Main Street Sweets

35 Main St, Tarrytown
(914) 332-5757

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Paris Williams

Main Street Sweets is a very cute ice cream shop the employees are really nice and helpful. They do have a large selection of in-house made ice cream however, I found the flavors to be a little bit bland and not as bold and flavorful as other ice cream shops I’ve tried. The cupcake ice cream flavor was basically vanilla with sprinkles in it. I’ve had better at other places.

Richard

Homemade ice cream, delicious

Tom Holmes

Great home made ice cream! Better than Ben & Jerry's!

Marlon Small

Surprisingly rude service

L L

Love this place! It’s honestly one of the cutest spots I’ve been to, and the vibe alone makes you want to keep coming back. But the real star here is the ice cream. Their homemade ice cream is hands down some of the best I’ve ever had creamy, fresh, and packed with flavor in every bite.

What really impressed me is how good their vegan ice cream is. A lot of places treat vegan options as an afterthought, but here they taste just as rich and satisfying as the regular flavors. You’d never know the difference!

They have such a fun mix of unique flavors alongside the classics, so whether you’re adventurous or just craving your go-to favorite, you’ll find something to love. Every time I come, I’m tempted to try something new.

The staff is super friendly too, which adds to the whole experience. It’s clear they care about the quality of what they make and the happiness of their customers. Between the atmosphere, the service, and the ice cream itself, this place is a gem.

Highly recommend stopping by you’ll fall in love with it just like I did!

Andrea van Hintum (Avh)

5 even 10 stars all the way! Mint chocolate chip was delicious!! My recommendation though, adding some gluten free pastries would be awesome!!

Ron Cherry

Main Street Special is off the charts. Thanks for the recommendation Jordan C!

Johana B (Hana)

Would rate it a 7/10, but maybe that’s because I ordered a coffee flavor.. which was called the “main street special” but it’s good, you can never go wrong with ice cream, love love love ❤️

Vincent Cannizzaro

Always awesome

Renee Lakatos

Homemade ice cream and cones! About 32 different flavors plus other sweet treats. Inside and outside seating. It’s busy! Staff is friendly. We had a flavor called Devon’s Dream. Vanilla with different chocolate chips both white and dark, plus Reece’s! Amazing!

rental inthecity

I can see why this ice cream shop has been around for a quarter of a century! Their ice cream is flavorful and the service is great!

Glenn

Ice Cream! What’s better on a hot Summer day than a cool cup of ice cream?!!! Delicious flavors, served at perfect “eat it up” temperature with spoons up to the moon! (Sturdy!). Love it!!

Greg Bunce

Best ice cream shop I've been to in ages!!

Miriam V.N

Wow! First time in this place and they have a lot of variety of flavors and toppings. Also they have 3 flavors for vegans 🌱
It seemed very busy but was quickly to got our ice creams 🍨

Rebecca Richardson

I was extremely excited to try main streets sweets (my friend recommend it to me). There was MOLD on the cakes, see for yourself.

Loading...