Browse menus, reviews and photos of the best places to eat in Sayre.
Deli · $
501 South Keystone Avenue, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“Stopped in for lunch on a road trip. Skip the commercial options and do a food trust fall. I had an off menu hoagie that has me wishing this place was local.”
American · $$
718 North Lehigh Avenue, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“Great unusual selections. Food was delicious and service was excellent and cheerful. Thanks for a great dining experience.”
Cafe · $
100 South Elmer Avenue, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“Their cakes and cupcakes are delicious. Wonderful job with decorating a retirement cake for my brother. Everyone enjoyed it.”
Italian · $
235 Desmond Street, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“We went to Yanuzzi's for the first time tonight. The food was delicious and the service was amazing.”
Bar & Grill · $
108 North Thomas Avenue, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“Definitely recommend to anyone looking to have a good time”
Tacos · $
142 South Keystone Avenue, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“Very excellent food. Will order again from here for sure”
Burrito · $
105 North Lehigh Avenue, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“Super awesome! Quick, fresh, and decently priced for the portions! Always friendly service and good atmosphere; highly recommend!”
Cafe · $
121 West Packer Avenue, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“Great coffee and delicious gluten free items! I’ll be back!”
Diner · $
517 North Keystone Avenue, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“I mistakenly thought there was a confederate flag flying on their property, I was WRONG, that one was flying at a house nearby. Will definately be back for their awesome food!!!!”
American · $
2081 Elmira Street, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“This is my husband and I’s favorite place to eat ! My husband travels for work and eats all around the US … This is his favorite place to eat out of everywhere he has been to !!! They have the most amazing food !! The prices are great as well ! All of their food is amazing ! The baby back ribs fall off the bones ! Their barbecue sauce is to die for ! Their buttery sauce for the steamed veggies is so delicous !You can get the best soft pretzel 🥨 for only eight bucks that is bigger than your head. 🤣😻 Their cookies melt in your mouth ! Their biscuits/cornbread come out steaming fresh with this amazing cinnamon butter that just melts so perfectly on them … Their sweet tea is made perfectly !😻The owners and staff are so kind !!! Truly grateful to help a place like this. We travel an hour to eat here and worth it. I will post pictures after my review so you can see how amazing the food is ! 💜💙🩵🩷💚 ( P.S….. After our first visit here sometime ago … we bought a Yeti cooler to keep the leftover cool for the ride home. 🤣… Yes .. it’s that amazing !🤩We always bring the cooler with us now for the leftovers ! 🤣💜)”
Cheesesteaks · $
129 South Keystone Avenue, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“Nice people. Cheesesteak was fantastic and came out fast. Everything was fresh. We will be back.”
Bar · $
912 North Wilbur Avenue, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“Second time back here. Only ever up here for work it’s always a nice atmosphere to come to for a bite to eat after a long day.”
American · $
1356 Elmira Street, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“My husband and I luckily happened across Beeman’s while traveling. The atmosphere, service, and food were all exceptional! I highly recommend the smoked corned beef hash. I am so happy we ventured off the gps route! Thank you for a very satisfying dining experience! 10/10!”
Diner · $
120 W Lockhart St, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“Always great flavor and exceptional service! Have never had a negative experience at either Chacona’s or Blackburn’s!”
Chinese · $
202 Desmond Street, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“Service & Food are amazing! They deliver also which is great because us nurse's here at RPH aren't always able to grab a break! My favorite are the steamed dumplings!! Highly recommend... Thank you all a New Kam BO for all you do!”
Bakery · $
502 South Lehigh Avenue, Sayre
“I purchased Frozen Italian bread and Rolls as the fresh ones werent ready yet. . After they thawed, I believe I have found one of the holy grails of authentic Italian bread. Its incredible!!! It is now my main staple and will be frequently visiting. Kudos!!!!”
Sports Bar · $
1860 Elmira Street, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“They torched a memory today… Yeah, it’s probably been 25 years since I last had a bourbon street steak, but when did the garlic butter replace the sweet honey glaze I remember? However, the baby back ribs were pretty tasty, and much better than the ones Longhorn served us. The star of the day was our server, Traci P. Just the right amount of sass with that sweetness which left smiles on our faces. Her iced water was pretty good too. UPDATE: Ordered DoorDash pickup, ribs, mashed potatoes, cheeseburger wontons and green beans. All this for $22 using some promo code. Wonderful!”
Chicken Wings · $
201 Spring Street, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“Fabulous place to eat and relax”
Bar · $
129 Cayuta Street, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“great place to hang out, friendly staff!”
Bar · $
109 North Lehigh Avenue, Sayre
“Hello! If you're here to look at the Lehigh Bar that shut down alongside disallowed customers from not paying tips, then this is the wrong one! Said bar in question has been permanently closed for years.”
Fast Food · $
2303 Elmira Street, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“Food is always hot and the kitchen always looks clean. The line is never long through the drive through but the order does take a few minutes longer as it seems most of the items come out fresh. Excellent DoorDash experience as well. The staff prioritized the Dashers and made for a profitable spot to Dash from.”
Bar · $
221 Desmond Street, Sayre
“Atmosphere. Patrons and staff are great! Always fun activities going on. The owners are top notch people …. And the food is always good!”
Bakery · $$
901 North Elmer Avenue, Sayre
“Excellent people who are very professional. They work in harmony with the shipper and ensure that things are handled smoothly and efficiently. They count the pieces in the load and are appreciative of good service.”
Coffee Shops
1970 Elmira Street, Sayre
“Located inside the new IR Federal Credit Union and staffed by wonderful employees from PennYork Opportunities, which serves the special needs community. Coffee drinks are very good. Love the iced coffee. Super nice people. Very reasonable prices.”
Sandwich Shop · $
477 North Keystone Avenue, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“Subway has been my go-to spot for a quick and satisfying meal for years. I love the flexibility of being able to customize my sandwich exactly how I want it. The ingredients always seem fresh, and there's something incredibly satisfying about watching my sub being made right in front of me. One of my favorite combinations is the classic Italian B.M.T. with all the veggies and a generous drizzle of Southwest sauce. It's always so flavorful and filling. I also appreciate that they offer healthier options, like the various salads and the ability to make any sub into a wrap. The staff at my local Subway are always friendly and efficient, even during the lunch rush. The restaurant is kept clean, and I can always find a seat. Plus, the frequent promotions and loyalty rewards make it even better value. Overall, Subway is a reliable choice for a quick, tasty, and relatively healthy meal. It's a place I can count on when I'm on the go or just don't feel like cooking.”
Pizza · $
205 South Keystone Avenue, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“Amazing, friendly staff. I came in expecting a casual lunch with my cousin and left questioning why I hadn’t eaten there sooner. First,the hot wings. OMG, the flavor was on point . Crispy outside, juicy inside, and that sauce? Pure perfection. One bite had me sweating like I was at a court date—but in the best way. Then the garlic knots. Calling them “knots” feels disrespectful—they were little clouds of buttery, garlicky joy. Soft, rich, and that garlic oil at the bottom… I definitely blacked out for a second and came back to an empty basket with zero regrets. The pizza? I’m from Long Island, so I’m picky—but it held its own. Crispy yet chewy crust, solid flavor. By the end, I was full, happy, and low-key considering proposing to the chef. This place isn’t just a restaurant—it’s an experience… and proof that carbs are always worth it. 9/10. Would risk garlic breath again. 💛🧡❤️🩷”
Buffet · $
1318 Elmira Street, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“Love this place my favorite Chinese buffet”
Chinese · $
1645 Elmira Street, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“I love this place! The selection of Chinese and American food is awesome! You can sit and eat till you explode, for one great buffet price. Or you can order for takeout. The whole staff are very friendly, knowledgeable and helpful. The food is absolutely delicious!”
Italian · $$
115 South Thomas Avenue, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“This is a hometown favorite. The food has been consistently delicious for decades. They take their time preparing your order. It's a great place to come and relax. If you're looking for generic, chain restaurant food off a Sysco truck and fast service, go someplace else. If you're looking for old world, relaxed service so that you can savor your company and your meal, this is the place to be.”
Fast Food · $
1753 Elmira Street, Sayre
Customers’ favorites
“Absolutely made fresh everyday never ever have an issue with this place if I did they compensated for my order and took well care of me unlike Burger King i spent over 15 dollars at Burger King and they messed me whole order up and only wanted to compensate me 60 cents for a piece of she cheese get real Wendy’s replaced my whole meal even with it half gone and never ever gave me the run around thank u Wendy’s for supply fresh food every day thank u Wendy’s for serving this town and have amazing workers in there love love love the environment!!!❤️ Wendy’s for the wing Burger King is just a clown”