8 Best American Restaurants in Watkins Glen

Lakeside Resort & 3812 Bistro Wine Bar • $$
3812 NY-14, Watkins Glen

“Couldn’t be more happier about our stay. My partner and our dog stayed in the Lake View Cabin and were absolutely blown away. The view is incredible, we could see a waterfall across the lake! The cabin was very spacious and clean, also equipped with everything we could possibly need during our stay. We were so happy to have found a dog friendly place, and the owners dog Rocky (I think that’s the name) was very sweet whenever we had the chance to see him around the property. The check-in process was easy and the lady who helped us check-in was very friendly. We can’t WAIT to come back, thank you for making our trip so special.“

4.6 Superb117 Reviews
Curly's Family Restaurant Family • $
2780 NY-14, Watkins Glen

Customers` Favorites

Corned Beef Hash-2 Eggs and Toast
Biscuits and Gravy
Chicken Sandwich
Chicken Parmesan
With Home Fries
Onion Rings
Pancakes
Burger
Steak

“My husband and I both a a turkey melt and soup. I had the sweet potato and ham soup and he had the chicken tortellini. They were excellent. You could tell the soup was homemade. The place is clean and the staff was friendly and attentive. Great place for families.“

4.5 Superb93 Reviews
Maria's Tavern Pubs • $
509 N Franklin St, Watkins Glen

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Breast Salads
Turkey Ham or Roast Beef
Steak Cut French Fries
Fried Pepperoni Slices
American Cheeseburger
Medium Wings Crispy
Philly Cheese Steak
Cajun Chicken Wrap
Soup or Chili Bowl
Mozzarella Sticks

“Got three dozen wingsPlainMango habaneroAnd sweet and sourI was missing a plain wing but aside from that they were goodShe gave me some of the house made blue cheese. I don't like blue cheese normally but it was really good too. Out of the flavors I got, sweet n sour def was the best“

4.6 Superb39 Reviews
Graft wine + cider bar Wine Bar • $$$
204 N Franklin St, Watkins Glen

Customers` Favorites

Steamed P E I Mussels
Pan Seared Salmon
Swordfish Special
Roasted Chicken
Olives Almonds
Smash Burger

“Highlights: service, wine, local ingredientsLowlights: taste and cookMy partner and I have been trying to go to Graft for a long time. We drove 45 minutes two separate times, after checking their website and Instagram just to find out they were closed on days they were listed as open.We gave up for about a year, and finally was able to make it in last night.The restaurant is small with only three tables and bar space. It is cozy and cute. They have an upstairs but we did not see it.We love that all their ingredients are farm-to-table and my partner who had been several years prior was excited to take me. The first thing he mentioned when we walked in is that the menu seemed to be "whitewashed" which we found to be disappointing. In his past experience, he loved that the chef's Dominican culture was really represented in the food. Now, you would not be able to recognize it from any other American menu.We ordered a wine and started continued to enjoy the company we were with. The waitress was funny and attentive, with a perfect amount of awareness of when we needed her, but not consistently interrupting conversation.Unfortunately when we got our food we were a bit disappointed. The scallop appetizer was tasty but over cooked. We also got oysters, which were okay but I think could be more fresh. While not near the ocean, I have had oysters in this area that I enjoy much more.The bread was amazing and is from my favorite bakery in the region, Wide Awake.For food, we ordered the Arctic Char, Tuna special and the dry aged steak. The arctic char was dry, the tuna dish was very one note and SUPER salty, but the worst thing was the steak.It was ordered medium rare and was WAY over cooked. It was very dry and hard to chew through. All the seasonings on everything seemed to lack depth.Lastly, we ordered all of the desserts and none of them were that good. Rice pudding was not the right consistency and very sweet, the cheesecake was sour and the other chocolate tasty was just okay.Overall we had a great time, but were pretty let down by the food, especially for the cost.“

4.5 Superb46 Reviews
Blue Pointe Grille American • $$
16 N Franklin St, Watkins Glen

Customers` Favorites

Seafood Scampi
Harbor Burger
Fish Sandwich
Lobster Roll
Chardonnay
Pierogies

“Did the Easter buffet. Loads of food and variety . There was something for everyone. The area where the gentleman carved the beef needs attention. The beef was way too rare and was extremely hard to cut and chew. Overall it was a great choice and reasonably priced and the hotel had great and wonderful views. If we are in the area we will do Mother's Day.Vegetarian options: The buffet had some delicious choicesDietary restrictions: The buffet had choices markedWheelchair accessibility: It was good and marked“

4.2 Good81 Reviews
Seneca Lodge American • $$
3600 Walnut Rd, Watkins Glen

“My motorcycle club has gone to Seneca Lodge several times and man they are so accommodating! The rooms are always cleaned top notch, the staff is always polite, personable but always professional. If you are looking for a rustic place to staff for a few days to weeks, the first place in Watkins Glen needs to be Seneca Lodge!!“

4 Good66 Reviews
Seneca Harbor Station American • $$
3 N Franklin St, Watkins Glen

Customers` Favorites

New England Clam Chowder
Caesar Salad
Crab Cakes
Steak Salad
Fish
Soup

“We stopped in here at what I suspected is the end of their season after a LONG day of drinking on thr wine trail. It was amazing to see the place with no customers since it's impossible to get near the place during peak season. I prefer the open deck but when it's 50 and raining, the large windows and warm wood floors are just as nice. Be warned this is not a cheap place to eat, dinner ran us about $100 with no drinks. That said, the food was good and the service was beyond perfect. The waitress quickly picked up on the fact I was not in a good place and happily kept my water glass full non stop which I 200% appreciated. End of the day, the view alone is worth the stop. Side note: parking for this location in season is IMPOSSIBLE, plan ahead.“

3.9 Good96 Reviews
Kookalaroc's Bar and Grill Seafood • $$
107 11th St, Watkins Glen

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Scallops Meatball Parm Ball
Cheeseburger and Fries
Fried Chicken Sandwich
Fried Fish Sandwich
Peel and Eat Shrimp
Broiled Oysters
Lobster Roll
Steamed Clams
Shrimp PO Boy
Pulled Pork

“We went here on a whim and were pleasantly surprised. Unsurprisingly, it has a racing theme, but surprisingly, it also had live music this Friday night. The place was a little loud, but it was hopping, so that's to be expected. By the number of locals there enjoying themselves, we knew we had picked a good spot to eat and drink. The service was friendly, the locals were friendly, the food was good, overall an enjoyable time. We'll be back .Parking: Only a few spots in their lot for the many folks there. You might have to walk a bit (a block?) to get there, but it's worth it.“

3.8 Good95 Reviews
Loading...
map Map