16 Best American Restaurants in Ithaca

Milkstand Restaurant American • $
215 N Meadow St, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Garlic Chicken 'N' Waffles
Sweet Garlic Chicken and Waffles
Honey Butter French Toast
Sriracha Chicken & Waffles
Chorizo Skillet Scramble
Piglet Skillet Scramble
Berry Cheesecake Crepe
Biscuits and Gravy
Biscuits & Gravy
Scrambled Eggs

“We love the Milkstand! It's a locally owned and sourced restaurant with a wide variety of choices on the menu - all of which are available all day. The wait staff is always very good, our server today, Jennifer, was definitely a five-star server. Friendly, attentive and knowledgeable. Just a great place to go!“

4.5 Superb418 Reviews
Simeon's American Bistro Bistros • $$
224 East State Street, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

Simeon's Award-Winning New England Clam Chowder
Vin Blanc Bar Harbor Maine Mussels
Dozen Fresh Oysters on a Half Shell
Broiled Half Maine Lobster Entree
Lobster Mac \u0026 Cheese
Cheeseburger and Fries
Lobster Mac & Cheese
Classic Wedge Salad
Salmon and Farro
Sea Bass Special

“Me and my boyfriend had a great time! Food was amazing“

4.6 Superb339 Reviews
The Rook American • $$
105 W Court St Unit 100, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

Duck Fat Fried Chicken
Bacon Wrapped Dates
Buttermilk Salad
Salmon Rilletes
Duck Fat Fries
Pork Schnitzel
Royale Burger
Hush Puppies
Summer Pasta
Cheeseburger

“The Rook is always a must-visit whenever we’re in town! The menu is full of flavorful dishes, and their cocktails and beverages are equally impressive. The atmosphere is inviting and lively, making it a perfect spot for any occasion. The staff goes above and beyond - Manny in particular is friendly, attentive, and a joy to chat with. We can’t recommend The Rook enough for great food, drinks, and an unforgettable experience😍🙌“

4.5 Superb219 Reviews
Moosewood Vegetarian • $$
215 North Cayuga Street, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

Pasta with Butter or Olive Oil Tomato Basil Sauce Parmesan
Strozzapreti Al Tartufo Nero Available During Dinner Only
Lasagna Available During Dinner Only
Green Pea and Mint Hummus and Pita
Moosewood Tossed Salad
Moroccan Chickpea Stew
Lemon Tahini Broccoli
Vegan Chocolate Cake
Spicy Coconut Curry
Mediterranean Salad

“Fantastic Restaurant!! A must see and delicious healthy cuisine!!!“

4.4 Superb566 Reviews
The Heights American • $$$
903 Hanshaw Road, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

The Heights' Signature Chocolate Cake
Open Fire Grilled Rack of Lamb
Salmon Collar with Fried Clams
Salmuera Grilled Swordfish
Flame Grilled Duck Breast
Char Grilled Fish Reuben
Pan Roasted Skirt Steak
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Vegetable Harvest Salad
Braised Beef Short Rib

“I drove down from Cape Vincent to meet one of my best friends from college who was in the area for a family wedding. I was completely blown away by my meal. The waitress was incredible. I had the Chilean sea bass and it literally melted in my mouth. The salad with fresh fruit and a raspberry vinaigrette was outstanding. We ordered coffee and I was brought a little tray with fresh whipped cream, as well as other delightful garnishes. Finally… the mile high carrot cake!! Pure bliss. Thank you for a truly memorable experience. And I was so grateful that we weren’t rushed. We don’t get to see each other frequently and it was a blessing to just spend time together.“

4.4 Superb280 Reviews
Antlers Restaurant Steak House • $$
1159 Dryden Road, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

Maple Leaf Farms Roast Duckling
Antlers Original Burger
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Fried Green Tomatoes
Santa Barbara Salad
Boston Baked Scrod
Scallops Au Gratin
Surf \u0026 Turf
Delmonico Steak
Baby Back Ribs

“From the cocktails to the coffee wonderful. Had the bread basket loved it Prime rib was great. And the srver Blake was beyond good , great service. Will be back again“

4.4 Superb382 Reviews
Lincoln Street Diner Diner • $
309 E Lincoln St, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

Western Omelette and Sausage Patty
Cajun Special Gravy and Biscuits
Single Pancake with Homefries
Corned Beef Hash and Eggs
Pancakes or French Toast
Veggie Western Omelette
It's Raining Cupcakes
Hab & Hash Omelette
Breakfast Sandwich
Confetti Muffins

“best service and breakfast ever. we stop every march on our way home from the finger lakes.“

4.7 Superb253 Reviews
Chili's Grill & Bar Tex-Mex • $
608 South Meadow Street, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

Nashville Hot Mozz - Shareable
Crispy Chicken Crispers Combos
Grilled Chicken Fajitas
Bean and Veggie Fajitas
Southwestern Eggrolls
Molten Chocolate Cake
Brisket Quesadillas
Cajun Chicken Pasta
White Skillet Queso
Texas Cheese Fries

“The honey chipotle chicken strips are amazing! If you get the 3 deal thing they have , u can get them, 2 sides and a drink for like 14 or 15 bucks! Which isn't bad considering a number one at mcdonalds is damn near the same price!( I don't know if you have been to Ithaca mcdonalds lately especially at night time, but saying it sucks is an understatement! )“

4.3 Superb391 Reviews
Gorgers Sandwich Shop • $
116 W State St, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

South of the Border
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Philly Cheesesteak
Bacon Cheese Fries
Chicken Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken
Shrimp PO' Boy
Pulled Pork Sub
Coconut Shrimp
Shrimp PO Boy

“Best place for a sub!! We love it here“

4.6 Superb285 Reviews
Brewer's Kitchen & Taproom Bar & Grill • $$
1384 Dryden Rd, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

House Fry or Onion Ring Platter
Barbeque Cauliflower Wings
Buffalo Chicken Egg Rolls
Classic Bacon Cheeseburger
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Kimchi Tater Tots
Chicken Sandwich
Burger and Fries
Fish and Chips
Smoked Wings

“Had a lovely time. The food was mostly good, but the poutine gravy was just poorly reheated, canned chicken gravy. It was gelatinous and had no flavor. It was like a pile of phlegm on fries. Everything else was great. Fantastic outdoor area and craft brew selection. Will be back for burgers.“

4.6 Superb191 Reviews
The Establishment American • $$
255 Statler Drive, Ithaca

“We came here during royal feast night and had an amazing experience!
The food was great, service was very professional and well trained, and the overall atmosphere created went further to enhance the culinary experience.
I really enjoyed how everything was organized and presented. From the table settings and menus to the plating of food, the care and attention to detail was evident.
Everyone did a great job to ensure we had a wonderful time.
I’ll definitely be back (if I can score a reservation ;))“

4.5 Superb99 Reviews
Atrium Cafe Cafe • $
Sage Avenue, Ithaca

“? Yummy Alert! ?The crab and corn soup is soooooo tasty! Try it.Layout of the food area is a bit odd which creates a bad logistical flow for people getting food and those exiting with their food. Also, the staff are seemingly unfriendly and I swear I thought the guy serving in the hot food section was going to drip sweat into the curry. The older lady next to him served the rice so sloppy. The dish looked ugly because of how it was served and presented and so I left it. But, the crab and corn soup is fantastic!“

5 Superb19 Reviews
Italian Carry Out Italian • $
1070 Danby Road, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Salad Yummmm
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub
Chicken Wing Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
ICO Meatball Parm
Cheese Tortellini
Chicken Wing Sub
Breaded Mushrooms
Pepperoni Pizza
Flying Squirrel

“Tonight I placed a delivery order and it was fabulous. I ordered the fried haddock dinner with penne pasta and tossed salad. The fish was cooked perfectly,( Not greasy at all)., and the portion was very generous. The Penne pasta was. Also delicious. Delivery was quick.. This is one of My. Favorite. Take out places. Can't go wrong!.“

4.6 Superb193 Reviews
The Terrace Restaurant American • $
130 Statler Drive, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

Rice Bowl

“Nice people,service was tops.“

4.2 Good109 Reviews
Monks on the Commons American • $$
120 S Aurora St, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

Ithaca Beer Seasonal
Lamb Lollipops
House

“Chef Joey has a gift for elevating meals both in flavors and textures. I wish I lived closer, I’d be here at least once a week…“

3.9 Good223 Reviews
McCormick's at Moakley House American • $
215 Warren Road, Ithaca

“Stopped by for lunch today, had a great experience!“

4.1 Good19 Reviews

You May Also Like