WOW! I've had sandwiches twice from here and both times they have been amazing! I would highly recommend either the brisket or the chicken sandwich. They have gluten free bread, and you can choose to have your sandwich on greens and omit the bread. I love the pickles you can add. The homemade fudge that you get for free is seriously the icing on the cake, nothing better than some dessert after your sandwich!
Cody P.
There's a lot of great sandwich places, but it would be safe to say Peachtree is at least in the top ten in Syracuse. They put a lot of care and just the right amount of pretension into every sandwich. The pricing is a bit inflated, but I've been coming back repeatedly over the last few months, so why not? I've had just about everything on the menu at this point. Number one item is The Brisket. Not all their sauces and combos are a love connection but everything about this sandwich is kizmit. The meat is so tender and delicious, and then it's combined with some actual spice from jalapenos. Not that it needed the help, but the slightly sweet and smokey taste of the comeback sauce is the bow on top. Best item at Peachtree, and I'd nominate it as one of the best brisket sandwiches in Syracuse. 2nd and 3rd are too close to call, so we'll just move on to both. First we have The Chicken, where they take a hearty breaded cut of chicken breast, cover it with hot honey and then bury the whole thing in southern slaw. The chicken, the breading, and the honey are a pristine combination. The slaw adds the much needed cold crunch, but the sweetness pulls me out of the experience. With the honey already in place, it needs spicy or even just regular slaw. I'm still very fond of the sandwich despite what my tastes would call a mismatch in flavors. Also at 2nd or 3rd is The Bacon. I'll be honest, I was not expecting to absolutely love this sandwich. Bacon is the best but it's a sidekick, not a star. This is just a regular sandwich with bacon as the meat, I came in with my guard down. Turns out, the bacon is thick cut, always cooked perfectly, and seasoned to absolute deliciousness. It's the best bacon I've ever had, and enough to single handedly turn some regular bread, lettuce and mayo into a sandwich you'll never forget. Next in line are what I'd call just the regular sandwiches. The club is the same setup as any other club, but at least you get the added value of Peachtree bread and the sauce they use. Not as remarkable as the others, but if you've gotta have a club sandwich you won't regret it. The turkey is great too, about the same level as the club. The focaccia bread kind of weirds me out. Tastes great, but it holds together more like cake than bread. I took the other half home and put it in the oven for a while and liked it a lot better. I do not recommend the burger. For $13.00 you get a pretty dry patty without much taste. We tried fixing it with sauce, but it's just an unsubstantial burger with no selling points. Pass on that. The tenders are nothing special. They are on the kids menu, but they cost the same as tenders anywhere else. The chili is pretty good, and a good buy for $5.50 (get it with cheese). Just spicy enough to be kind of spicy. It'd probably be great on a hotdog, but like, byohotdog I guess. Oh, and the fries are delicious. Non-frozen, fresh cut. I don't know what they're fried in, but they seem fresh every time. So that's my take on pretty much everything available here. Overall, very highly recommended place to try. All the bread and ingredients are excellent, and all their sandwiches use unique and delicious sauces. They put in the work to put their own signature feel on their sandwiches that will set them above the stuff you'd get from a regular deli or diner. You also get free fudge with your meals. Maybe it's just the summer heat, but mine is always in the consistency of hot fudge. I recommend putting in the freezer. It's also fine enough to dissolve completely into your coffee and chocolate it up.
AuntJewelSweetbox Bakery
When I received my bag it had a Lil piece of fudge attached to it I instantly pulled it off and decided it should be eaten first. At that point I had to make grown women decisions as to was I gonna be late to my appt or go back for more I mean it was that darn good. Wait and the sauces are tasty like the south on point.
Roger B.
Speedy service, great value, and fresh food. Honestly was pretty surprised at how good it is. Definitely going to be a regular in my lunch rotation.
Alicia C.
Love this place. Gluten Free bread option. Excellently executed sandwiches. Staff is always cranking things out and are super nice. They give free fudge with each order. The brisket is so very good, albeit a bit heavy so I can't get it every time. I love that their club uses the Alabama White sauce instead of regular mayo--that sauce smacks. Also they make Greta thick cut, but not floppy, bacon. They serve fresh cut fries (aka five guys style) and that is my fave. You will be stuffed!
Ahmad Abu-Ramadan
First time trying after seeing it around a bunch. Everything was great! Brisket sandwiches were huge, tender and flavorful, definitely a must try. Chicken sandwich was great too! Staff was friendly, quick, and clean! Great first experience and will definitely be back!
Sean Place
Have been hearing nothing but good things about this joint for a while. Finally made it in and was not disappointed. Sandwiches were delicious and the fries were on point. Look forward to trying it many more times.
Erica O.
Run don't walk. This sandwich shop is amazing. I was excited as I read the menu, brisket, turkey and roast beef prepared in house. Hand cut fries, pimento cheese, coleslaw, pickled jalapenos all homemade. The pimento cheese and toast was so tasty I had a hard time stopping, but my sandwich was ready. The brisket was tender and smokey, the coleslaw was perfect and I loved the sweetness of the pickled jalapenos. I got my sauce on the side and didn't even add it. My friend and I couldn't stop eating the fries... they were hot, crispy, just a little salty and delicious....we didn't even put ketchup on. My friend has lots of food sensitivities so when she saw everything was house made, she was very happy and ate her entire roast beef sandwich. She couldn't stop raving about the flavor and how much she was enjoying it. Don't forget they give you a small piece of fudge! Perfect ending. Everyone greeted us warmly and the service was friendly and fast.
Robin C.
Love Peachtree! The sandwiches are delicious and the service is friendly and excellent. Their specialty is house made bacon and it is delicious! The fries aren't too shabby either!
Krissy Rice
Love the chicken and bacon signature sandwiches so it was an easy choice to order catering for an office meeting. The sandwiches were individually wrapped and labeled to eliminate digging through and the salads were packed to capacity. The cookie/fudge platter was a hit as well.
Good sandwich- bread a little dry. Are the employees on some kind of prison work relief program? Some tough hombres. Didn't care for the fudge.
Allen J.
Wowwwwww this place is amazing. Recently moved to DeWitt and everyone suggested checking this place out and it did not disappoint! Can't wait to come back and try everything else.
S L.
This little sandwich shop is the bomb diggety!! FRESH food the is packed with flavor!! Owner/chef is on top of every detail. He has more staff on shift that makes sense. Everyone is working hard and seem pretty happy to be there. Kudos to the owner for running a class A joint!!
Heidi Menikheim
Delicious Sandwiches! I had the chicken sandwich and it was one of the best I've had!
Bryan F.
Unbelievable. Most underrated sandwich shop in DeWitt AND Syracuse. The brisket is the best sandwich I have ever had in my 20 years of living and that could not be more truthful.
WOW! I've had sandwiches twice from here and both times they have been amazing! I would highly recommend either the brisket or the chicken sandwich. They have gluten free bread, and you can choose to have your sandwich on greens and omit the bread. I love the pickles you can add. The homemade fudge that you get for free is seriously the icing on the cake, nothing better than some dessert after your sandwich!
There's a lot of great sandwich places, but it would be safe to say Peachtree is at least in the top ten in Syracuse. They put a lot of care and just the right amount of pretension into every sandwich. The pricing is a bit inflated, but I've been coming back repeatedly over the last few months, so why not? I've had just about everything on the menu at this point. Number one item is The Brisket. Not all their sauces and combos are a love connection but everything about this sandwich is kizmit. The meat is so tender and delicious, and then it's combined with some actual spice from jalapenos. Not that it needed the help, but the slightly sweet and smokey taste of the comeback sauce is the bow on top. Best item at Peachtree, and I'd nominate it as one of the best brisket sandwiches in Syracuse. 2nd and 3rd are too close to call, so we'll just move on to both. First we have The Chicken, where they take a hearty breaded cut of chicken breast, cover it with hot honey and then bury the whole thing in southern slaw. The chicken, the breading, and the honey are a pristine combination. The slaw adds the much needed cold crunch, but the sweetness pulls me out of the experience. With the honey already in place, it needs spicy or even just regular slaw. I'm still very fond of the sandwich despite what my tastes would call a mismatch in flavors. Also at 2nd or 3rd is The Bacon. I'll be honest, I was not expecting to absolutely love this sandwich. Bacon is the best but it's a sidekick, not a star. This is just a regular sandwich with bacon as the meat, I came in with my guard down. Turns out, the bacon is thick cut, always cooked perfectly, and seasoned to absolute deliciousness. It's the best bacon I've ever had, and enough to single handedly turn some regular bread, lettuce and mayo into a sandwich you'll never forget. Next in line are what I'd call just the regular sandwiches. The club is the same setup as any other club, but at least you get the added value of Peachtree bread and the sauce they use. Not as remarkable as the others, but if you've gotta have a club sandwich you won't regret it. The turkey is great too, about the same level as the club. The focaccia bread kind of weirds me out. Tastes great, but it holds together more like cake than bread. I took the other half home and put it in the oven for a while and liked it a lot better. I do not recommend the burger. For $13.00 you get a pretty dry patty without much taste. We tried fixing it with sauce, but it's just an unsubstantial burger with no selling points. Pass on that. The tenders are nothing special. They are on the kids menu, but they cost the same as tenders anywhere else. The chili is pretty good, and a good buy for $5.50 (get it with cheese). Just spicy enough to be kind of spicy. It'd probably be great on a hotdog, but like, byohotdog I guess. Oh, and the fries are delicious. Non-frozen, fresh cut. I don't know what they're fried in, but they seem fresh every time. So that's my take on pretty much everything available here. Overall, very highly recommended place to try. All the bread and ingredients are excellent, and all their sandwiches use unique and delicious sauces. They put in the work to put their own signature feel on their sandwiches that will set them above the stuff you'd get from a regular deli or diner. You also get free fudge with your meals. Maybe it's just the summer heat, but mine is always in the consistency of hot fudge. I recommend putting in the freezer. It's also fine enough to dissolve completely into your coffee and chocolate it up.
When I received my bag it had a Lil piece of fudge attached to it I instantly pulled it off and decided it should be eaten first. At that point I had to make grown women decisions as to was I gonna be late to my appt or go back for more I mean it was that darn good. Wait and the sauces are tasty like the south on point.
Speedy service, great value, and fresh food. Honestly was pretty surprised at how good it is. Definitely going to be a regular in my lunch rotation.
Love this place. Gluten Free bread option. Excellently executed sandwiches. Staff is always cranking things out and are super nice. They give free fudge with each order. The brisket is so very good, albeit a bit heavy so I can't get it every time. I love that their club uses the Alabama White sauce instead of regular mayo--that sauce smacks. Also they make Greta thick cut, but not floppy, bacon. They serve fresh cut fries (aka five guys style) and that is my fave. You will be stuffed!
First time trying after seeing it around a bunch. Everything was great! Brisket sandwiches were huge, tender and flavorful, definitely a must try. Chicken sandwich was great too! Staff was friendly, quick, and clean! Great first experience and will definitely be back!
Have been hearing nothing but good things about this joint for a while. Finally made it in and was not disappointed. Sandwiches were delicious and the fries were on point. Look forward to trying it many more times.
Run don't walk. This sandwich shop is amazing. I was excited as I read the menu, brisket, turkey and roast beef prepared in house. Hand cut fries, pimento cheese, coleslaw, pickled jalapenos all homemade. The pimento cheese and toast was so tasty I had a hard time stopping, but my sandwich was ready. The brisket was tender and smokey, the coleslaw was perfect and I loved the sweetness of the pickled jalapenos. I got my sauce on the side and didn't even add it. My friend and I couldn't stop eating the fries... they were hot, crispy, just a little salty and delicious....we didn't even put ketchup on. My friend has lots of food sensitivities so when she saw everything was house made, she was very happy and ate her entire roast beef sandwich. She couldn't stop raving about the flavor and how much she was enjoying it. Don't forget they give you a small piece of fudge! Perfect ending. Everyone greeted us warmly and the service was friendly and fast.
Love Peachtree! The sandwiches are delicious and the service is friendly and excellent. Their specialty is house made bacon and it is delicious! The fries aren't too shabby either!
Love the chicken and bacon signature sandwiches so it was an easy choice to order catering for an office meeting. The sandwiches were individually wrapped and labeled to eliminate digging through and the salads were packed to capacity. The cookie/fudge platter was a hit as well.
Restaurantji Recommends
Good sandwich- bread a little dry. Are the employees on some kind of prison work relief program? Some tough hombres. Didn't care for the fudge.
Wowwwwww this place is amazing. Recently moved to DeWitt and everyone suggested checking this place out and it did not disappoint! Can't wait to come back and try everything else.
This little sandwich shop is the bomb diggety!! FRESH food the is packed with flavor!! Owner/chef is on top of every detail. He has more staff on shift that makes sense. Everyone is working hard and seem pretty happy to be there. Kudos to the owner for running a class A joint!!
Delicious Sandwiches! I had the chicken sandwich and it was one of the best I've had!
Unbelievable. Most underrated sandwich shop in DeWitt AND Syracuse. The brisket is the best sandwich I have ever had in my 20 years of living and that could not be more truthful.