49 Best Pizza Restaurants near Fayetteville

“I have been coming to Avicolli’s since my mom was recently hospitalized. I am from out of state and I consider myself a pizza snob. This coal fired pizza is just amazing. Thank you to the pizza guy Bobby for restoring my faith in pizza! Your pizza is 👌🏼perfection!“

“The young man whose name I believe is Rydell (sorry if I spelled it wrong), is one of the nicest and most helpful cashiers I’ve meet. We’ve gone through his check out line multiple times and we’re always greeted with a smile and friendly conversation. In a world where it’s so hard to find anyone that is personable anymore, he really deserves to be recognized by Wegmans! He’s an awesome example.“

“I was fired when i was in the ICU in a coma. Barely survived, but when i finally woke up and came out of the coma, I read a text from now ex boss. He permanently covered every one of my shifts. DESPICABLE“

“Love this pizza and the way they cut it!!! Thank you!! Will be going back again 😁✅“

“Jamesville for the win

Robbie Ts is amazing. Yall know why I went, the calzone, man am I glad I did.

While there as a fly on the wall tries to do I listen, well, thats not how Robbies is. I was introduced to another business owner and he told me about his pool hall. While waiting I was told about the bakery around the corner, so I had to go over there also. Super peach of a nice lady treated me to a cookie from her private stash from the Bakery. Also told me she better see me on Where Syracuse eats on facebook.

What a town! Businesses run by the owners and man does the heart show!

New deal...let's find the men and women that own AND run where we eat. Let's actually bring it home and local.“

“I have eaten there a lot and everything is very great. Today I got the Buffalo chicken sub, and I was disappointed. It needed more sauce, too much cheese and too little chicken. Worst thing is I told a friend to get it and I got the steak which was awesome.“

“Highlights: 1st friendly staff !! 2nd watching the workers hustle!! They we all very attentive including the dishwasher. 3rd my order was read back to me. 4th watching a worker walk through the dining area asking each table if everything was to our likings. 5th OUR FOOD WAS AMAZING!! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🍕“

“Simply … The Very Best Pizza … And Best Value For Fair Price! I’ve been getting my pizza here for years. They get you what you want every time. And … during the Christmas Holiday, they go further by offering a free Pizza for every $30 gift Cert you buy for your family/friends. A truly Great Business & Great Neighbor! 10 Stars!“

“Best pizza around! Real Friendly and fast!“

“The deep dish Utica greenza pizza was amazing! It was cooked just right. The service was excellent too!!“

“Hands down some good pizza. Literally was waiting for my other order. Got convinced to sit down to eat a slice I was curious about (CBR). It blew my mind! Had to hold off tears cause it was that flavorful😭😅. Lovely staff and definitely a welcoming environment to be in. Keep up the hard work and appreciate the hospitality“

“Kosta’s - what a great place for pizza , calzones, Kostas Delight specials. A friendly guy who owns/runs the place so every meal is consistent. A must try.“

“Cicero Country Pizza is a standout pizza restaurant that delivers delicious, well‑crafted pies with a flavor that keeps customers coming back. The crust strikes a great balance — crisp on the outside yet tender inside — and toppings are generous and fresh, whether you choose classic pepperoni, veggie‑loaded options, or specialty pies with creative combinations.“

“If you are looking for exceptional pizza in Syracuse, New York, Tazza Pizzeria is a absolute must-visit.
Their lamb pizza is legit—packed with incredible flavor and cooked to perfection. To top it off, they serve it with a side of hot sauce and homemade ranch that takes every bite to the next level. It is genuinely so tasty.
Beyond the food, the restaurant itself is really cute inside, featuring great art on the walls that gives the space a warm, welcoming vibe. It is located in a lovely area, making the whole dining experience enjoyable from start to finish. If you are anywhere near Syracuse and craving fantastic pizza, definitely check Tazza Pizzeria out!“

“Went to Nick’s on Thompson Rd. last night (always look forward to going there) and had a sausage, pepper and onion pie and a few wings. Great food, great owners, a MUST visit for all. (Open weekdays only)“

“been going there since i was a child pizza never failed me and wings are bomb i have a kid of my own there when i was a kid me and my dad would always come here after hiking so now i do that with my son“

“I run a tire shop down the rd from here, we eat here all the time food is always on point customer service is excellent I love coming here the workers are wonderful. Today our food was on them i couldn't believe it. Weather your in town or local go check this place out if you haven't already!!“

“The food was very good. The house Italian dressing was delicious. Utica greens very very good. Sausage and meatballs and sauce all exceptional and portions were over the top. Beyond all of that, I can't say enough about the service. We were there on a Saturday night, and were seated immediately. Server was amazing, super friendly, helpful with menu options and food was delivered fast. She even bagged our leftovers for us. Will definitely be back.“

“Amazing food, even better desserts. Great friendly staff. Always clean and organized. Everything comes in big portions, definitely worth the price.“

“Amazing place and food!!!“

“Fantastic all around. Great pizza, giant slices, and good people.“

“We have been patrons of T2 for love music inside and outside, enjoyed many a pizza and wings, had some great parties with graduations,work HH and retirements. This establishment also does so much for the community. These folks are too notch. In addition, they have a great volleyball area and outside bar and fire pit. I can’t say enough!“

“Excellent Chicago style pizza. The crust is amazing. I recommend and will be going back. Can't wait to try some of their other pizzas too.“

“Delicious! I’ve never had a bad meal from here.“

“Great food! I don't get wings anywhere else. And when I do, I always regret it.“

“Not in the best area, but the steak sub was really good and loaded with peppers, onions and cheese. The lemon pepper wings were the best I had in awhile. I will definitely be back! I ate the food too fast to get a picture of it. Lol... next time. Now, after trying the BBQ wings, I'm hooked. Great food. Good cook.“

“very courteous, pleasant.“

“Love Varsity Pizza! I remember when I was younger going to SU games but swinging by Varsity’s for a slice before the game.“

“It's been a while since I've been here. I had a slice of cheese pizza and a pepperoni roll. The pizza isn't as good as I remeber it. It was kinda dry. The peperoni roll was burnt on the bottom. Then I got a calzone for dinner. It was ordered with mozzarella, ricotta, pepperoni, and mushrooms. It was mainly just a layer of mozzarella. Very little ricotta. Not a lot of pepperoni and mushrooms either.“

“I stopped here at least once a week after it was recommended by by my boss. Pizza is always good with plenty of choices. All the pizzas are great they make the best pizza I have had , service is always fast and friendly.. I totally recommend sami's for good food good service at a great price.“

“We chose this restaurant to celebrate after our courthouse wedding, and it honestly couldn’t have been more perfect. From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere felt special welcoming, and just the right place to soak in such an important day. The staff went above and beyond to make us feel celebrated without being over the top. Everyone was kind, attentive, and genuinely happy for us, which made the experience even more meaningful. The food was incredible as always. It felt like the perfect way to mark the start of our new chapter together. This will always be a special place for us. We come here for trivia and have built great relationships with the staff. We’re so grateful we chose to celebrate here and will definitely be back for anniversaries to come. Cecelia and Kevin Roskopf“

“Have known the Macri’s for almost 50 years and used to work here too! Great family and great pizza! Moved away in ‘96…and still my favorite pizza nationally…definite 5 stars…too bad Richard’s only blemish on here is some tool from NYC who calls the “traditional cut” some oblong rectangles…Another one of these NYC idiots trying to pretend to be something he isn’t to the “farmers” in Upstate and CNY“

“The pizza is good but I wish the garlic or artichokes would cook down better. Our favorite Blaze is in NJ and they always get the garlic to cook down really well and burst with flavor. Regardless, still some top tier pizza with a great price! Wish we had one in Camillus or Auburn.“

“What a wonderful place! Highly recommend stopped by on our way through from Iowa great food friendly people wonderful experience! Thanks for a wonderful stop!“

“​Stopped by Wings In Cuse and overall had a great experience! The staff is super friendly, and the location itself is really cool. It is housed in a former bank, so the exterior has a solid, classic look, and there are still cool remnants of the old setup inside. Parking is easy and convenient too.

​The food was spot-on. Their potato wedges are fantastic, crispy, and delicious, and the wings are definitely the star of the show. The garlic knots are pretty solid, too. (They have pizza on the menu if you need to round out an order, but the wings and sides are where it is at for me)

​Definitely coming back again soon. Highly recommend checking them out!“

“Stopped for slices on they way through. Very good!!! Prices are second to none.“

“their pasta is sooo good, pizzas are awesome, food in general is really really good. prompt fast service, friendly counter help, everyone is so nice. good food good and friendly employees.“

“they stayed open 10 extra mins to save my night. the young man on the phone made it clear they were totally fine helping me out. he was super nice they made our stuff and didnt have any kind of annoyance about it. we visit at least once a wk and very much like the sandwiches and deep pan pizza. Thank you for saving our night! Dillan was wonderful hes a great representative for your brand!“

“After a hard day working on a house project I was too tired to cook so I called OIP Eastwood location and ordered 4 works steak subs with sides of marinara, 10 chargrilled mango habanero wings and a large sausage and mushroom pizza! We were starving obviously! Hillary got my order 100% correct and was super friendly! 25 minutes later the food was ready! When we got the food home and started devouring everything, all was prepared to perfection and tasted amazing! You now have 3 additional fans of your amazing food besides myself! Thank you all so much for making our hard day of work end so deliciously and making my difficult day so much easier come dinner time! ❤️“

“Been there many times...food always right on. ...even called close to closing time, more than once, had the order done - everything right.“

“Thank you Pies Guys of Eastwood! Tonight we tried the Chicken Parm Pizza also an order of Garlic Knots and Garlic Parm Wings “Extra Crispy”! Everything was PERFECT!“

“The atmosphere at this establishment is truly inviting and perfect for relaxing with friends after a long day. Each beverage offered displays a remarkable level of craftsmanship and attention to detail in every pour. The staff members are consistently professional and ensure that every guest feels welcome throughout their entire visit. It is clear that a great deal of passion goes into maintaining such a high standard of quality for the community to enjoy. This venue is an exceptional destination for anyone who appreciates a refined and comfortable social experience.“

“After a hard day working on a house project I was too tired to cook so I called OIP Eastwood location and ordered 4 works steak subs with sides of marinara, 10 chargrilled mango habanero wings and a large sausage and mushroom pizza! We were starving obviously! Hillary got my order 100% correct and was super friendly! 25 minutes later the food was ready! When we got the food home and started devouring everything, all was prepared to perfection and tasted amazing! You now have 3 additional fans of your amazing food besides myself! Thank you all so much for making our hard day of work end so deliciously and making my difficult day so much easier come dinner time! ❤️“

“This is a wonderful staple of the community with a longstanding tradition of customer first, the staff always make you feel like you are their nieghbor, and the slices are perfectly balanced, not too much dough nice ans traditional. I took my wife here and she loved it. It killed those pizza cravings and leveled out her pre partum mood🤣❤“

“After a hard day working on a house project I was too tired to cook so I called OIP Eastwood location and ordered 4 works steak subs with sides of marinara, 10 chargrilled mango habanero wings and a large sausage and mushroom pizza! We were starving obviously! Hillary got my order 100% correct and was super friendly! 25 minutes later the food was ready! When we got the food home and started devouring everything, all was prepared to perfection and tasted amazing! You now have 3 additional fans of your amazing food besides myself! Thank you all so much for making our hard day of work end so deliciously and making my difficult day so much easier come dinner time! ❤️“

“I had to try Fat Boy Pizza after hearing all the hype about it!! Walking down the alleyway to get there reminded me of a NYC style Italian pizza place. Let me tell you I tried slices of the das whats up and meatball pizza. Both slices were out of this world from the sauce to the crust and the high end meats on both especially the meatballs were excellent . They knocked it out of the park with there ingredients. I also bought a plain cheese pizza for the kiddos who rated it a 10 out of 10!!! I spoke with the owner who let me know they were going to be opening up a courtyard for dining!! I definitely will be back and maybe even catch a concert next time a get a pizza. What a unique set up great job FatBoy Pizza!!!!“

“Cool small Casino located about 15 to 20 minutes from Syracuse New York. The have a few table games lots of slots and a sports betting place. The betting lounge is very nice with chairs that slightly recline and tables attached to pull over and use.“

“The staff where very welcoming. My grandsons Birthday party was fantastic. The kids had a blast. Ty for being so accommodating. I would suggest it as a party place for toddlers and younger youths.“