Olisi's New York Style

2352 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda
(716) 837-6767

Customers' Favorites

Photos

+35 photos
+34 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I wanted to like this more. The pizza was under-cooked a bit and kind of a greasy bland. The wings were clearly frozen by the deep purple color of the bone when eating. The dark color of the meat seemed to indicate that the cooking oil may have been older. The taste of the food was okay, kinda standard nothing special.
They have a huge lot with lots of space for parking. This used to be a John & Mary's location years ago. They had some decent coupons. I will...
This is a review specifically for the chicken finger sub, because it is perfection. What makes it so great? For starters the bread is well toasted, which is so important for structural integrity. The chicken fingers are made specifically for the sub, perfectly cooked and coated to your preference. There are places I can't order chicken finger subs from now because Olisi's makes them so much better. It's that good.
Very nice people. Pizza was great! Cheesy, good sauce ratio, and the crust was crisp on the bottom, but chewy throughout, and had a perfect crunch. Good flavor. Highly recommend! I traveled to New York from Arkansas, love Pizza, and was dying to try New York style pizza in New York. This did not dissapoint.

More Reviews