GREAT vibes, lovely staff, my friends enjoyed their drinks and flights very much. The food was underwhelming (pork carnitas didn’t have much flavor) but I would go back and try something else. The fries were delicious!
chrisrmo66
A hidden gem. We were visiting the finger lakes and came upon this brewery in Trumansburg. What a find! They had a tremendous beer selection, and the food was incredible. The staff was so friendly and the atmosphere vibrant. We loved it so much we returned the next night!
Sioux OConnor
Always a pleasant adventure. Great beer and excellent food.
Raul H.
Stopped here after a hike. We were starved. My wife ordered the carnitas nachos a liked them. I got the burrito with beef birria brisket. It was good and huge! It comes with two salsas and some chips on the side. We ordered a flight of beer and they were pretty good as well.
Vicki K.
After a 25 mile bike ride, hot, sweaty, starving and thirsty this place was a huge hit! We got a flight of brews, a burrito and 2 tacos.... Wow! Everything was amazing! No sour cream and no guacamole bc you don't need it! One bite and you'll understand! Atmosphere was relaxed and friendly! Will definitely come back next time we are in the area!
Rhea Burke
Loved the burritos
Breanna Ryan
Pretty good beers and the food was excellent! Surprisingly great food!
Lori Jennison
Awesome place. Great hospitality! Fantastic food! Reasonable prices with an outdoor area. Will definitely revisit!
Brent Lemberg
Beers were really good, only had 2 though. One of the best pils I've had in awhile. Single malt/hop pale ale very good too. Really enjoyed the food!!! Tasty brisket burrito. Gotta get there more often!
Princess K
Great food, great prices, wonderful staff. Fun place to watch and dance to live music.
Great beer good atmosphere and the food was good too! Mexican food and we're from California so we can attest to the quality.
Brooke M.
Come for the beer, stay for the out-of-this-effing-world tacos. My fiancé and I came in upon hearing that Garrett's had started to serve food and we decided to order one of every taco (that's 10 tacos) and a quesadilla. One bite into our first taco, and we both said "Holy Shit!" simultaneously. Our faves were the fish tacos, pork tacos, veggie tacos, and the barbacoa quesadilla. I can't wait to enjoy again. And the best way to enjoy the tacos is with literally anyone of their beers, but I'm a big fan of their Drink the Juice IPA and their #almost pale ale.
Autumn Reed
Great selection of drinks (beer, hard cider, and wine). Extremely friendly staff and customers. Great vibe! Highly recommend.
David Calaiaro
Very friendly and welcoming staff, wonderful setting, and best of all, delicious food! Tried the special fish taco, the barbacoa, chicken tinga, and veggie tacos. They were unreal!The bar is wonderfully set up, with comfortable seating. A nice selection of beers and flights to boot.A must visit if you are in town, I know I will be dropping in next time I'm in the area!
Peter Taft
Enjoyed our beers, a Stout and Juicy IPA. The Stout was probably the best one I've had in a long time. The addition of Mexican style food has really turned Garrett's into a place to go. Tacos were great, actually tasty and hot. Great crowd too.
GREAT vibes, lovely staff, my friends enjoyed their drinks and flights very much. The food was underwhelming (pork carnitas didn’t have much flavor) but I would go back and try something else. The fries were delicious!
A hidden gem. We were visiting the finger lakes and came upon this brewery in Trumansburg. What a find! They had a tremendous beer selection, and the food was incredible. The staff was so friendly and the atmosphere vibrant. We loved it so much we returned the next night!
Always a pleasant adventure. Great beer and excellent food.
Stopped here after a hike. We were starved. My wife ordered the carnitas nachos a liked them. I got the burrito with beef birria brisket. It was good and huge! It comes with two salsas and some chips on the side. We ordered a flight of beer and they were pretty good as well.
After a 25 mile bike ride, hot, sweaty, starving and thirsty this place was a huge hit! We got a flight of brews, a burrito and 2 tacos.... Wow! Everything was amazing! No sour cream and no guacamole bc you don't need it! One bite and you'll understand! Atmosphere was relaxed and friendly! Will definitely come back next time we are in the area!
Loved the burritos
Pretty good beers and the food was excellent! Surprisingly great food!
Awesome place. Great hospitality! Fantastic food! Reasonable prices with an outdoor area. Will definitely revisit!
Beers were really good, only had 2 though. One of the best pils I've had in awhile. Single malt/hop pale ale very good too. Really enjoyed the food!!! Tasty brisket burrito. Gotta get there more often!
Great food, great prices, wonderful staff. Fun place to watch and dance to live music.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great beer good atmosphere and the food was good too! Mexican food and we're from California so we can attest to the quality.
Come for the beer, stay for the out-of-this-effing-world tacos. My fiancé and I came in upon hearing that Garrett's had started to serve food and we decided to order one of every taco (that's 10 tacos) and a quesadilla. One bite into our first taco, and we both said "Holy Shit!" simultaneously. Our faves were the fish tacos, pork tacos, veggie tacos, and the barbacoa quesadilla. I can't wait to enjoy again. And the best way to enjoy the tacos is with literally anyone of their beers, but I'm a big fan of their Drink the Juice IPA and their #almost pale ale.
Great selection of drinks (beer, hard cider, and wine). Extremely friendly staff and customers. Great vibe! Highly recommend.
Very friendly and welcoming staff, wonderful setting, and best of all, delicious food! Tried the special fish taco, the barbacoa, chicken tinga, and veggie tacos. They were unreal!The bar is wonderfully set up, with comfortable seating. A nice selection of beers and flights to boot.A must visit if you are in town, I know I will be dropping in next time I'm in the area!
Enjoyed our beers, a Stout and Juicy IPA. The Stout was probably the best one I've had in a long time. The addition of Mexican style food has really turned Garrett's into a place to go. Tacos were great, actually tasty and hot. Great crowd too.