SUPREME PIZZERIA
$ • PizzaAbout SUPREME PIZZERIA
Customers' Favorites
Large Pizza
5 Wings
SUPREME PIZZERIA Reviews
97 ratings
Share your opinion about SUPREME PIZZERIA
Hands down some good pizza. Literally was waiting for my other order. Got convinced to sit down to eat a slice I was curious about (CBR). It blew my mind! Had to hold off tears cause it was that flavorful😭😅. Lovely staff and definitely a welcoming environment to be in. Keep up the hard work and appreciate the hospitality
Pizza so good very kind even gave me extra food definitely coming back
Pizza fire
Staff super friendly
Staff super friendly
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 9PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 8PM |
SUPREME PIZZERIA in Shop City Plaza is a restaurant that serves authentic New York Style pizza in the Syracuse area. Reviews describe the pizza as the best around, with fresh dough that has a classic NY stretch—crispy on the bottom with a beautifully airy, chewy crust. The sauce is rich, vibrant, and perfectly seasoned, balancing out a generous layer of high-quality, perfectly melted cheese. The CBR slice blew one reviewer's mind with its flavor. Two perfect large pizzas with loaded toppings and perfectly cooked wings also impressed. A slice of pepperoni pizza bigger than a head, 5 wings that were so delicious mild and extra crispy, plus a can of soda came for 10 dollars. The menu also includes fresh pasta, garlic knots, Riggies, and a calzone advertised as Syracuse's biggest. One reviewer was amazed by the Alfredo, and the sizes weren't meant to make you share your food, but the taste and each bite will have you saying otherwise. The owners and the entire crew are incredibly infectious, warm, and welcoming, giving the shop that mom and pop NY Italian vibe. The atmosphere is clean and friendly, with stellar customer service that makes you feel right at home. Both the food and the hospitality are a perfect 10/10.