Bagel was fantastic and staff was super friendly. Also their iced coffee was surprisingly good, breaking the trend that all bagel stores have bad/weak coffee.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
D H.
I just want to express my sincere and heartfelt gratitude to the Sabelli staff. I've been at home all week battling COVID and relying on delivery apps for my meals, and unfortunately, the costs have been adding up. However, this evening when I ordered a pint of soup from Sabelli, I was pleasantly surprised to find two pints in the bag. I cannot express how much this meant to me and how it felt like a true blessing from God. You lifted a huge load from me. May He continue to bless you, your business, and all of your loved ones always. Thank you.
Allison Smith
Wonderful staff and great tasting fresh food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steven Leibowitz
Wow! Had an assorted Wrap Platter delivered for a Football watch party. Wraps were huge and a big hit. Ordering was simple and staff was great answering questions. Condiments came wrapped in plastic wrap. The entire presentation was great. AWSOME!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A S
Cheese was not melted in my omelette??? And there were peppers and onions in my omelette which I DID NOT ORDER. I did a create ur own omelette, and its even on the receipt. Barely ate it. Peeled back the “omelette” top, and theres cold, hard, NOT melted cheese. For $25 for an omelette and a few strips of bacon on the side im so disappointed. Will never order here again.
Food: 1
Sherry C.
Here's what we've ordered: - bacon, egg, and cheese on an everything croissant 4/5 - sausage, egg and cheese on an egg bagel 5/5 - cookies (the guy gave us the wrong ones even though we pointed it out to him.... it was still good) 4/5 - iced coffee (self serve, milk is in the mini fridge) 3/5 What I've ordered through Doordash/UberEats: - Cubano 5/5 - Egg Salad 3/5 - Macaroni salad 3/5 - Pasta with spinach, feta, and tomatoes 4/5 - Chicken empanada 3/5 - Chicken bacon ranch 4/5 I started to order from Sabeli's during the pandemic through DoorDash and UberEats and haven't walked into the deli until the beginning of this week. I was surprised to see how small it is. The staff is friendly for 6AM and just opening (they were really nice). Their lunch sandwiches are amazing, huge portions, delicious. I found that their chicken bacon ranch is on the saltier side. If you're into salt, go for it! It's pretty good. The breakfast sandwiches were good as well. However, they ran out of the regular croissant so we ended up with an everything croissant. As for their egg salad, macaroni salad, and pasta salad.. They had a bit too much sauce (mayo) for me so I couldn't enjoy the flavors of everything else. If you love mayo, I recommend it. I prefer to taste the seasonings. Their cookies were delicious. The guy didn't give us what we wanted but it was 5AM. Don't judge us! I know you've wanted cookies in the morning before! I really enjoyed these cookies with my iced coffee. The reason why I give the iced coffee a 3 out of 5 rating is because it wasn't strong at all. I liked that it was a self serve station for the coffee. The milk and cream are in the mini fridge. If you don't like or want coffee, they have other beverage options as well. The deli was very clean and I'd be concerned if it wasn't at 6AM when they opened! They do not have indoor seating but come hungry, leave happy.
norberto g.
Over priced bagels no fixed prices. My friend got a toasted Bacon Egg and cheese bagel and paid $5changed and I purchased a everything bagel with bacon and cheese no eggs and charged $8.00.unreal! Bacon was also microwaved and rubbery not fresh
Greg Perles
I’ve catered a couple of events (around 25 people) and can’t overstate how much I love this place: the food is delicious, the speed & attentiveness of the service is exemplary, the prices are entirely reasonable & fair. I recently called in a panic at the last minute because I had forgotten to order for a big meeting; Rob and his crew put together an outstanding lunch for 25 people & delivered it in less than an hour!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lindsey G.
Food here is always fresh and delicious Great lunch specials as well since I will not be here for Thanksgiving I am going to order a Thanksgiving meal for some of my family forget Boston market that place definitely went downhill at the Hicksville location
M T.
I ordered two bagels with salmon, cream cheese and onions. One bagel with gluten free which they said would be smaller was tiny. As you can see by the picture there is no salmon or maybe tiny pieces of it, yet they charged $6.99 for it. I am from the city and you just can't do that, you should be embarrassed. If I was not in a rush I would have come back and complained for a full refund or at least to get the salmon I paid for. So I paid an extra $13.98 for salmon which should have been slices, not diced tiny pieces. It's a nice looking store, but won't be back if that's they way they do business.
We love Sabelli so much !! Rob and the staff go above and beyond to make everyone happy oh and the food is incredible ❤️
Antonios Charalambous
Sandwiches are great! Bagels are garbage.
Benjamin Gruber
The best sandwich shop! High quality food and a great owner.
Mireya Doud
This place has great bagel sandwiches and coffee!!! Their deli counter has an array of cold salads. This place doesn’t skimp on ingredients either. Place is clean and staff is friendly and helpful. Will come back again!
Kayla Murphy
Delicious bagels and bites! Lots of variety and incredibly kind and funny staff!
Bagel was fantastic and staff was super friendly. Also their iced coffee was surprisingly good, breaking the trend that all bagel stores have bad/weak coffee.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I just want to express my sincere and heartfelt gratitude to the Sabelli staff. I've been at home all week battling COVID and relying on delivery apps for my meals, and unfortunately, the costs have been adding up. However, this evening when I ordered a pint of soup from Sabelli, I was pleasantly surprised to find two pints in the bag. I cannot express how much this meant to me and how it felt like a true blessing from God. You lifted a huge load from me. May He continue to bless you, your business, and all of your loved ones always. Thank you.
Wonderful staff and great tasting fresh food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wow! Had an assorted Wrap Platter delivered for a Football watch party. Wraps were huge and a big hit. Ordering was simple and staff was great answering questions. Condiments came wrapped in plastic wrap. The entire presentation was great. AWSOME!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cheese was not melted in my omelette??? And there were peppers and onions in my omelette which I DID NOT ORDER. I did a create ur own omelette, and its even on the receipt. Barely ate it. Peeled back the “omelette” top, and theres cold, hard, NOT melted cheese. For $25 for an omelette and a few strips of bacon on the side im so disappointed. Will never order here again.
Food: 1
Here's what we've ordered: - bacon, egg, and cheese on an everything croissant 4/5 - sausage, egg and cheese on an egg bagel 5/5 - cookies (the guy gave us the wrong ones even though we pointed it out to him.... it was still good) 4/5 - iced coffee (self serve, milk is in the mini fridge) 3/5 What I've ordered through Doordash/UberEats: - Cubano 5/5 - Egg Salad 3/5 - Macaroni salad 3/5 - Pasta with spinach, feta, and tomatoes 4/5 - Chicken empanada 3/5 - Chicken bacon ranch 4/5 I started to order from Sabeli's during the pandemic through DoorDash and UberEats and haven't walked into the deli until the beginning of this week. I was surprised to see how small it is. The staff is friendly for 6AM and just opening (they were really nice). Their lunch sandwiches are amazing, huge portions, delicious. I found that their chicken bacon ranch is on the saltier side. If you're into salt, go for it! It's pretty good. The breakfast sandwiches were good as well. However, they ran out of the regular croissant so we ended up with an everything croissant. As for their egg salad, macaroni salad, and pasta salad.. They had a bit too much sauce (mayo) for me so I couldn't enjoy the flavors of everything else. If you love mayo, I recommend it. I prefer to taste the seasonings. Their cookies were delicious. The guy didn't give us what we wanted but it was 5AM. Don't judge us! I know you've wanted cookies in the morning before! I really enjoyed these cookies with my iced coffee. The reason why I give the iced coffee a 3 out of 5 rating is because it wasn't strong at all. I liked that it was a self serve station for the coffee. The milk and cream are in the mini fridge. If you don't like or want coffee, they have other beverage options as well. The deli was very clean and I'd be concerned if it wasn't at 6AM when they opened! They do not have indoor seating but come hungry, leave happy.
Over priced bagels no fixed prices. My friend got a toasted Bacon Egg and cheese bagel and paid $5changed and I purchased a everything bagel with bacon and cheese no eggs and charged $8.00.unreal! Bacon was also microwaved and rubbery not fresh
I’ve catered a couple of events (around 25 people) and can’t overstate how much I love this place: the food is delicious, the speed & attentiveness of the service is exemplary, the prices are entirely reasonable & fair. I recently called in a panic at the last minute because I had forgotten to order for a big meeting; Rob and his crew put together an outstanding lunch for 25 people & delivered it in less than an hour!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food here is always fresh and delicious Great lunch specials as well since I will not be here for Thanksgiving I am going to order a Thanksgiving meal for some of my family forget Boston market that place definitely went downhill at the Hicksville location
I ordered two bagels with salmon, cream cheese and onions. One bagel with gluten free which they said would be smaller was tiny. As you can see by the picture there is no salmon or maybe tiny pieces of it, yet they charged $6.99 for it. I am from the city and you just can't do that, you should be embarrassed. If I was not in a rush I would have come back and complained for a full refund or at least to get the salmon I paid for. So I paid an extra $13.98 for salmon which should have been slices, not diced tiny pieces. It's a nice looking store, but won't be back if that's they way they do business.
Restaurantji Recommends
We love Sabelli so much !! Rob and the staff go above and beyond to make everyone happy oh and the food is incredible ❤️
Sandwiches are great! Bagels are garbage.
The best sandwich shop! High quality food and a great owner.
This place has great bagel sandwiches and coffee!!! Their deli counter has an array of cold salads. This place doesn’t skimp on ingredients either. Place is clean and staff is friendly and helpful. Will come back again!
Delicious bagels and bites! Lots of variety and incredibly kind and funny staff!