This used to be our FAVORITE place - we raved about it to everyone!! Ordered tonight and it’s NOT the same!! The chicken looks gross and is half the size as it was and yet the same price. Pizza totally different too. Also took forever to get through to someone and they are not longer on Slice to order online? Never ordering from here again, im so sad
Nick Cosgrove
This restaurant is under new ownership and the pizza is not the same. It has gone down the tubes. First off, trying to call and place an order took forever for someone to actually answer the phone. Second, they have the same menu, but do not make the pizzas the same way. Lastly, the staff was rude when I called to tell them my order was wrong. This place used to be good, now I won’t order here anymore.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Emile Gable
Excellent pizza. In my opinion, much better than any of the other places around. They use an actual brick oven, wood fired. Pizzas and sauce are well seasoned, fresh ingredients, excellent dough, similar to a wood fired you’d find in the city.
Autumn Sierra
First time here, I ordered the Margherita wrap with a side of fries. Both were delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Thomas Mauriello
Solid brick oven pizza here at Margherita Pizza. Small shop, nothing fancy in a small, newish strip mall. A couple tables outside.
Nice crunchy pizza. We had the clam pizza, Would like to try regular cheese pie (almost wish I ordered the) to get a better comparison between other pie shops. Hope to return for that slice.
Place was quite hoppin with pick up orders and quite a few people seated. They have the full range of other Italian dishes which I did not try (yet).
Solid.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Edison Logu
Today, I visited Margherita Pizza with my family, and since we were in the area, we decided to enjoy some pizza. I must say, the wood-fired pizza was fantastic, accompanied by great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pen Pencil
Better than any pizza place north of it in Westchester.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Denise Dossantos
I got delivery. Ordered a pasta fagoli, and a 12' classic ny pizza. It was absolutely delicious! Crust was perfectly crunch and sauce was delicious. Soup was hot upon delivery and very tasty. Will definitely order from here again.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Helen Kitsios
I ordered from there for the first time, a Chicken Parm pizza, a pepperoni pizza and a chicken parm panini. Everything was great. I went in to pick it up and was greeted with friendliness, warmth and courtesy. This is my new pizzeria!! I love the personal touches. It’s very quaint inside and they even have a couple of cute tables out in front.
No one should order delivery from these people because they are very slow in preparing the food. If you order from them for delivery, they will speed up the work, otherwise your food will be delayed by thirty minutes, or even an hour.
chris nova
Some of the best pizza in westchester. No doubt
Aidan Ekelund
So happy this place is around - best lasagna pie!!! They use Italian flour and it makes all the difference. Also would recommend the Italian Mole-Cola
The staff is always friendly and attentive, making each visit feel special. If you're looking for a place that serves not just great food but a genuine Italian dining experience, this pizzeria hits the mark every time!
Christopher N
This is one of my favorite pizza spots!!!!! I always get a Lasagna Pie, I love it every time, they never disappoint. I also get the zeppoles with Nutella for dessert, those are the best. Not everyone makes zeppoles the way I like it, and the Nutella is addicting.
Everyone in there treats me great and they are very welcoming. I always eat my pie inside and it is a great place to be. They over extend themselves every time I’m there.
I will always come here!!!!!!!! Been coming since they opened.
Everything looks good when I get there.
You won’t regret eating here.
I also appreciate all their beverage options.
Larry Nissman
Not sure if I have already reviewed this place, but I have eaten here many times now and it can't hurt to say again how good the pizza is. Definitely the best crust around. I usually have the standard plain slices and occasionally the square pepperoni slice. Always consistent and excellent.
This used to be our FAVORITE place - we raved about it to everyone!! Ordered tonight and it’s NOT the same!! The chicken looks gross and is half the size as it was and yet the same price. Pizza totally different too. Also took forever to get through to someone and they are not longer on Slice to order online? Never ordering from here again, im so sad
This restaurant is under new ownership and the pizza is not the same. It has gone down the tubes. First off, trying to call and place an order took forever for someone to actually answer the phone. Second, they have the same menu, but do not make the pizzas the same way. Lastly, the staff was rude when I called to tell them my order was wrong. This place used to be good, now I won’t order here anymore.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Excellent pizza. In my opinion, much better than any of the other places around. They use an actual brick oven, wood fired. Pizzas and sauce are well seasoned, fresh ingredients, excellent dough, similar to a wood fired you’d find in the city.
First time here, I ordered the Margherita wrap with a side of fries. Both were delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Solid brick oven pizza here at Margherita Pizza. Small shop, nothing fancy in a small, newish strip mall. A couple tables outside.
Nice crunchy pizza. We had the clam pizza, Would like to try regular cheese pie (almost wish I ordered the) to get a better comparison between other pie shops. Hope to return for that slice.
Place was quite hoppin with pick up orders and quite a few people seated. They have the full range of other Italian dishes which I did not try (yet).
Solid.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Today, I visited Margherita Pizza with my family, and since we were in the area, we decided to enjoy some pizza. I must say, the wood-fired pizza was fantastic, accompanied by great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Better than any pizza place north of it in Westchester.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I got delivery. Ordered a pasta fagoli, and a 12' classic ny pizza. It was absolutely delicious! Crust was perfectly crunch and sauce was delicious. Soup was hot upon delivery and very tasty. Will definitely order from here again.
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered from there for the first time, a Chicken Parm pizza, a pepperoni pizza and a chicken parm panini. Everything was great. I went in to pick it up and was greeted with friendliness, warmth and courtesy. This is my new pizzeria!! I love the personal touches. It’s very quaint inside and they even have a couple of cute tables out in front.
Sicilian Pizza AMAZING
Restaurantji Recommends
No one should order delivery from these people because they are very slow in preparing the food. If you order from them for delivery, they will speed up the work, otherwise your food will be delayed by thirty minutes, or even an hour.
Some of the best pizza in westchester. No doubt
So happy this place is around - best lasagna pie!!! They use Italian flour and it makes all the difference. Also would recommend the Italian Mole-Cola
The staff is always friendly and attentive, making each visit feel special. If you're looking for a place that serves not just great food but a genuine Italian dining experience, this pizzeria hits the mark every time!
This is one of my favorite pizza spots!!!!!
I always get a Lasagna Pie, I love it every time, they never disappoint.
I also get the zeppoles with Nutella for dessert, those are the best. Not everyone makes zeppoles the way I like it, and the Nutella is addicting.
Everyone in there treats me great and they are very welcoming.
I always eat my pie inside and it is a great place to be.
They over extend themselves every time I’m there.
I will always come here!!!!!!!! Been coming since they opened.
Everything looks good when I get there.
You won’t regret eating here.
I also appreciate all their beverage options.
Not sure if I have already reviewed this place, but I have eaten here many times now and it can't hurt to say again how good the pizza is. Definitely the best crust around. I usually have the standard plain slices and occasionally the square pepperoni slice. Always consistent and excellent.
Loading...