Sandwiches were good but very overpriced. Listen everything is high, but I thought this was really not worth the price. Same with the baking side prices were very high.
Winter Spiced Cranberry
Great Italian dessert shop! They serve gelato, which makes this place even better! The pastries here are top-notch. I just love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato
littlepeachtea
I love this cafe!! the cookie butter latte is so yumm and I love the variety of sweet treats and savory sandwiches. Also they're dog friendly! Cutest cafe in Syosset. Plus the staff are so nice! Would definitely recommend to anyone.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Milhojas, Cake Selection
Kath Minaya
Excellent service and very good quality and everything super clean ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patricia Hambrook
Great place for lunch and dinner. Now serving wine!
Olga Campbell
We had a cake ordered , actually two cakes for my two kids bdays on two occasions . Bakery has amazing choices of fillings and options . Both my kids had the pictures they wanted to replicate and Dylan and her team exceeded our expectations on presentation and taste price was also good ! It’s my go to place ! Highly recommend! Thanks again for making my kids birthday an amazing event! Also ordered cakes for smaller occasions ! Amazing flavours !
When we arrived We were greeted in a very nice manner. The food was absolutely amazing here and I had a blast.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Priscilla Antunez
We love their cakes for special occasions, and I also love getting lunch and coffee at Stellina Bakery & Cafe. As you might imagine, their bread is delicious and often find myself craving their tuna salad sandwich. Like right now! ?Parking: I usually park in the back if I can’t find free parking on the street
Good variety of pastries. The coffee isn't bad either. They also have sandwiches.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Carolyn Cardone
I know thisHas to be some type ofMisunderstandingWhen I stopped in and looked and purchasedMini Tiramisu and cannoli mini cakesThey were staleI could not believe itHere I amBoasting about this BakeryI can't believe they put stuff out that was a week
Both a cake to celebrate the new year, the sponge was over baked not by a little, super dry , all layers fell apart. Quality really has gone down, just to live it when it was still Cardinale. Not worth the money are visit. Service was also super
Food: 1
Recommended dishes: Cake Selection
Marie Arroyo
I had the rainbow donut and it was insanely good. It was like having an elite rainbow cookie in donut form. The service was fantastic. The person who helped me was extremely helpful and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Niambi Nelson
Beautiful inside, welcoming and reasonably priced. But… I got 8 of the mini cakes that are $25/lb. The 8 came up to a lil over $11 which was very fairly priced. Out of the 8 only 3 we’re fresh and the other 5 were very stale and hard.. hard that you cannot bypass it and they had to feel the staleness when they picked it out and still gave it to me. I was very disappointed that the majority of the mini cakes were stale because the 3 that were fresh were really really good. I would give the bakery another try but I would make sure to let them know about my experience and to make sure the cakes are fresh.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Mike C.
Fool me once shame on you, fool me 2x shame on me. I won't be back. Stopped in for lunch the first time in the very beginning of new ownership. I wasn't quite sure of the concept. The 'manager' who was sitting at a table playing on her phone eventually greeted us and sat us down. After several minutes I wave her down and asked for menus and water for the table. After several more minutes of neglect I approached the counter and asked if I could order. The girl at the counter took my order right there. We were eventually served our food which was good. During the meal I spilled my water (full glass) all over the floor. The employees walked over it several times before I finally said to the 'manager' that someone could possibly slip and fall on it to which she agreed and finally had someone clean it up. Then came time to pay the bill, no one to be found. I approach the manager again and ask for the check. She gives it to me after a long struggle handling the printer then explains to me in embarrassment that she usually doesn't handle such tasks. Now I hand her my CC and more struggling ensues. I'm now shaking my head in disbelief and ask if there's waitress service to which she replies no, it's like McDonald's here , you order at the counter and we bring you the food. I was a little relieved by her answer because I thought to myself the whole time how could the service be so bad?? Fast foward to today for lunch. Now I think I'm experienced and know the deal here and looking forward to a good meal. So we walk in and go directly to the front counter and ask for menus. The girl behind the counter says we don't have any and points to the board behind the counter which has some things but not all that are available I know this because I checked the online menu prior to entering the store. So now I start to ask if they have salads which are not listed on the board and she says yes, so I just asked for an easy Caesar salad and so does my friend .Then question about the pizzas which were listed with just nicknames but not the ingredients so she goes into the back because she has no knowledge of any of them and comes back and just says we have only the vegetable pizza. So now we just order a Panini to split. Now for the fun part. The girls brings out the panini first on a dish, no napkins ,no silverware, no sharing plates and walks away. I get up, walk to the count to ask for napkins and silverware, which she begrudgingly gives me. I return to the table and sink my teeth in to an ice cold Panini, yuck. A few minutes later, she brings one Caesar salad out and then several minutes later, the next one. We were still eating our cold Panini when she approaches the table with two dressings, and walks away.. We finish our meal which wasn't bad and walk up to the counter to order two coffees with milk. After a few minutes, the girl brings the coffee to our table black with no milk. now I again approached the counter and ask for milk and stir sticks. To bring this long boring story to an end. This entire experience was a disaster from beginning to end, I couldn't help but shake my head the entire time I was there. Hey Mr. Stellina, how about putting some management in place in you Syosset location. If not I'm afraid the end is near. By the way only one other table there during my entire visit . Good luck, won't be seeing you any time soon.
Joanne C.
I can not even give this location a one star: First of all there is no menu to look at. You have to look at a board to see what they have and even then some items are not even available. The staff does not make eye contact with you. Four girls working not one was helpful. They bring you food with no utensils, or extra plates. Panini came out first (cold) with the salad to follow about 10 minutes later. Brought my salad to counter to have wrapped to take home and not one person wanted to lift their head to offer assistance. There is no management in place and it shows. if you are going to hire girls to work that really don't want to work then at least have a manager to oversee them and the place. Worst place I've ever been to in a very long time. A small coffee shop has better service. Awful! Prediction, will not last.
Sandwiches were good but very overpriced. Listen everything is high, but I thought this was really not worth the price. Same with the baking side prices were very high.
Great Italian dessert shop! They serve gelato, which makes this place even better! The pastries here are top-notch. I just love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato
I love this cafe!! the cookie butter latte is so yumm and I love the variety of sweet treats and savory sandwiches. Also they're dog friendly! Cutest cafe in Syosset. Plus the staff are so nice! Would definitely recommend to anyone.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Milhojas, Cake Selection
Excellent service and very good quality and everything super clean ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place for lunch and dinner. Now serving wine!
We had a cake ordered , actually two cakes for my two kids bdays on two occasions . Bakery has amazing choices of fillings and options . Both my kids had the pictures they wanted to replicate and Dylan and her team exceeded our expectations on presentation and taste price was also good ! It’s my go to place ! Highly recommend! Thanks again for making my kids birthday an amazing event! Also ordered cakes for smaller occasions ! Amazing flavours !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Gelato, Cake Selection
When we arrived We were greeted in a very nice manner. The food was absolutely amazing here and I had a blast.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We love their cakes for special occasions, and I also love getting lunch and coffee at Stellina Bakery & Cafe. As you might imagine, their bread is delicious and often find myself craving their tuna salad sandwich. Like right now! ?Parking: I usually park in the back if I can’t find free parking on the street
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Gelato, Tiramisu Cake, Cake Selection
Good variety of pastries. The coffee isn't bad either. They also have sandwiches.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
I know thisHas to be some type ofMisunderstandingWhen I stopped in and looked and purchasedMini Tiramisu and cannoli mini cakesThey were staleI could not believe itHere I amBoasting about this BakeryI can't believe they put stuff out that was a week
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Both a cake to celebrate the new year, the sponge was over baked not by a little, super dry , all layers fell apart. Quality really has gone down, just to live it when it was still Cardinale. Not worth the money are visit. Service was also super
Food: 1
Recommended dishes: Cake Selection
I had the rainbow donut and it was insanely good. It was like having an elite rainbow cookie in donut form. The service was fantastic. The person who helped me was extremely helpful and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beautiful inside, welcoming and reasonably priced. But… I got 8 of the mini cakes that are $25/lb. The 8 came up to a lil over $11 which was very fairly priced. Out of the 8 only 3 we’re fresh and the other 5 were very stale and hard.. hard that you cannot bypass it and they had to feel the staleness when they picked it out and still gave it to me. I was very disappointed that the majority of the mini cakes were stale because the 3 that were fresh were really really good. I would give the bakery another try but I would make sure to let them know about my experience and to make sure the cakes are fresh.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Fool me once shame on you, fool me 2x shame on me. I won't be back. Stopped in for lunch the first time in the very beginning of new ownership. I wasn't quite sure of the concept. The 'manager' who was sitting at a table playing on her phone eventually greeted us and sat us down. After several minutes I wave her down and asked for menus and water for the table. After several more minutes of neglect I approached the counter and asked if I could order. The girl at the counter took my order right there. We were eventually served our food which was good. During the meal I spilled my water (full glass) all over the floor. The employees walked over it several times before I finally said to the 'manager' that someone could possibly slip and fall on it to which she agreed and finally had someone clean it up. Then came time to pay the bill, no one to be found. I approach the manager again and ask for the check. She gives it to me after a long struggle handling the printer then explains to me in embarrassment that she usually doesn't handle such tasks. Now I hand her my CC and more struggling ensues. I'm now shaking my head in disbelief and ask if there's waitress service to which she replies no, it's like McDonald's here , you order at the counter and we bring you the food. I was a little relieved by her answer because I thought to myself the whole time how could the service be so bad?? Fast foward to today for lunch. Now I think I'm experienced and know the deal here and looking forward to a good meal. So we walk in and go directly to the front counter and ask for menus. The girl behind the counter says we don't have any and points to the board behind the counter which has some things but not all that are available I know this because I checked the online menu prior to entering the store. So now I start to ask if they have salads which are not listed on the board and she says yes, so I just asked for an easy Caesar salad and so does my friend .Then question about the pizzas which were listed with just nicknames but not the ingredients so she goes into the back because she has no knowledge of any of them and comes back and just says we have only the vegetable pizza. So now we just order a Panini to split. Now for the fun part. The girls brings out the panini first on a dish, no napkins ,no silverware, no sharing plates and walks away. I get up, walk to the count to ask for napkins and silverware, which she begrudgingly gives me. I return to the table and sink my teeth in to an ice cold Panini, yuck. A few minutes later, she brings one Caesar salad out and then several minutes later, the next one. We were still eating our cold Panini when she approaches the table with two dressings, and walks away.. We finish our meal which wasn't bad and walk up to the counter to order two coffees with milk. After a few minutes, the girl brings the coffee to our table black with no milk. now I again approached the counter and ask for milk and stir sticks. To bring this long boring story to an end. This entire experience was a disaster from beginning to end, I couldn't help but shake my head the entire time I was there. Hey Mr. Stellina, how about putting some management in place in you Syosset location. If not I'm afraid the end is near. By the way only one other table there during my entire visit . Good luck, won't be seeing you any time soon.
I can not even give this location a one star: First of all there is no menu to look at. You have to look at a board to see what they have and even then some items are not even available. The staff does not make eye contact with you. Four girls working not one was helpful. They bring you food with no utensils, or extra plates. Panini came out first (cold) with the salad to follow about 10 minutes later. Brought my salad to counter to have wrapped to take home and not one person wanted to lift their head to offer assistance. There is no management in place and it shows. if you are going to hire girls to work that really don't want to work then at least have a manager to oversee them and the place. Worst place I've ever been to in a very long time. A small coffee shop has better service. Awful! Prediction, will not last.