza. Nice atmosphere, and great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza always amazing but tonight’s Pan pie was absolutely the best !! Great food, great staff and terrific delivery service !!Thank you ! Charlie &
Food: 5
Service: 5
The worst pizza in The Three Villages.The best is Brancinelli's in Hauppauge.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2