New York Pizzeria
$ • PizzaAbout New York Pizzeria
Customers' Favorites
White Pizza with Tomato
Pepperoni Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Lots of Pizza
Large Pizza
Meat Pizza
New York Pizzeria Reviews
174 ratings
Share your opinion about New York Pizzeria
Best pizza ..... period.
best pizza anywhere. period
I would of gave ya all 5 stars but we drove all the way from Ohio just to get the Sicilian slices and you only had one left. We will be back saturday to finish our quest. Best pizza ive ever had
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 12 - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 12 - 8PM |
| Thursday | 12 - 8PM |
| Friday | 12 - 8PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 8PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
New York Pizzeria offers some of the best pizzas, featuring a crispy crust and generous toppings that remind customers of traditional New York-style pies. The pizza has just the right amount of sauce and cheese, and for an even better experience, customers are encouraged to ask for an extra long bake. While the selection of slice options may be limited, the food and service are consistently fantastic and friendly. Many visitors are pleasantly surprised by the quality and taste, especially those from NYC or nearby areas, and often choose to order a large pie to go. The restaurant is especially appreciated for its authentic flavor, comparable to the decent NY Pizza shops found all over Manhattan, with some noting the importance of NYC water in achieving that quality. Customers frequently praise the crust, describing it as perfect—thin, salty, and just right. The veggie pizza is often highlighted for being loaded with fresh ingredients, and the cheese and pepperoni options are highly recommended. Overall, it is a great quality pizzeria that brings the authentic New York pizza experience to the Finger Lakes area.