Great waitress, great food. Reasonable lunch specials. They have homemade deserts. Served a large group of people.
Spam Bin
The pizza was ok. No complaints. However, The roast beef sub was really bad. If anybody is reading this, who works at the restaurant, please take a look at your roast beef. It is so tough and processed. You Need to up your game on this. Thank you.
Amanda C.
My husband and I decided to order a pizza this past Friday night! We decided to order from one of our local favs! Molinara's! We order from here every once in a while because we can spice it up with our semi sweet sauce instead of your average traditional pizza sauce! The hint of sweetness this sauce can provide elevates your taste buds and definitely a must try for anyone who likes a hint of sweetness! The pizza was amazing and had such a great ratio of cheese to toppings! They really piled on the olives and mushrooms on that half of our pizza! Plus they don't over exceed in the cheese department but put the most perfect and extremely melty amount! The service is always super quick and always ready within 30 minutes after ordering! The pizza comes out nearly perfect every time! The little place itself does have a little dining room, but we always opt to order takeout it's just a skip around the corner! We definitely will be ordering from this little favorite place of ours again!
Mike M.
Ever since I bought my house and moved into the Tonawanda Amherst area Molinara's has been my number one favorite pizza place for a NYS style pie. Pizza is my favorite food and this traditional family run business does it right! My wife and I love the cheese and pepperoni with the semi sweet sauce- not too sweet but has that perfect zing in the sauce! This time we ordered a large semi sweet half cheese and half mushrooms and olives on our Lenten Friday dinner! The service was great- ordering it for a specific time and it was piping hot out of the oven right on time on my way back home from the gym! The pizza was excellent!! We love this little place and would highly reccomend them for your next pizza pie! Great job Molinaras!!
paul colt
Good pizza but I go there for the stuffed banana peppers there rolled in pizza dough and deep fried absolutely the best.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Pope Marius
This pizza is in competition amongst the worst that I've ever had. It's taste was inexplicable. I honestly cannot explain the taste... but I took one bite and my body said "NOPE! Never again!"
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
henry costello
Excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Jenna C.
Zero stars. We ordered the following: chicken Marsala (no cheese for a dairy allergy), stuffed pepper Stromboli, and a calzone with chicken. What we got: a Stromboli with ham and cheese, a cheese calzone with NO chicken, and chicken Marsala with cheese in the sauce. We called and we got ZERO apology. Their response to the marsala? Well the marsala has cheese in the sauce. Wouldn't you think they would have said that on the phone when we ordered? We paid all of this money and we didn't get anything we wanted. The guy on the phone couldn't care less. Don't order from here. Give your business to someone else who actually cares about their customers.
Dale Pawarski
Stuffed hot peppers wrapped are incredible... the stuffed hot pepper pizza 0/10 no I mean no flavor needs salt or something, stuffing, sauce, cheese ..also not cooked through. But the wrapped peppers are a great reason to go here. I consider them official WNY grub.Parking: Easy on and out.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Paul G.
I tried Molinaros for the first time on New Years Day because they were opened, and I have found a home. The pizza was excellent and the wings just as good. I bought a pizza with regular sauce and one with the sweet sauce. Likes them both but the sweet sauce was out of this world. i also bought 25 hot wings and 25 Bar-B-Q wings and they were some of the best I've had in a while. Will be back for years to come
Worst steak sub I've ever had! The meat was so salty, I couldn't eat it. The roll was soggy and the lettuce, onion and tomato under the hot meat made them soggy too.The place was freezing cold and it could use a good cleaning.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Jared Wansart
Worst food I ever had. Ordered a pizza sub by far the worst pizza sub that I ever eat. It wasn’t cooked all the way, and the bread was soggy. Absolutely horrible. I also ordered fried mushrooms. They weren’t cooked all the way all slimy and falling apart. I also ordered a chicken salad with honey mustard, and it was absolutely not honey mustard. It was just straight up mustard. And I normally don’t complain or call, so when I did they said the owner left for the night you have to call tomorrow which I did and spoke to the owner about my experience and he said” Well you aren’t getting a refund, I made the food myself so I don’t know what to tell you.” Horrible service horrible food never ever ordering from here ever again and 100% don’t recommend anyone To ever eat from this place.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Tom Storm
Best stuffed banana peppers in all of Buffalo.The rolls cool, as is the pasta - but just get the 3 stuffed pepper appetizer - one of the best single dishes in this city. I've been buying it for 10+
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kevin M.
Worst food I ever had. Ordered a pizza sub by far the worst pizza sub that I ever eat. It wasn't cooked all the way, and the bread was soggy. Absolutely horrible. I also ordered fried mushrooms. They weren't cooked all the way all slimy and falling apart. I also ordered a chicken salad with honey mustard, and it was absolutely not honey mustard. It was just straight up mustard. And I normally don't complain or call, so when I did they said the owner left for the night you have to call tomorrow which I did and spoke to the owner about my experience and he said" Well you aren't getting a refund, I made the food myself so I don't know what to tell you." Horrible service horrible food never ever ordering from here ever again and 100% don't recommend anyone To ever eat from this place.
Great waitress, great food. Reasonable lunch specials. They have homemade deserts. Served a large group of people.
The pizza was ok. No complaints. However, The roast beef sub was really bad. If anybody is reading this, who works at the restaurant, please take a look at your roast beef. It is so tough and processed. You Need to up your game on this. Thank you.
My husband and I decided to order a pizza this past Friday night! We decided to order from one of our local favs! Molinara's! We order from here every once in a while because we can spice it up with our semi sweet sauce instead of your average traditional pizza sauce! The hint of sweetness this sauce can provide elevates your taste buds and definitely a must try for anyone who likes a hint of sweetness! The pizza was amazing and had such a great ratio of cheese to toppings! They really piled on the olives and mushrooms on that half of our pizza! Plus they don't over exceed in the cheese department but put the most perfect and extremely melty amount! The service is always super quick and always ready within 30 minutes after ordering! The pizza comes out nearly perfect every time! The little place itself does have a little dining room, but we always opt to order takeout it's just a skip around the corner! We definitely will be ordering from this little favorite place of ours again!
Ever since I bought my house and moved into the Tonawanda Amherst area Molinara's has been my number one favorite pizza place for a NYS style pie. Pizza is my favorite food and this traditional family run business does it right! My wife and I love the cheese and pepperoni with the semi sweet sauce- not too sweet but has that perfect zing in the sauce! This time we ordered a large semi sweet half cheese and half mushrooms and olives on our Lenten Friday dinner! The service was great- ordering it for a specific time and it was piping hot out of the oven right on time on my way back home from the gym! The pizza was excellent!! We love this little place and would highly reccomend them for your next pizza pie! Great job Molinaras!!
Good pizza but I go there for the stuffed banana peppers there rolled in pizza dough and deep fried absolutely the best.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
This pizza is in competition amongst the worst that I've ever had. It's taste was inexplicable. I honestly cannot explain the taste... but I took one bite and my body said "NOPE! Never again!"
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Zero stars. We ordered the following: chicken Marsala (no cheese for a dairy allergy), stuffed pepper Stromboli, and a calzone with chicken. What we got: a Stromboli with ham and cheese, a cheese calzone with NO chicken, and chicken Marsala with cheese in the sauce. We called and we got ZERO apology. Their response to the marsala? Well the marsala has cheese in the sauce. Wouldn't you think they would have said that on the phone when we ordered? We paid all of this money and we didn't get anything we wanted. The guy on the phone couldn't care less. Don't order from here. Give your business to someone else who actually cares about their customers.
Stuffed hot peppers wrapped are incredible... the stuffed hot pepper pizza 0/10 no I mean no flavor needs salt or something, stuffing, sauce, cheese ..also not cooked through. But the wrapped peppers are a great reason to go here. I consider them official WNY grub.Parking: Easy on and out.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
I tried Molinaros for the first time on New Years Day because they were opened, and I have found a home. The pizza was excellent and the wings just as good. I bought a pizza with regular sauce and one with the sweet sauce. Likes them both but the sweet sauce was out of this world. i also bought 25 hot wings and 25 Bar-B-Q wings and they were some of the best I've had in a while. Will be back for years to come
Restaurantji Recommends
Worst steak sub I've ever had! The meat was so salty, I couldn't eat it. The roll was soggy and the lettuce, onion and tomato under the hot meat made them soggy too.The place was freezing cold and it could use a good cleaning.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Worst food I ever had. Ordered a pizza sub by far the worst pizza sub that I ever eat. It wasn’t cooked all the way, and the bread was soggy. Absolutely horrible. I also ordered fried mushrooms. They weren’t cooked all the way all slimy and falling apart. I also ordered a chicken salad with honey mustard, and it was absolutely not honey mustard. It was just straight up mustard. And I normally don’t complain or call, so when I did they said the owner left for the night you have to call tomorrow which I did and spoke to the owner about my experience and he said” Well you aren’t getting a refund, I made the food myself so I don’t know what to tell you.” Horrible service horrible food never ever ordering from here ever again and 100% don’t recommend anyone To ever eat from this place.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Best stuffed banana peppers in all of Buffalo.The rolls cool, as is the pasta - but just get the 3 stuffed pepper appetizer - one of the best single dishes in this city. I've been buying it for 10+
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Worst food I ever had. Ordered a pizza sub by far the worst pizza sub that I ever eat. It wasn't cooked all the way, and the bread was soggy. Absolutely horrible. I also ordered fried mushrooms. They weren't cooked all the way all slimy and falling apart. I also ordered a chicken salad with honey mustard, and it was absolutely not honey mustard. It was just straight up mustard. And I normally don't complain or call, so when I did they said the owner left for the night you have to call tomorrow which I did and spoke to the owner about my experience and he said" Well you aren't getting a refund, I made the food myself so I don't know what to tell you." Horrible service horrible food never ever ordering from here ever again and 100% don't recommend anyone To ever eat from this place.
Good selection of slices.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5