5 Best Pizza Restaurants near Trumansburg

“Best pizza ..... period.“

“Takeout order of 2 Italian dinners with pickup at 5:45pm. Arrived at 5:35pm on a Friday evening, expecting it to be busy. The line entering filled all open spaces, with a line waiting for their takeout. My husband went to the bar for a beer while waiting, and couldn't believe the efficiency of handling each waiting person, and no one was exiting as if they didn't want to wait or were tired of waiting. Our takeout order came between 4:45p and 4:50p. It was fresh, hot and delicious even after a 15min drive to camp. We definitely will be back when next in town, a great treat!“

“Coffee and donuts are always fresh and delicious! Staff are always friendly and willing to help in any way. One night at around 2 a.m., I had the worst toothache ever. My poor husband rushed to Byrne Dairy in search of anything that would make me stop crying out in pain. Unfortunately their Ambasol was out of stock... The cashier ran out to his car and came back with a brand new item he had purchased for his girlfriend. He gave it to my husband for free! Now that's customer service!“

“What an awesome spot! Ambiance was airy, comfortable and inviting. We were treated with amazing Sicilian crust pizza with locally sourced pepperoni and leeks fresh out of the greenhouse. The beer was delicious, Porter Hill was especially tasty. Please come check this spot out!“

“Val and Jim were amazing! We came all the way from Pennsylvania, and they truly made our visit unforgettable. They gave us a tour of the brewery and went above and beyond to make sure we had a memorable and enjoyable experience. They were so personable, friendly, and welcoming from the moment we arrived.

The experience was fantastic, and I would highly recommend stopping by. I’m not much of a beer drinker and usually don’t like most beers, but I was pleasantly surprised. I actually loved the beers here! Whether you’re a beer enthusiast or not, this place is definitely worth visiting.“