The Old '76 House

$$ • American, Bars, Pet Friendly

Hours:
110 Main St, Tappan
(845) 359-5476

About The Old '76 House

The Old '76 House offers a perfect dining experience with delicious food and great service in a historical setting. The attentive staff, like Joe, contributes to a fun atmosphere, sharing interesting facts about the tavern's past. The menu may feel a little dated by some, but the overall experience remains amazing. Customers have praised dishes such as the jagerschnitzel for its crispy texture and sweet red cabbage, and the chicken cordon bleu for its unbelievable tenderness. The venison medallions are also noted for their good flavor, complemented well by a compote. While the pot roast is described as fork tender, some found the accompanying popover slightly bitter.

Although the veggies served with most dishes could use more flavor, the restaurant's atmosphere and history make it a must-visit destination. The cocktails, however, could be improved, as some guests have reported issues with drinks like the old fashioned and Irish coffee. Despite a few critiques, the desserts, particularly the creme brulee, continue to impress. The Old '76 House is a great spot for both special celebrations and regular visits, with a decent gluten-free selection and a blend of history and good food.

Customers' Favorites

The Old '76 House Reviews

4.6
302 ratings
Restaurantji Rating
5
80%
4
8%
3
5%
2
2%
1
5%
Food
4.6
Atmosphere
4.8
Service
4.7

Share your opinion about The Old '76 House

Restaurantji Rating

Read All Reviews(302)

Ratings

Menu

Add a Menu
The Old '76 House Menu
The Old '76 House Menu

Photos

Add a Photo
The Old '76 House
The Old '76 House
View All Photos

Hours

Monday 5 - 9PM
12 - 3PM
Tuesday 5 - 9PM
12 - 3PM
Wednesday 5 - 9PM
12 - 3PM
Thursday 12 - 3PM
5 - 9PM
Friday 5 - 10PM
12 - 3PM
Saturday 5 - 10PM
12 - 3PM
Sunday 12 - 8PM
Updated on: