50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Clay

“This place hits the spot every time. Honestly I’m a tough critic but I’ve never had bad pizza or wings here. We go to this location specifically because of the quality of their chicken wings, as most other pizza places are skimping out with cheap chicken that tastes horrible. This place does not sacrifice quality for cost, and you get what you pay for. Pizza and wings are fresh and great, quick and friendly service and always craving this place. Thank you!“

“Wow! The Chicken Riggies were incredible- I did order standard and they had the perfect kick. Had plenty of chicken and slivers of cherry peppers- loved this. Thank you for a delicious dinner that was also my lunch. Thank you, chef. I’ll be back and will order these again next time. Recommended, great service at the bar- the Genny Citrus Pils was also perfection.“

“Highlights: 1st friendly staff !! 2nd watching the workers hustle!! They we all very attentive including the dishwasher. 3rd my order was read back to me. 4th watching a worker walk through the dining area asking each table if everything was to our likings. 5th OUR FOOD WAS AMAZING!! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🍕“

“Kosta’s - what a great place for pizza , calzones, Kostas Delight specials. A friendly guy who owns/runs the place so every meal is consistent. A must try.“

“I just want to shout out my friends At Amore who never dissapoint we come every week every Friday. Their pizza wings so delicious Esp their chicken wing pizza I never go anywhere else 10/10 thank you guys you rock!!🇮🇹🇮🇹🇮🇹“

“The deep dish Utica greenza pizza was amazing! It was cooked just right. The service was excellent too!!“

“Went to Nick’s on Thompson Rd. last night (always look forward to going there) and had a sausage, pepper and onion pie and a few wings. Great food, great owners, a MUST visit for all. (Open weekdays only)“

“First time trying pizza from here after seeing all the great reviews for a new spot and they definitely lived up to the hype. Fresh ingredients, a thin and crispy NYC-style crust, and everything was ready right at the pickup time I selected. The guy working gave a warm welcome and creates a friendly environment! I will be going back for sure.“

“I run a tire shop down the rd from here, we eat here all the time food is always on point customer service is excellent I love coming here the workers are wonderful. Today our food was on them i couldn't believe it. Weather your in town or local go check this place out if you haven't already!!“

“Amazing food, even better desserts. Great friendly staff. Always clean and organized. Everything comes in big portions, definitely worth the price.“

“I can't say enough about how much we enjoy this restaurant.“

“We just left Akropolis and the Gyros were amazing 👏 The lamb meat was so fresh, tasty, and tender. I am assuming the owners, they were the nicest people ever. Also, the restaurant was extremely clean! Thanks for meal ❤️❤️“

“Everything is always so good and reasonably priced. Portions are good sized. Very underrated place.“

“They are amazing and the food is great! The whole family loves it!!“

“Their pizza is one of the best in the area. The crust is so good I never leave any of it..Their wing are great as well. This is only our second time ordering but we are looking forward to exploring more of their menu. Definitely worth every penny and the service is fast and friendly.“

“The pizza was delicious—fresh, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. The staff were very nice and made us feel welcome. We’ll definitely be back!“

“Amazing place and food!!!“

“Lakeshore is perfect every time! Very reasonably priced and the friendliest staff. The pizza and wings are chefs kiss 🧑‍🍳 💋 we always get the cheese and 24 wings deal, we like to keep it simple. But we love it and it’s perfect for our little family and hosting friends. You guys rock! 🎸“

“Easily the best pizza in the Camillus/Fairmount area.“

“The staff were great, they went out of their way to make sure my nieces birthday was special. Highly recommend them! Desi the owner was awesome!“

“We had my husbands 36th birthday here on 11/8. We rented out a portion of the party room and got it catered. We had about 25-30 people show up. Food was excellent and fresh, and loved that we had a little window to order drinks at. Andrea was very apologetic that some people took one of our tables but we didn’t really care, we had more than enough. My dad has celiac and we were able to get him a GF personal pizza and some owings, he didn’t end up getting sick from cross contamination so we were thankful for that! It’s always a risk when we eat somewhere new. We will be back for regular dinners, we had never been before!“

“Shout out to your staff and especially your delivery drivers! I hurriedly placed an order & ran into work, forgetting my wallet, your driver delivered my food & because he recognized my name said no worries just call & pay when you get a chance! I’ve been ordering from you for yrs & we’ve never had a single issue. Keep it up! 👌🏾 10/10“

“Excellent Chicago style pizza. The crust is amazing. I recommend and will be going back. Can't wait to try some of their other pizzas too.“

“Cicero Country Pizza is a standout pizza restaurant that delivers delicious, well‑crafted pies with a flavor that keeps customers coming back. The crust strikes a great balance — crisp on the outside yet tender inside — and toppings are generous and fresh, whether you choose classic pepperoni, veggie‑loaded options, or specialty pies with creative combinations.“

“Highlights: 1st friendly staff !! 2nd watching the workers hustle!! They we all very attentive including the dishwasher. 3rd my order was read back to me. 4th watching a worker walk through the dining area asking each table if everything was to our likings. 5th OUR FOOD WAS AMAZING!! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🍕“

“Great, friendly service. Excellent food stopped there almost every time I go that way I just don’t go that way that much.“

“DiLauro's bakery is # 1 to me and my family. my dad, Tommy Angarano baked bread for many years. he worked there when the founder, Mr. DiLauro ran it. that family was good to my dad. God bless all the DiLauro family“

“Awesome Awesome Awesome Customer Service and great food! First time trying Luna Pizza! It was delicious!“

“This is my go to late night place. The owner is such a nice man and their food is always incredible. I always get chicken over rice with extra meet and white sauce and an order of Falafel and I can feed myself for 24 hours. I hope they never close this place. <3“

“Very kind service! Excellent pizza!“

“It’s clean, the bathroom is tiny and not accessible, food is pretty good. I keep coming back. Service above average but it’s a pizza shop. The flow of this restaurant is kinda backwards and creates crowding and hovering customers. I find it annoying when busy.“

“very courteous, pleasant.“

“The pizza was good however I ordered garlic knots and there was no flavor to them whatsoever and were pretty dry. I ordered 10 knots and only ate one then threw the rest in the garbage since no one else in my family wanted to eat them. The mozzarella were nothing great and were somewhat soggy, it was giving they were heated up in the microwave.“

“The pizza is good but I wish the garlic or artichokes would cook down better. Our favorite Blaze is in NJ and they always get the garlic to cook down really well and burst with flavor. Regardless, still some top tier pizza with a great price! Wish we had one in Camillus or Auburn.“

“We chose this restaurant to celebrate after our courthouse wedding, and it honestly couldn’t have been more perfect. From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere felt special welcoming, and just the right place to soak in such an important day. The staff went above and beyond to make us feel celebrated without being over the top. Everyone was kind, attentive, and genuinely happy for us, which made the experience even more meaningful. The food was incredible as always. It felt like the perfect way to mark the start of our new chapter together. This will always be a special place for us. We come here for trivia and have built great relationships with the staff. We’re so grateful we chose to celebrate here and will definitely be back for anniversaries to come. Cecelia and Kevin Roskopf“

“Tonight my sweetheart had a hankering for some chicken wings. We were blown away by the exceptional food and customer service. We ordered 20 wings, and two slices of pizza, and the owner himself walks us out four NY style slices of pizza! We only ordered two! He told us that his priority is us, the customer, not money. He wanted us to be happy. And happy we were. When we finished our slices, our wings came out and they were fried to golden perfection!!!!

It was an amazing experience to be treated like VIP! All other wing spots have been trumped by the exceptional service at Wing inCuse!!!!“

“The pizza is great but there’s this guy Mike there that I just go to stare at. He’s fine af.“

“I ordered 20 chicken wings tonight that took 1 hr and 20 minutes to get to me and I live less than 5 minutes from then. I didn’t even received 20 wings that I paid for. Once I received them they were not edible. They were so burned and dried. I took them back and they would not give me my money back. They were disgusting. Never again.“

“Another anniversary dinner at Pastas, and it didn’t fail. Caleb at the bar is our go to, and is always top notch! From letting him pick our dessert, to casual chats, we won’t go to anyone else! Thanks for making our night just a bit more special! 5+ stars, always!“

“Spent 3o.oo for pizza and wings.The pizza bottom was burnt to the point that it couldn't be eaten The wings were also so well done couldn't eat them.It was like some one forgot about them.Last chance for this place been burned too many times.“

“After a hard day working on a house project I was too tired to cook so I called OIP Eastwood location and ordered 4 works steak subs with sides of marinara, 10 chargrilled mango habanero wings and a large sausage and mushroom pizza! We were starving obviously! Hillary got my order 100% correct and was super friendly! 25 minutes later the food was ready! When we got the food home and started devouring everything, all was prepared to perfection and tasted amazing! You now have 3 additional fans of your amazing food besides myself! Thank you all so much for making our hard day of work end so deliciously and making my difficult day so much easier come dinner time! ❤️“

“their pasta is sooo good, pizzas are awesome, food in general is really really good. prompt fast service, friendly counter help, everyone is so nice. good food good and friendly employees.“

“We frequently get the Garlic Pizza for the office. Always a big hit!“

“Such a great place! The owner is a really great guy and so helpful to all his customers! A great warm inviting place to enjoy family and friends ! Food is fantastic!“

“Great food from a hard working Caribbean restaurant.I am from New York City where I've had Jamaican food from dozens of places so I have lots experiences to compare to.I am new to the area. I was driving down the street and noticed the sign for Jamaican food. I had to turn my car around because I love a good a Jamaican spot!I ordered curry goat which tasted just as I would expect. The meat was tender, the rice had a good texture and the sauce was spiced really well, not too spicy.The owner was very nice and we had a pleasant conversation.This will definately be my goto spot for Jamaican food.“

“My friend and I decided to try this place because our favorite pizza place was closed for vacation. This is our new FAVORITE pizza now. The sauce was delicious and the veggie pizza was loaded. We will definitely be back.“

“Had Sandy as our waitress today ! Only waitress there and she was amazing. She works harder than any one I’ve seen and she’s 74! Shoutout to sandy at the Cicero Pizza Hut!!“

“Ordered a couple days ahead pizza were ready at exactly the time I asked, I know because I got out of work early and ended up there ten minutes before the time I specified. Pizzas were exactly the twin trees style I have a certain neostelogia for and were prepared perfectly within those parameters“