21 Best Pizza Restaurants in Ithaca

“I ordered a pizza a short while ago and it is OUTSTANDING! All the ingredients are very fresh, the sauce and crust are just how I like them and it looks amazing. I think this is the best pizza in Ithaca and it will be my go to place from now on! About a month ago I had an issue with a Door Dash order and Nate went above and beyond to make it right.“

“We both really enjoyed the pizza. Love the crispy crust too! Toppings were fantastic! We will definitely need to come back! We'll spread the word!!!“

“Lillyanna and I stopped to eat here in the Ithaca Mall the day before Halloween 😋 This pizzeria has been in this mall for as long as I can remember 🥰 The food was Amazing … but the Service and Customer Appreciation from this Man was unmatched by far especially these days!!! Made fresh food just the way we ordered … hand delivered to our table and the thankful hospitality was heart warming!! BRAVO Stefano 🙌 ❤️🇮🇹💚🍕🍝 🤌🏼🌹🌹 🙌“

“Great group of people, that attracts even cooler customers.“

“great pizza, my sister n I loved it“

“excellent food good people“

“I was visiting Ithaca from out of town and stopped by More Than Pizza – and I’m so glad I did! The staff was incredibly welcoming and made me feel right at home. Their kindness and hospitality truly stood out. On top of that, the food was amazing – fresh, delicious, and made with care. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this place is a must-visit. Highly recommend!“

“Top notch service and amazing food. I’ve been working a construction job for over a year now, across the street from here and we all go for lunch often. Kamal specifically always helps us get our lunch very fast and affordable. Highly recommend“

“My boyfriend bought a piece of pizza at Press Bay Alley today from Adelina’s truck. I had already eaten lunch but couldn’t resist taking bite after bite of his pizza. The contrast of crunch and warm softness was perfect. The sauces, textures and flavors were fresh, thoughtfully balanced and paired, and the best way I can put it, is that you can taste the intention in this food. It is so hard to come by food that has this kind of presence. If you are going to eat some pizza, this is it. Bravo 💛.“

“Went with a group of 4 Freshmen college students. All the entrees and the pizza were really good. Good portions. Friendly service, it was very busy, but the server did very well while tending to several big tables at the same time! Will definitely be back.“

“Las pizzas más ricas que he probado!“

“Finding something that everyone agrees on, a place that isn't insanely busy and something that isn't going to break the bank. We found a winner.
Fridays are always a challenge for dinner for my family. Pudgies has always been that hidden gem that alot forget about. The website makes ordering and paying for it so easy. We ordered the party pack. For the amount of food you get, it was worth the price. It was delivered in short time and the food was still hot. The delivery guy(George) was great. He greeted me with a smile, he was courteous and very professional. After grabbing some of the food from him, he seen that I was struggling a little bit and he told me to take my time. I appreciated the fact that he wasn't trying to throw everything at me and rush out. He waited for me to put some things down, wish me a good day and even close my door for me. The food was delicious. Thank you for a great experience.“

“Tonight I placed a delivery order and it was fabulous. I ordered the fried haddock dinner with penne pasta and tossed salad. The fish was cooked perfectly,( Not greasy at all)., and the portion was very generous. The Penne pasta was. Also delicious. Delivery was quick.. This is one of My. Favorite. Take out places. Can't go wrong!.“

“Great service, exactly as ordered. Very friendly“

“I ordered a Margherita pizza and salad and it was delivered via Uber. What a GREAT experience! The food was AMAZING, and it arrived exactly when promised. I just warmed up the rest of the pizza for lunch (the afternoon after), and it was just as yummy! Fabulous crust! I’ll not get pizza anywhere else, after being a devoted customer of Pizza Aroma for two decades. I wish I had taken pics of the pizza, but I was waaaaaay too hungry, and I was not disappointed! Thank you Pronto! ♥️“

“Fabulous food, huge portions, reasonably priced, and terrific service!“

“Tonight was my first visit. I was traveling for work and it was amazing. Great food, atmosphere and drinks. Wish this was in my home town!“

“It's a good store in many ways, but I have some complaints. One is that they keep rearranging things and they do not use a logical placement (like all kinds of cookies together, not spread about). Secondly, I want to comment on milk containers, and don't know how to make a fresh post. Here's the comment: The caps on all "Pure Pak" containers are Very Hard To Open. The problem is a catch built into the cap, probably some middle manager's idea to increase security. Well it's a disaster for older people or anyone with weak hands. We have to use pliers or a nutcracker. Ridiculous. Open your milk with pliers? Absurd! It's milk, or Almond milk. Even kids should be able to open the container.“

“I had the lemon artichoke pasta . It was excellent along with the service !“

“GREAT WITH CELIAC DISEASE!!!!

Don’t let the “beer co” fool you - this is a fried food dream for celiacs! All of their breading use corn flour so all of the fryers are always GF. I went with two celiac, two non- and they could not taste the difference. As someone who grew up loving buffalo chicken fingers, it’s a loss not to have them.

They also have ciders to drink!

Would absolutely recommend! Delicious and safe!“

“This is a wonderful place to eat, have some excellent drinks, and socialize.“