Mercato Roman Pizza

31 NY-303, Tappan
(845) 606-9000

Recent Reviews

Samarra Abuhouran

Everything about Mercato is incredible. The food is absolutely delicious, the staff and service is fantastic, and the ambiance is great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Larry F.

Called in advance inquiring about available tables and was told no reservation needed Arrived 30 minutes later and the back was filled with a party They offered us a table at the door in the front window No ambiance cold and crowded We were one of three couples that walked out Poor customer service

Andrew B.

The veal & ricotta meatballs were delicious and the pinsa pizza is excellent too. Not a fan of the shrimp scampi pizza, but we will definitely be back.

Nancy S.

We found this place on a spur of the moment lunch date decision and so glad we did as we really enjoyed ourselves so much. The pizza is fantastic and we also enjoyed a shrimp app with this incredible tomato sauce and got cheese served with some crust to soak up that yummy sauce. The owner Stephanie I think is her name was so welcoming and even let our dog come join us as it was late and not crowded in the front. Our service was perfect too and I will return for sure maybe for dinner to try the other pasta dishes and more pizza.

Alison C.

4.5 stars My family and I decided to order takeout from Mercato Roman Pizza the other night and were glad that we did. The menu was limited, but also very innovative. We had been craving pizza, so we wound up ordering 3 of those, as well as some meatballs to start. When we arrived at the restaurant to gather our items, we were in awe of its cute, cozy nature. The wood-burning oven added a real warmth to the already adorable space, which was also BYOB. The ride back home was tough, as the smell of the food was extremely enticing. Once we arrived home, we immediately proceeded to fix ourselves plates of the yummy looking dishes. The Veal and Ricotta Meatballs were light, fluffy, and stuffed with ricotta cheese. They were served in a savory San Marzano tomato sauce that was perfect for dipping into with the included Sourdough Crostini. In the end, I was extra grateful for the red sauce, as our pizzas offered very little of it. The pies were made on extremely thin, crispy crusts, made of sourdough with lower carbs and gluten. The Truffle Potato variety was topped with thinly-sliced, Yukon potatoes, fresh rosemary, extra virgin olive oil, and truffled sottocenere cheese. The sottocenere was aromatic and flavorful, but the roasted rosemary sprigs really brought life to each slice. The Shrimp Scampi pie used an interesting cheese blend of Caciocavallo, Parmesano, and Pecorino. It was lightly kissed with what they called a "Tomato Mushroom Cloud" that was heavily garnished with garlic bread crumbs, which really made this a flavor powerhouse. Each slice was also topped with a large tiger shrimp, which were supposed to be marinated, but were actually plain and undercooked. I would have really loved this pizza best if the shrimp had been more cooked through. Instead, my favorite pie was the Prosciutto di Parma one, which was served at room temperature, likely to preserve the quality of the meat, which had been aged for 36 months. The tender, thinly-sliced prosciutto was draped over layers of fresh mozzarella, blistered tomatoes, and arugula. Aged balsamic vinegar had been drizzled over the top, but also managed to bake into the crust. That pizza was pure perfection! We were thrilled with everything that we ate and planned to go to Mercato to see how the pizza would differ when it was eaten live. I am sure the pizza would be gooier and cheesier, while the warm environment would provide a delightful environment to further enhance the culinary experience.

Joanne D.

The most delicious pizza If you like regular NYC pizza this is upscale and delicious and the crust is from heaven All toppings are delicious and perfectly created! Just order the pizza on the menu! The one with truffle honey is to die for Has a nice cocktail also

Stephen Lynch

Excellent pizza made by a group of people who care about what they're doing and have passion for making their guests feel welcome.My wife and I have been there many times and we've never been disappointed. She's vegetarian and I'll eat virtually anything and we never have problems splitting dishes, sharing etc.Enjoy a restaurant doing things the right way... hopefully for a very long time.Kid-friendliness: I would say this is more of an adult restaurant but it can work with kidsWheelchair accessibility: It's a bit tight so I don't think it's great for wheelchairs but could work. It wouldn't be easy

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza, Ceasar Salad, Lemon Semifreddo, Garlic Bread, Truffle Potato, Pepperoni Pizza, Pizzas, Wild Mushroom Pinsa, Chopped Salad, Sausage Pinsa, Wood Roasted Cauliflower

dilshod khamdamov

Prices are a bit high. But it's worth it! Pizza is

Food: 5

Chav Landau

This place was really great! The pizza /crust is delicious and the salad and pastas are so good. The service was lovely! I’ll be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ceasar Salad, Pizzas

Michelle W.

A taste of Italy, but at home! My husband and I have had carryout, and just recently dined in at Mercato and have thoroughly enjoyed ourselves in each setting. The quality of ingredients is second-to-none, and exemplified the Italian attitude of great quality and simple ingredients producing a great result. Highly recommend the diablo pizza, the aglio olio pasta and arancini. Can't wait to return!

Steve Rozzo

I took a customer to lunch and we had a great afternoon. Service and food were excellent. Prices were reasonable and atmosphere was very chill.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Pepperoni Pizza, Fettuchini Carbonara

Albert Maniscalco

Kid-friendliness: They always have old movies playing on the back wall which keeps their attention.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Margherita Pinsa, Pizzas

Scott Rosenberg

Beautiful space in strip mall.Very welcoming staff.Outstanding pasta& pizza!Reasonable prices.Fabulous bolognese!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian B.

Pizza was excellent. Light, crispy, fresh and quality ingredients. Also had a fresh pasta dish once. That was also quite good. I have only had take out but will definitely try dining in. Really, really good. Service was good but a bit goofy, otherwise 5 stars.

Tiffany Henriques

Such a great dinner here, we really enjoyed the pizza and salads!! Highly recommend. Also such a great vibe inside!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Margherita Pinsa, Ceasar Salad, Pepperoni Pizza, Pizzas, Sausage Pinsa

Load More