Noble Pies

We tried the chicken pot pie, pumpkin and cherry and all were absolutely incredible! Cherry was maybe the highlight. You can taste the butter in the crust and quality of the ingredients.

Service was also excellent! Thank you :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Pot Pie

No apple pie at 9 am on a Sunday as they don't get deliveries until later in the day. What’s the point of being open before getting something to sell?

Omg, this was the best pecan pie I’ve ever eaten. I wish I can come back again for more!! My friend had the cherry pie and she felt the same way. I have to come back again when I’m in town.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Update update.... my 3 year old said wow this pie is yummy so very very yummy wow! She was talking about the black dirt chocolate cream every bite she kept saying wow this is good delicious so yummy
Update : The Owners are so nice and again the pie is amazing so hoping to get a pie really soon!.....I was really excited to finally visit the store after receiving their pies as a gift and thinking about it for a while. Since I was in Westchester, I figured I’d give it a try. Unfortunately, when I got there, a post-it on the door said they closed at 2:45 today. Such a bummer! Still, I’d definitely recommend trying it if you’re local, but if you’re not from Tarrytown, be sure to call ahead on Mondays to confirm their hours.

Food: 5

Got a blueberry pie yesterday which I'm returning for a refund. It's a silly piece of fermenting blueberry nonsense. You have got to be a fool to buy pie from these people.

Constantly closed due to staff shortages. Is it that difficult to staff a 300sq ft store?
Wasted an hour for a closed store. Never again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

A surreal culinary experience. We got the peach pie (warmed up of course) and the apricot/orange ice cream. Both were heavenly. Anthony was super helpful and kind! Made us feel like regulars.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Key lime pie with no cream , broken crust no lime decoration. I could have made this myself, it wasnt that tasty either. Not worth the exorbitant cost.

Let me start by saying I have never liked pie. One day I was at a local farmers market and saw a mini blueberry pie and bought it for my son. When I offered it to him he passed on it and I tried it so it wouldn’t go to waste. It was delicious. I thought it was a fluke because pie is gross. I’ve day while riding around Tarrytown I saw the noble pie store front and remembered that yummy mini pie so I went in and purchased 6 inch blueberry crumb pie. Got home and tried a bite as I was starting to cook dinner. The pieces gone before dinner was done. “Am I a pie person?!?!”, I asked my husband. For an entire week after I could not get the pie off my mind so I decided to return to the pie shop and I tried a slice of the beach pie. WOW!!!! Incredibly creamy, fresh, and a buttery/ salty saltine cracker crust. WHO IN THE WORLD THOUGHT THIS UP?! Long story short go visit them and buy all the pies! They are perfection you won’t be disappointed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Seriously good pies. Very small, but I’ve never been to the back patio are. We usually pick up and bring it home. But these pies… they’re so good. There’s a big step up into the front door, so not wheelchair friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mighty delicious pie. The apple pie felt like it followed every trick in the Serious Eats guide for perfect apple pie. I think they used several varieties of apples so that some bake into mush and provide thickening, while some remain crisp and tart. The crust was flaky with clearly visible layers. It was sweet but not too sweet. The chicken pot pie and lime pie were also delicious. A small amount of seating is provided at the back of the store.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A popular pie shop headquartered in Warwick, New Jersey.

Pecan pie and key lime pie are very delicious.
Hudson Valley apple pie seems to be popular, but blueberry pie is also great.

I tend to buy too much when I go to this store, but I always finish it all. We are particular about the ingredients we use, and this is a pie that brings out the flavor of the ingredients, which is different from the overly sweet cakes that are common in America. It should also fit under Japanese people.

They also have a branch in Rye.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place is a small hole in the wall but don't let it's size fool you. I judge a dessert place by the quality of its strawberry rhubarb pie. Strawberry Rhubarb pie has been my favorite pie ever since I was a kid. This place is the place for all you strawberry rhubarb pie lovers out there. Remember to have them put whipped cream on it. MMMMMM Yum!!!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

World’s most average cherry pie- in styrofoam packing if you’re taking to go!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Absolutely love this place - pies are delicious and service is wonderful!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5