DeWitt Bagel

$ • Bagels, Coffee Shops, Kosher

Menu Order Online

About DeWitt Bagel

DeWitt Bagel is a popular local spot known for its delicious bagels and variety of cream cheeses. Customers frequently praise the bagels for their freshness, great flavor, and crisp texture, comparing them favorably to those in NYC. The shop offers a wide selection of bagels, including favorite varieties like salt bagels, and has options for those with gluten sensitivities, such as GF bagels. Many reviews highlight the quality of their cream cheese and the good taste of their coffee. The menu also includes items like scrambled eggs on bagels with sausage, though some customers mention receiving fried eggs instead of scrambled, but they remain eager to return and try again. The shop sells locally made goodies, which can vary with the season, and provides a reward punch card for loyal customers. Overall, DeWitt Bagel is highly recommended for its fresh, flavorful bagels and friendly atmosphere, making it a favorite for bagel lovers who are willing to travel for this "bagel sandwich shop."

Customers' Favorites

blt Sandiwch with Your Choice of Bagel

Bagel with Nova Lox Cream Cheese

Lox N' Loaded Sandwich

Bagel with Egg & Meat

Ol' Faithful Sandwich

Cream Cheese and Lox

Baker's Dozen Bagels

The Cuban Sandwich

The Critz Sandwich

Bagel with Butter

+7 more Show less

Photos

Add a Photo

View All Photos

DeWitt Bagel Reviews

4.1

175 ratings

70%

10%

Food

Atmosphere

Service

Share your opinion about DeWitt Bagel

Write a review

I have been looking for a bialy for some time and while there are plenty of places that make bagels, so few have bialy on their menu. I found the bialy here to have very good texture and flavor, but wish there was more onion and poppy seed, which is very traditional on a bialy.

Staff was very kind. Came here specifically for a gluten free breakfast sandwich and it was delicious. Only negative the seating area and coffee counter were dirty.

They are always amazing.

Read All Reviews(175)