The oldest Tavern in America and still a great place to eat. We went here for a Valentine's day lunch and had a great experience. The food was excellent with a variety of menu choices. The service was good and for history buffs the atmosphere can't be beat. Washington liked to eat here and Hamilton lived upstairs for two years wow. The food was the standout hot and delicious. We will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Leo Senyk
Good service, Many fun foods to try: Scallops, Wild Venison, NY local trout, Duck l’orange If you are looking for healthy options but also indulging options this is the place to go. Good historic vibes.
tanya lee
Unbelievable meal. Can’t wait to go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ross P
This was our first visit to the 76 House and it was incredible! Everything exceeded my expectations. I’ve been wanting to go for years, and we just never made it up there. We finally decided to go for a special occasion and it did not disappoint! The manager, Meghan, and our server, Laly, went above and beyond to make our evening special and memorable. The building is beautiful, and full of history dating back to the Revolutionary war. There was classical live music that was enjoyable but not intrusive. The service was attentive but not pushy. The food was delicious - hats off to the chef. One of the best meals we had in years. The onion soup was perfection. My only regret was not getting the tableside Caesar salad! We were smiling the whole way home. This place is classic dining, reminiscent of an era when dinner out was an event, but current, and in a charming, historic setting. Thank you for such a great evening!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jonathan V. Murray, Sotheby's Realtor
Really enjoyed my first experience at America's Oldest Tavern. Menu has all the staples including a few unique options such as duck, alligator & ostrich. Salads, Burgers, Turkey, Meatloaf, Seafood. I got the Chicken pot pie. Historical decor and inviting ambiance. Great food and friendly staff! Large Parking lot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeanne Knapp
We brunched for 5 hours at a cozy table by the fireplace. The buffet was plentiful and fresh. Our server Joe was super friendly; he and the hostess were very accommodating and welcoming us to stay and enjoy ourselves long after the check was paid and brunch had ended. We really appreciate a restaurant that lets you linger!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Abe Van Beveren III
Great colonial atmosphere that is truly historic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Don McVinnie
Such a charming, unique restaurant seeped in history. The owner was clearly very passionate about it's history and this really elevated the experience at the restaurant. The food was good but I definitely had food envy when someone else at the table ordered the lasagne which was exceptional. There was a superb band playing, with the volume and choice of the music at the perfect level.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Jim Raevis
Awesome historical experience. Great food & friendly employees!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
CL D (CLD0055)
I just for a quick beer or 2. Very cool place, very good service.
One of my favorite fall and winter spots. Great service warm cozy atmosphere. French onion soup and pot roast a must.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
V M
We had our first visit, yesterday evening. Was definitely worth the 60 mile drive. The hostess was informative, friendly, and accommodating The bartender was amazing and extremely helpful. The history and atmosphere was absolutely beautiful and comfortable Food and drinks were fantastic. Unfortunately, the service was subpar at best. Our server seem to have very little interest in helping us out or answering questions, almost to the point where it was awkward,. She r didn’t care to much to answer questions, short one word answers with very little information. There were long stretches of time where we didn’t even see her, but that was fine. I understand people are very busy and sitting in there for hours was not really a bad thing. We had a very good time, the bartender and another server stepped into help,. That was very appreciated, Especially since we didn’t even ask. Hey, we all have a bad days, Definitely recommend and I definitely will be returning,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Thomas Flessas
We've been here several times and it's always great. Awesome building and staff. We've had retirement dinners, birthdays, and anniversaries here. Tappan in general is very good for dining, there are a lot of great places to try out but this is one of our favorites. I wouldn't get it on your first trip in, but the yankee pot roast is a great home styled dish that is amazing! The desserts are great, I like the apple pie and crème brûlée. Can be a little loud when at capacity, I like going on slower nights. Love this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kelly Hendel
The historic setting is well worth at least one dining experience here. Colonial charm radiates from every original plank and beam and you half expect George Washington to walk through the main entrance. The service is consistently good. The food is fine overall and a few things we've ordered over several visits stand out as exceptional including Duckling Hamilton, Grilled Flatbread, Chicken Pot Pie,The American Bread Pudding and The '76 Tavern Burger which my husband talked about for weeks afterwards. There was a small mishap with one of the bartenders on our last visit which soured the experience, but the waitress and presumably the manager were quick to acknowledge and make amends without any prompting from us. That is unheard of in today's dining landscape and appreciated. Depending on the type of live music it can be so loud you can't converse without shouting.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
JACQUELINE E
Love the coziness and rich history of this place. The food was beautifully prepared and delicious.
The oldest Tavern in America and still a great place to eat. We went here for a Valentine's day lunch and had a great experience. The food was excellent with a variety of menu choices. The service was good and for history buffs the atmosphere can't be beat. Washington liked to eat here and Hamilton lived upstairs for two years wow. The food was the standout hot and delicious. We will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Good service,
Many fun foods to try:
Scallops,
Wild Venison,
NY local trout,
Duck l’orange
If you are looking for healthy options but also indulging options this is the place to go. Good historic vibes.
Unbelievable meal. Can’t wait to go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was our first visit to the 76 House and it was incredible! Everything exceeded my expectations. I’ve been wanting to go for years, and we just never made it up there. We finally decided to go for a special occasion and it did not disappoint! The manager, Meghan, and our server, Laly, went above and beyond to make our evening special and memorable. The building is beautiful, and full of history dating back to the Revolutionary war. There was classical live music that was enjoyable but not intrusive. The service was attentive but not pushy. The food was delicious - hats off to the chef. One of the best meals we had in years. The onion soup was perfection. My only regret was not getting the tableside Caesar salad! We were smiling the whole way home. This place is classic dining, reminiscent of an era when dinner out was an event, but current, and in a charming, historic setting. Thank you for such a great evening!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really enjoyed my first experience at America's Oldest Tavern. Menu has all the staples including a few unique options such as duck, alligator & ostrich. Salads, Burgers, Turkey, Meatloaf, Seafood. I got the Chicken pot pie. Historical decor and inviting ambiance. Great food and friendly staff! Large Parking lot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We brunched for 5 hours at a cozy table by the fireplace. The buffet was plentiful and fresh. Our server Joe was super friendly; he and the hostess were very accommodating and welcoming us to stay and enjoy ourselves long after the check was paid and brunch had ended. We really appreciate a restaurant that lets you linger!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great colonial atmosphere that is truly historic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Such a charming, unique restaurant seeped in history. The owner was clearly very passionate about it's history and this really elevated the experience at the restaurant. The food was good but I definitely had food envy when someone else at the table ordered the lasagne which was exceptional. There was a superb band playing, with the volume and choice of the music at the perfect level.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Awesome historical experience. Great food & friendly employees!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I just for a quick beer or 2. Very cool place, very good service.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
One of my favorite fall and winter spots. Great service warm cozy atmosphere. French onion soup and pot roast a must.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had our first visit, yesterday evening. Was definitely worth the 60 mile drive.
The hostess was informative, friendly, and accommodating
The bartender was amazing and extremely helpful.
The history and atmosphere was absolutely beautiful and comfortable
Food and drinks were fantastic.
Unfortunately, the service was subpar at best. Our server seem to have very little interest in helping us out or answering questions, almost to the point where it was awkward,. She r didn’t care to much to answer questions, short one word answers with very little information. There were long stretches of time where we didn’t even see her, but that was fine. I understand people are very busy and sitting in there for hours was not really a bad thing. We had a very good time, the bartender and another server stepped into help,. That was very appreciated, Especially since we didn’t even ask.
Hey, we all have a bad days, Definitely recommend and I definitely will be returning,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
We've been here several times and it's always great. Awesome building and staff. We've had retirement dinners, birthdays, and anniversaries here. Tappan in general is very good for dining, there are a lot of great places to try out but this is one of our favorites. I wouldn't get it on your first trip in, but the yankee pot roast is a great home styled dish that is amazing! The desserts are great, I like the apple pie and crème brûlée. Can be a little loud when at capacity, I like going on slower nights. Love this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The historic setting is well worth at least one dining experience here. Colonial charm radiates from every original plank and beam and you half expect George Washington to walk through the main entrance. The service is consistently good. The food is fine overall and a few things we've ordered over several visits stand out as exceptional including Duckling Hamilton, Grilled Flatbread, Chicken Pot Pie,The American Bread Pudding and The '76 Tavern Burger which my husband talked about for weeks afterwards. There was a small mishap with one of the bartenders on our last visit which soured the experience, but the waitress and presumably the manager were quick to acknowledge and make amends without any prompting from us. That is unheard of in today's dining landscape and appreciated. Depending on the type of live music it can be so loud you can't converse without shouting.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Love the coziness and rich history of this place. The food was beautifully prepared and delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...