Cafe Testarossa

499 Jericho Turnpike, Syosset
(516) 364-8877

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Fran

Food was delicious. I had salmon which came with vegetables and potatoe ravioli. Italian bread outstanding. Hubby had calamari for app and black linguine with shrimp, for entree, were enjoyed. His Napoleon desert was delicious.

Vincent

Been here many times. Love it. Very busy this time and a little short of staff. Our server Angela was very good.

Jo

Always consistently good. I've been going to Cafe Testarosa for years. Always delicious and service wonderful.

Sylvia

Cafe Testarosa is fantastic. The food and service was exceptional. We have been there three times and each visit has been great. It is becoming our new favorite.

Joe

We sits outside on patio . Has lots of greenery and flowers. Nice setting. Been here quite a bit and service and food has always been great .

david

The 3/4 Debacle. I ordered Tartufo for dessert. Usually, the Tartufo ball of ice-cream is served cut into 4 quarters. You are not going to believe this, but, mine was missing a quarter! I was only served 3/4 of my dessert! When I brought this up to management, they said that was normal for a "Dinner Special"! Whats next? 3/4 of a baked potato? 3/4 of a corn on the cob? Management: how much are you saving? What about the labor costs of cutting up 4 tartufo balls, and redistributing to 5 servings? This is what I will be talking about to my friends. Not that the main dishes were great, and generous, but about your stupidity with the Tartufo!

liz

We had a lovely experience. It was a quiet night and we were offered outside or inside seating. Our party chose inside. Staff was extremely attentive and accomodating. Food was delicious and beautifully presented. Portions were large and I just enjoyed my leftovers for lunch.

Michael

Excellent. Booked a table for 4 that turned into 5 at the last minute. Very accommodating. Food was incredible. Wednesday dinner in Sicily menu. Zucchini flowers and swordfish were outstanding.

Doreen

This was my first visit to this establishment but I will certainly be back. The food is exceptional. I had the house-made ravioli. Two people tried the price fixe, which was a great price, $59 for app, entree & dessert.The service was well-paced. We had a group of five chatty women and never felt uncomfortable or rushed.

Christine

Excellent food.. got charged for water when we said we didn't want sparkling. Received a bottle of flat water for $9.00. Good service Very noisy though

ann

We loved the crab cakes appetizer. Also black said I'll pasta fantastic. Always consistent and great service!

Anthony

We always enjoy our meal, the service and its great value the food is always excellent. Highly recommended

Lynn

We went on a Thursday night and ordered from the 3 course meal menu. The food was delicious. My friend ordered from the regular menu and her food was delicious too. It was our first time going and we will return.

Sima

The food was bland, the waitress was stressed out and you couldn't hear yourself think. All in all, not a great eating experience.

Bella

For those who appreciate refined dining in a tranquil setting, this restaurant offers an exceptional experience. The elegantly spacious and light-filled dining room exudes a sense of calm sophistication, with tables thoughtfully arranged to ensure privacy and comfort. Unlike more crowded establishments, there is no intrusion of neighboring conversations—only the quiet pleasure of your own company. The cuisine is exquisite: fresh, artfully prepared, and delicately balanced, with the fish cooked to perfection. Service is impeccable—gracious, attentive, and discreet—creating an atmosphere of genuine hospitality without ever feeling intrusive.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...