“We had The Italian and meatball sub. Also coconut custard pie. The Italian sub was delicious, the oil and vinegar , yum.. Meatball was little cold. Coconut pie was also something else, brought home and everyone enjoyed it for a couple days. Family friendly home style Italian treats and love. If in the area definitely a must try..“
“I come from Long Island where there is a pizza place every 100 yards. I know good pizza ( In my opinion). Busy place. Getting a good turnout. Small for seating but who cares.I bought two slices and struck up a little conversation with counter guy. When he said they came from Bayonne NJ they got extra points. He heated up my slices and I took it to go. $5.00.That's comparable. The guy before me was short on cash and they let him slide. More extra points. I am personal friends with pizza shop owners. They don't let anyone slide.So I'm in the truck. First slice hot, crispy thin crust. I'm a sauce hound so I was happy with amount. Not to much and not to little. Slight bend at the tip. I like a strong sauce so I give it a 8 on the sauce. 9 on the slice and 9 on the crust.This is my new pizza place.“
“Just picked up a large cheese pizza special $11.99. Added pepperoni. Brought the price to $16 something Inc tax. Pizza was very good!Parking: We went after dark. Difficult to find due to no outdoor lighting. They looked closed. There small sign didn't help much to locate the pizza shop.“
“Waverly Pudgies is the best in town! The pizza is delicious and they understand what "light sauce" means. I give 4 stars because of the cost of items. Very expensive. Other than that, a great place to grab a slice of pizza or two.“
“THIS PLACE IS A TOTAL GEM! Great food, great service, and a charming joint to enjoy some lunch. so went here with a coworker for lunch and was greeted my some friendly employees whose personality and fun spirit added some sunshine to a rainy day. My turkey sandwich was delicious, reasonable priced and a generous size. This will be my go-to place whenever I'm in the Sayre area. Don't miss out on this place!“
“Great atmosphere, service and food. We had a double chocolate stout and porter to go with our pizza and it did not disappoint. The pizza had a terrific crust and thick toppings. We liked it much more than the one we had at Amelio’s in Corning (see that review for full comments) and will definitely stop back by when we’re next in town. Kudos to Allison, the bartender who took such great care of us.“
“Amazing food and service. I ordered my food in advance. I have certain things I cannot eat and even though I ordered ahead, she didn't charge me for the wings after learning what I could not have. Will recommend to anyone and I will definitely be going back.“
“The Valley is seriously lacking in quality pizza shops. This restaurant, however, is more than pizza. Their pasta is good, as are their sandwiches. The bread in itself is delightful. (I could make a meal out of just that.)If you do takeout, it's common for them to get the order wrong, especially if you like to customize your meal. So, if you like to special order things, it's best to dine in.“
“I had a food catastrophe, and dinner ended up on the ground. I ordered 2 sheet pizzas and asked if I could have them in 25 minutes. They didn't disappoint ? Both pizzas were ready when I arrived for pickup. 16 shuffleboard league members were fed and happy. Thank you ?“
“We were out thrifting and had to stop for lunch. The burgers here... indescribable. I ordered the Mozzy, which came with cheese sticks and marinara on the burger. Holy cow...hands down will never eat another meatball sub. I just want this burger. The burger was so thick, but cooked exactly how I asked and truly seasoned to perfection. My husband ordered the Hawaiian, it came with pineapple and a bourbon sauce that he was quite smitten with. He was glad to have had the experience, as we usually don't step out of our comfort zones. This place is phenomenal, definitely a must try. We'll be back soon!“