10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Cortland

Melodyland Pizza • $
208 S Main St A, Cortland

Customers` Favorites

Pizza with Mushrooms Onions and Peppers
Hot Meatball Sandwich Covered in Sauce
Plain Cheese Pizza with Four Topping
Homemade Spaghetti with Meatballs
Homemade Spaghetti with Sausage
Home Made Pasta with Mushrooms
Ravioli with Meatballs
Large Antipasto Salad
Ravioli with Sauce
Side of Meatballs

“Why a meal my husband and I had today the steak was just cooked how we wanted it. The service was great and I’ve never had before. It’s called honey cake that will satisfy anybody’s sweet tooth around. I recommend it for friends and family. Great job, everyone.“

4.8 Superb22 Reviews
Pontillo's Pizzeria Cortland Pizza • $
124 Groton Ave, Cortland

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti or Ziti with Meatballs
Pizza with Sausage and Peppers
Buffalo Style Chicken Wings
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Chicken Caesar Salad
Cheese Burger Deluxe
Meatball Parmigiana
Chicken Wing Pizza
Chicken Finger Sub

“Love everything about this place. Pizza was excellent. Lady up front was really nice and very attentive. Getting a sub and eating on site is the way to go, chicken Parm was kinda soggy when it got back home, but that's on me. Everything was still delicious.“

3.9 Good92 Reviews
Hollywood American • $
27 Groton Ave, Cortland

Customers` Favorites

Hollywood Toasted Cheeseburger and French-Fries
Macaroni and Cheese with French-Fries
Bacon Cheeseburger with Onion Rings
Veal Parmesan with Capellini
Delmonico Steak and Fries
Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap
Chicken Broccoli Alfredo
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Grilled Chicken Salad
Shrimp with Mushrooms

“Ambiance... what is it ( look it up). Hollywood has the Best. Wait Staff - Hollywood has the Best. The food is Great and the Owners are Friendly and Visable. Not just the best in Cortland. The Best in CNY.“

4.3 Superb98 Reviews
Domino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
8 Court St, Cortland

Customers` Favorites

Meat Lover's Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Deluxe Pizza
Tater Tots
Lava Cake

“I order from these guys ALL of the time, been with dominos since 2014 as I was a college student. I lived in Seneca and aside from those guys, this is one of the BEST dominos pizza spots that I have ever ordered. Pizza is always fresh, delivery drivers are cool, indoor staff is cool and they always deliver on time. Great location. Worth every penny!!“

3.5 Good42 Reviews
A Pizza & More Pizza • $
104 Main St, Cortland

Customers` Favorites

hbbq Chicken w Bacon 50 50 CBR House Pie
Special of the Day in House Special Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Chicken Fingers
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Knots
Garlic Bread
Monster Roni
10 Wings
Subs

“A wonderful work environment! Good food too- Jodie makes the best meat-lovers and BLT pizzas in Central New York! Perfect place to order from if you’re in a group, there’s so much more than pizza. The honey bbq boneless wings are to die for, and I love the Philly cheesesteaks. Definitely the best pizza shop in Cortland.“

3.5 Good42 Reviews
D P Dough Pizza • $
7 Tompkins St, Cortland

Customers` Favorites

BBQ Steak Zone Steak
Maui Wowi Zone
Buffer Rolls
Buffer Zone
Cheese Stix
D P Dunkers
Cheeze Zone
Dough Bites
Cheesy Tots
Roni Rolls

“First off.. they have a bathroom, but it's out of order .. that's a problem if you bring your kids. The tables looked as if they needed a major cleaning. Food is ok. Not everything on the menu is available. The online ordering needs to be more user friendly.“

3.4 Good43 Reviews
Pudgie's Pizza Pizza • $
75 N Main St, Cortland

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Style Chicken Wings
Slice of Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza by the Slice
Boneless Wings
Pudgie-Burger
Buffalo Wings
Cheese Steak
Char-Grilled
Cheese Pizza
Fried Dough

“From being from New Haven/NY area, it's hard to find pizza that can compare. But for upstate ny, this pizza was actually quite delicious! Good pizza dough to sauce ratio! Enjoyed the amount of cheese too. Would recommend if looking for a good pizza from being out of town!“

3.4 Good72 Reviews
A Round Pizza Chicken Wings • $
4943 NY-281, Cortland

Customers` Favorites

Honey BBQ Chicken and Ham and Pinnacle Slices
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Lots of Choices of Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Chicken Wing Pizza
Buffalo Wing Pizza
Spinach Feta Pizza
Salad Combo Pack
Specialty Pizzas
Boneless Wings

“This is probably the best new York style pizza in this area. The crust isn't too thick or cakey. It's just right and has a nice crunch. They have a large variety of choices. I ordered a slice of the garlic tomato pizza. It's a white pizza with cheese and fresh tomatoes. I also ordered the feta and spinach slice. It also has the white garlic sauce with feta cheese mozzarella and spinach. Super great pizzeria and they make their own pizza doe.“

4 Good56 Reviews
BRIX - brick oven pub Chicken Wings • $
60 Main St, Cortland

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Traditional Wings
Napoli Pizza
Chicken Wings
Vegan Burger
Cobb Salad
Brick Oven
Stromboli
Nachos
Vegan

“First time here, and met with friendly staff, semi-crowded, rustic vibes. Parking was a little difficult. Mix of booths, tables, high tops and the bar.

The menu had a variety with gluten free and vegetarian options. We were told the gluten free pizzas are made alongside cookware that touches flour so keep in mind if you have a severe gluten problem or Celiacs.

We ordered some burgers, onion rings, a wrap, homemade chips, and a gluten free crust pizza - which were all very delicious, except the chips were a bit heavily salted - so I would opt for fries, sweet potato fries or the onion rings, and the gluten free pizza crust was a little burnt on the edges. Our food also took a substantially longer time than other tables seated after us, not sure if that was because of the gluten free preference.

The restrooms have stalls, and were very clean. And overall, a very trendy place with great service and food.

Vegetarian options: V & GF options

Dietary restrictions: Listed clearly on menu.“

3.9 Good107 Reviews
Trax Pub & Grill Bar • $$
2000 NYS, NY-392, Cortland

Customers` Favorites

Smokin Mountain Nachos
Mac and Cheese Pizza
Bacon Wagyu Burger
Fries

“Trax was a great place to eat in the area, thee food and drinks were great and Kelsey was a great waitress. Would reccomend!“

3.5 Good42 Reviews

You May Also Like