I tried Gino's Sicilian Pizza for the first time and went with their Sicilian pizza — and wow, I’m so impressed! 🍕😍 If you’re a fan of a thicker crust and a more doughy, hearty pizza, this is definitely the place for you. Every bite was flavorful, cheesy, and perfectly baked, with that classic Sicilian texture that just melts in your mouth 🧀🔥 The pizza is filling and satisfying, perfect for sharing or enjoying all to yourself if you’re really hungry 😋 The toppings were fresh, the sauce had great flavor, and the crust had that ideal balance of soft inside and slight crisp on the edges 🍅✨ Overall, my first experience here was fantastic, and I’ll absolutely be coming back for more. If you haven’t tried Gino’s Sicilian pizza yet, you’re seriously missing out — highly recommend giving it a try! 🌟🍕💯
We are in from out of town ( although I grew up around here) and wanted good 'Buffalo' pizza. We're so glad we chose Gino's! Everything about the pepperoni, mushroom, olive, onion, and sausage pizza was absolutely perfect, from the the generous amount of toppings to the perfectly baked crust (no one in the Southern Tier gets the middle cooked thoroughly). My husband surprised me by also ordering wings and they were delicious...crispy cooked and sauced properly. Great job!
Food: 5
Nick Caesar
Went to get food at Gino’s late at night with a few friends. They delivered excellent service to us quickly cooking us up some fresh slices that were delicious. The fostered a good atmosphere to sit down and talk with some of the guys.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Josh Rochevot
Recently moved nearby, roommates said they were not too happy, so I didnt bother , then one day I decided to give it a try, ordered a stinger, man with heavy accent said he wouldnt make a half sub, even tho its on the menu also on the website for order etc... so I decide to get the whole sub... ends up costing an even $17 and was skimpy esp for such a high cost , you would think with all the competition nearby they would care. . Seemed to be one whole chicken finger split through the entire whole sub and steak was skimpy as well.. I dont usually bother with reviews but I felt this one was necessary.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Tracy
They never have slices ready. This is my third time coming in and today was my last. I didn’t want to leave a bad review but crap I don’t know what to say because there’s always a 15 minute wait for slices. Went to John’s Pizza instead.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Justin
Solid lil joint in Tonawanda. Never had a bad slice from them, usually my quick bite stop every here and there. Workers ain’t the most friendly but they’re chill. Solid pizza and fingers. Wish they had a public restroom though
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
BMH
Perfect Buffalo neighborhood style pizza spot. Gino is often there keeping everything moving smoothly. T.V. plays sports. Good team, great pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Sheridan
Love Gino's Pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jamie F
It's hard to find good Sicilian pizza in the Buffalo area. Their Sicilian was excellent, definitely will get another Sicilian pie in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
E T
Famous for their Buffalo Style pizza; the pizza was oozing with cheese that overflowed on every slice we took from the box. They did not cheap put on the cheese at all when we ordered the classic. This location specifically was a little run-down, and the patio was closed. But the quality and popularity of their pizza makes up for it.
First time trying. Pizza was delicious nice and crispy bottom definitely going back oh and the wings soild 10
Mizuno Yui
One of my favorite buffalo style pizzas in wny
Dylan Ramback
good food, bomb wings, got stoned and ate some wings and they were goof
Pete Lowry
Solid Pizza!
Prathamesh Kulkarni
It's good Buffalo style pizza. Doughy airy thick crust, lots of cheese, sweet sauce and cup and char pepperoni. Not exactly my style (I prefer NY style pizza), but I enjoyed their pepperoni pizza. It's not greasy and comes well seasoned which is a plus. The sauce is very sweet, though to be fair that is how pizza is made in Buffalo.
I tried Gino's Sicilian Pizza for the first time and went with their Sicilian pizza — and wow, I’m so impressed! 🍕😍 If you’re a fan of a thicker crust and a more doughy, hearty pizza, this is definitely the place for you. Every bite was flavorful, cheesy, and perfectly baked, with that classic Sicilian texture that just melts in your mouth 🧀🔥
The pizza is filling and satisfying, perfect for sharing or enjoying all to yourself if you’re really hungry 😋 The toppings were fresh, the sauce had great flavor, and the crust had that ideal balance of soft inside and slight crisp on the edges 🍅✨
Overall, my first experience here was fantastic, and I’ll absolutely be coming back for more. If you haven’t tried Gino’s Sicilian pizza yet, you’re seriously missing out — highly recommend giving it a try! 🌟🍕💯
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chicken Finger Pizza, Steak Pizza, Pepperoni Calzone
We are in from out of town ( although I grew up around here) and wanted good 'Buffalo' pizza. We're so glad we chose Gino's! Everything about the pepperoni, mushroom, olive, onion, and sausage pizza was absolutely perfect, from the the generous amount of toppings to the perfectly baked crust (no one in the Southern Tier gets the middle cooked thoroughly). My husband surprised me by also ordering wings and they were delicious...crispy cooked and sauced properly. Great job!
Food: 5
Went to get food at Gino’s late at night with a few friends. They delivered excellent service to us quickly cooking us up some fresh slices that were delicious. The fostered a good atmosphere to sit down and talk with some of the guys.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recently moved nearby, roommates said they were not too happy, so I didnt bother , then one day I decided to give it a try, ordered a stinger, man with heavy accent said he wouldnt make a half sub, even tho its on the menu also on the website for order etc... so I decide to get the whole sub... ends up costing an even $17 and was skimpy esp for such a high cost , you would think with all the competition nearby they would care. . Seemed to be one whole chicken finger split through the entire whole sub and steak was skimpy as well.. I dont usually bother with reviews but I felt this one was necessary.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
They never have slices ready. This is my third time coming in and today was my last. I didn’t want to leave a bad review but crap I don’t know what to say because there’s always a 15 minute wait for slices. Went to John’s Pizza instead.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Solid lil joint in Tonawanda. Never had a bad slice from them, usually my quick bite stop every here and there. Workers ain’t the most friendly but they’re chill. Solid pizza and fingers. Wish they had a public restroom though
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Perfect Buffalo neighborhood style pizza spot. Gino is often there keeping everything moving smoothly. T.V. plays sports. Good team, great pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love Gino's Pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It's hard to find good Sicilian pizza in the Buffalo area. Their Sicilian was excellent, definitely will get another Sicilian pie in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Famous for their Buffalo Style pizza; the pizza was oozing with cheese that overflowed on every slice we took from the box. They did not cheap put on the cheese at all when we ordered the classic. This location specifically was a little run-down, and the patio was closed. But the quality and popularity of their pizza makes up for it.
Restaurantji Recommends
First time trying. Pizza was delicious nice and crispy bottom definitely going back oh and the wings soild 10
One of my favorite buffalo style pizzas in wny
good food, bomb wings, got stoned and ate some wings and they were goof
Solid Pizza!
It's good Buffalo style pizza. Doughy airy thick crust, lots of cheese, sweet sauce and cup and char pepperoni. Not exactly my style (I prefer NY style pizza), but I enjoyed their pepperoni pizza. It's not greasy and comes well seasoned which is a plus. The sauce is very sweet, though to be fair that is how pizza is made in Buffalo.
Loading...