13 Best Italian Restaurants in Ithaca

“Their Pizza is Magical. We order several times a week at work. highly recommend“

“Lunch buffet is a great choice -healthy and quality food and great service. Life is service!“

“I had the lemon artichoke pasta . It was excellent along with the service !“

“This place is amazing , food is great Definitely authentic Italian food . We love it 100% ❤️ The only disappointment is this guy named Steve (sever) he’s so rude. The way he talked to he’s coworkers is unbelievable. No respect at all specially with young people. Hopefully the owners are aware of this guy behavior.“

“They have fantastic food and service you can't ask for better food and service. there the best“

“Great pizza so far the best pizza in upstate ny. I work at Russ pizza in greenpoint Brooklyn ny. And this pizza is very similar to ours. Love it“

“The food here was very good! We are extremely spoiled in NJ with tons of amazing Italian restaurants around. This little restaurant did well, we enjoyed our dinner & our server was very attentive. It's a small place, but it was quaint.“

“Top notch service and amazing food. I’ve been working a construction job for over a year now, across the street from here and we all go for lunch often. Kamal specifically always helps us get our lunch very fast and affordable. Highly recommend“

“Those who return to DP Dough understand that there will necessarily be a light salting of disappointment as the grease-soaked carbs settle into the beer already occupying your tummy. Connoisseurs even seek it out. Somehow the calzonic anticipation leads to a perfect first bite but the rest somehow breaks the spell, creating a very /delectatio morosa/ feel. Under no circumstances should DP Dough be compared to fine dining, nor even to the Pizza Aroma half a block away; this is utilitarian fare, or cuisine to save a life: as like a tourniquet, not thrombolysis. For what it is as drunk food it succeeds quite well, lower in quality than a certain hot truck, but distinctive in that it comes to you where you are, rather than vice versa. Get a speed zone with ranch—always get ranch; their marinara has remained consistently a tad too sweet across years of history in an attempt to build that reputation for that faint sense of unease that will so easily be forgotten by tomorrow's drunken carousing, when the story will repeat all over again.“

“You will not find a better place or nicer people on the commons than this place. One of my fav places !“

“Outstanding Food & Customer Service We drive an hour to dine here They exceed our expectations“

“simply the best pizza in New York!“

“We were a party of seven and all of our dishes were delicious! Our server, Dustin, was great! Very friendly staff! I'm gluten-free and highly recommend!!!

Dietary restrictions: There are great gluten-free options/menu!! I had the steak and shrimp, which was delicious. Also, had the flourless chocolate cake. Wondeeful!“