13 Best American Restaurants near Sayre

The Grille at The Train Station American • $$
718 N Lehigh Ave, Sayre

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich
The Almighty Brisket
Salad Takeout: Yes
The Frickle Burger
Chicken Parmesan
Firehouse Burger
Prime Rib Sammie
Fish and Chips
French Fries
Bruschetta

“Gluten Free Friendly…. Plus it involves a train station!“

4.6 Superb199 Reviews
Callears Bar-B-Que Restaurant and Catering American • $
2081 Elmira St, Sayre

Customers` Favorites

Quarter Rack of Ribs and Pulled Pork Side Order of Fried Pickles
BBQ Ribs Potato Salad Sweet Potato Fries
Sweet Potato Biscuits
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Macaroni and Cheese
Loaded Baked Potato
Prime Rib Sandwich
Sweet Potato Roll
Brisket Sandwich
Moms BBQ Beans

“Amazing food. All I cab say is "I love this place". Took the crew out for lunch and they loved it.“

4.3 Superb114 Reviews
Beeman's American • $
1356 Elmira St, Sayre

Customers` Favorites

Country Fried Steak with Country Gravy and Eggs
Bourbon Butter Smashed Potatoes
Chicken and Biscuits
Strawberry Shortcake
Philly Cheese Steak
Smoked Corned Beef
French Onion Soup
Corned Beef Hash
Liver and Onions
Chicken Tenders

“I had the grilled shrimp in mason butter. So delicious I couldn’t stop eating even though I was stuffed! Service was great and loved the atmosphere of this nice restaurant. If we lived closer we would go all the time. My husband loved his bourbon steak bowl too.“

4.2 Good212 Reviews
The Blackburn 1897 American • $
130 W Lockhart St, Sayre

Customers` Favorites

Pizza Special Chicken Alfredo Tomato and Bacon
Chicken Cheesesteak Hoagie with Jalape
Pretzel and Beer Cheese Onion Rings
Delmonico Steak and Sweet Potato
Garlic Pizza with Pepperoni
Chicken Slovakia Salad
Philly Cheese Steak
Friday Fish Fry
Pepperoni Pizza
Taco Salad

“We are frequent diners of The Blackburn 1897. Always super friendly and attentive service, very cozy atmosphere and awesome food every time!“

4.3 Superb39 Reviews
Sam’s Bar & Grill Bar • $
912 N Wilbur Ave, Sayre

Customers` Favorites

Sloppily Stacked Cheese Burger
Mini Pretzels & Cheese
Fried Ravioli

“This will be slightly long-winded but it's necessary. Sam's is seriously the only place in The Valley where it feels like coming home after a rough day, week, month. The staff are bar-none and treat everyone there like family. I'm a Tuesday regular, for their karaoke nights, and every time it feels like I'm performing right in my living room. Inviting, supportive, caring, and warm. No egos, just encouragement. The patrons that flock to this establishment are kind, silly, respectful and fun-loving, and this is due in a massive part to their zero-tolerance policy for those that can't conduct themselves as grown adults. The atmosphere is laid back and come-as-you are; which is especially important in an area where being a little weird/alternative isn't always greeted with the warmth that everyone deserves. They provide this level of acceptance and support in spades. The food is brilliant, home style, made to order and Kim is constantly updating the menu in an effort to keep things exciting and accommodating. I adore Sam's and ESPECIALLY the staff that work tirelessly to foster a culture of respect, fun, love, talent, and making sure everyone has a seat at the table. Also, seriously THE cleanest bar and grill in the area. These folks work their butts off. If you have never been there, I can't recommend it highly enough. ❤️ You're missing out on a real gem in The Valley.“

4.2 Good86 Reviews
Applebee's Grill + Bar Sports Bar • $
1860 Elmira St, Sayre

Customers` Favorites

Four Cheese Mac and Cheese with Pepper Chicken Tenders
6oz Sirloin Steak Coleslaw Garlic Green Beans
8 Oz Steak with Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Garlic Mashed Potatoes and Chicken
Double Crunch Fried Shrimp Dinner
Bourbon Street Chicken & Shrimp
Dressed Cheeseburger and Fries
Chicken Tenders Platter
Southwest Chicken Bowl
Bourbon Street Steak

“Where to start?! We had a great run in with the coolest bartender. Marquis was great with offering the tastiest beverages and appetizers right off the jump. I was taken back on his hospitality, as most restaurant bartenders these days are lackluster. He was personable and joked well with the patrons at the bar. Top notch experience! Thank you, sir!“

4.2 Good160 Reviews
Alliger's House of Wings Chicken Wings • $
201 Spring St, Sayre

Customers` Favorites

Dozen Wings with a Side Combo
Blue Cheese Bacon Burger
Hot Buffalo Wings
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Spiedies
Chicken Tenders
Bone in Wings
Chicken Wings
Loaded Fries
Warm Pretzel

“Been thinking of stopping every time we have to go to Guthrie. Today we finally stopped for lunch. So glad we did. Service was excellent and the wings were amazing. Will definitely stop again soon.“

4.1 Good107 Reviews
1882 On Desmond Bar & Grill • $
128 Desmond St, Sayre

Customers` Favorites

Reuben Egg Rolls and Crab Cakes
1882 Burgers and Cucumber Salad
Bacon Jalapeño Burger
Bacon & Bleu Burger
Funnel Cake Fries
Traditional Wings
Sidewinder Fries
Friday Fish Fry
Ahi Tuna Salad
Fried Haddock

“Stopped in for my first time last night with a couple of friends, The atmosphere was great, the staff was pleasant and friendly, made us feel like we have been going there for years. the food we had ordered was absolutely perfect, and pricing very reasonable, highly recommend others to check them out. great food, great service, great atmosphere.“

3.8 Good75 Reviews
Bluestone Brewing Company Brewery • $$
18 Pitney St, South Waverly - 1.79 miles

“Cannot recommend this restaurant enough! Went for a business dinner when staying at the Hampton Inn next door with a group of 9. We were highly disorganized but the servers could not have been more accommodating or patient with our large group. The atmosphere is fantastic and every single person agreed that their food was delicious. Can't wait to come back!“

4.5 Superb106 Reviews
Broad Street Pub Bar & Grill • $
371 Broad St, Waverly - 1.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Jalapeno Grilled Cheese with Tots
Mac N Cheese Bites Broccoli Poppers
Yuengling Battered Fish Sandwich
Fish Sandwich with Tater Tots
Peanut Butter Burger
Award Winning Burgers
Dressed Bacon Burger
Sweet Potato Fries
Jalapeno Burger
Chicken Wings

“Worth the drive to Waverly , HOT Food we needed to let cool before we could take a bite! Great Value !“

4.6 Superb74 Reviews
Tomasso's Italian • $$
398 County Rd 60, Waverly - 4.6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Tossed Salad

“Came through on a visit and stopped by Tommaso’s on a friends recommendation - and I’m so glad we did… It’s a hidden gem in Chemung, with delicious food, a mix of well crafted cocktails, and a staff that was on point! The owners making their way over to us to be sure we were well taken care of was everything- what a nice and humble couple! It was a great atmosphere and right on the golf course. A definite return on my next visit with more time for a round or two of golf for sure!“

4.5 Superb65 Reviews
Mooney's Sports Bar • $
506 S Elmira St, Athens - 1.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Coconut Shrimp with Raspberry Sauce
Chicken Bacon Ranch Mac and Cheese
Garlic Chicken Wings
Mozzarella Sticks
Onion Petals
Turkey Club
Sandwich
Burger

“Hubby's favorite place! Love the bomb sandwich!<<<< old review.
So it's been a little bit since we have been here, went tonight for hubby's birthday dinner, nothing tasted the same, idk if they have new cooks or what but food wasn't as good, also it upset our stomachs which has never happened here before, a little disappointed but that's life I guess.“

4.1 Good57 Reviews
Stars and Stripes Bar • $
317 Broad St, Waverly - 2.01 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Finger Sandwich

“limited menu but great food, definitely eat here again“

4.9 Superb9 Reviews

You May Also Like