9 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sayre

“Arguably some of the best pizza in the valley coupled with some of the nicest owners and staff. Whether it's the pizza, garlic knots, or chicken caesars salad, it's all been delicious. Recently they accidentally gave us the wrong pizza, which we had no issue with as it was delicious, and they insisted on making us the right pizza (which was also delicious). Chumpys has become our go to for quality pizza in the area and we will continue to come back.“

“Excellent management,Fast friendly service , clean kitchen and my sub was packed with over a inch of ham and price was more than fair ! Thank you“

“Gluten Free Friendly…. Plus it involves a train station!“

“Amazing, friendly staff. I came in expecting a casual lunch with my cousin and left questioning why I hadn’t eaten there sooner.
First,the hot wings. OMG, the flavor was on point . Crispy outside, juicy inside, and that sauce? Pure perfection. One bite had me sweating like I was at a court date—but in the best way.
Then the garlic knots. Calling them “knots” feels disrespectful—they were little clouds of buttery, garlicky joy. Soft, rich, and that garlic oil at the bottom… I definitely blacked out for a second and came back to an empty basket with zero regrets.

The pizza? I’m from Long Island, so I’m picky—but it held its own. Crispy yet chewy crust, solid flavor.

By the end, I was full, happy, and low-key considering proposing to the chef. This place isn’t just a restaurant—it’s an experience… and proof that carbs are always worth it.

9/10. Would risk garlic breath again.
💛🧡❤️🩷“

“I was in the Valley and walked in. Brand new customer. I am now saying that this is the best pizza anywhere. I bought one slice. Perfect. It is impossible to have a better slice than what I bought. Great restaurant. Will try the other Pudgie locations also.“

“the best Pizza in the valley fresh ingredients fair prices the staff is always friendly I have never gotten anything but excellent food from Vinny's highly recommend❤️“

“Wonderfully delicious Italian food! Best lasagna I’ve ever tasted!“

“It's always a pleasant experience coming here! Everyone is always friendly and attentive. The Sub of the Month Cheese steak deal is awesome right now! Definitely would recommend. The manager Teal was very helpful in making sure my allergies were taken seriously.“

“Ok with the 5stars I only ordered a sheet pizza . Plus it was our first time but no complaints maybe a suggestion the dough was done just not to my liking now the is personal preference not a complaint. I would like it darker and same with cheese nothing wrong on their end but as I said suggestions would be a good thing to do so the customer can get what they want does not mean they don't I just did not ask .place was nice the gentleman was awesome definitely will be going back to try more . I say give it a try for sure 😁“