10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Cicero

“Simply … The Very Best Pizza … And Best Value For Fair Price! I’ve been getting my pizza here for years. They get you what you want every time. And … during the Christmas Holiday, they go further by offering a free Pizza for every $30 gift Cert you buy for your family/friends. A truly Great Business & Great Neighbor! 10 Stars!“

“Cicero Country Pizza is a standout pizza restaurant that delivers delicious, well‑crafted pies with a flavor that keeps customers coming back. The crust strikes a great balance — crisp on the outside yet tender inside — and toppings are generous and fresh, whether you choose classic pepperoni, veggie‑loaded options, or specialty pies with creative combinations.“

“Lakeshore is perfect every time! Very reasonably priced and the friendliest staff. The pizza and wings are chefs kiss 🧑‍🍳 💋 we always get the cheese and 24 wings deal, we like to keep it simple. But we love it and it’s perfect for our little family and hosting friends. You guys rock! 🎸“

“My friend and I decided to try this place because our favorite pizza place was closed for vacation. This is our new FAVORITE pizza now. The sauce was delicious and the veggie pizza was loaded. We will definitely be back.“

“The atmosphere at this establishment is truly inviting and perfect for relaxing with friends after a long day. Each beverage offered displays a remarkable level of craftsmanship and attention to detail in every pour. The staff members are consistently professional and ensure that every guest feels welcome throughout their entire visit. It is clear that a great deal of passion goes into maintaining such a high standard of quality for the community to enjoy. This venue is an exceptional destination for anyone who appreciates a refined and comfortable social experience.“

“As someone who values great service and community businesses, Twin Trees Cicero consistently delivers. The restaurant is always clean and welcoming, the staff is friendly, and the food is excellent. The pizza is delicious, and the Thai Chili wings are some of the best around. A great local spot I’m always happy to recommend!“

“We have been waiting for this location to open and it did not disappoint! I will say I personally had an oops with the pizza and I called to order a new one fully expecting to buy it and the manager at this location is a master class in customer service! Having managed and run my own teams in customer support, I can say they have made a loyal customer from my first visit! Thank you team for a beautiful pizza, we will be back!“

“Cicero Wegmans I love you I really do but a member of your produce department really isn’t representing your brand well. On 2/4/23 I accidentally dropped one bunch of cilantro on the floor. It was a soggy snowy day and the cilantro landed in a muddy puddle. I picked it up and brought it to the nearest worker. Our conversation went like this…. Me: Hello I’m so sorry I dropped this cilantro on the floor. Her: Yea? Me: What would you like me to do with it? Her: You can put it back on the shelf. Me: Ummm It was on the soggy floor. Her: Yup! That’s why we tell you to wash your produce. She then takes the cilantro and puts it back!!!! 🤢🤷🏻‍♀️ After she walked away, I grabbed the floor cilantro (I can’t have someone buy that) and brought it to a manager at customer service. The manager fully agreed with me that it was disgusting to put it back. Not sure if that lady was having a bad day or if this is company policy but warning to all my Cicero shoppers……..wash that produce!!!“

“Had Sandy as our waitress today ! Only waitress there and she was amazing. She works harder than any one I’ve seen and she’s 74! Shoutout to sandy at the Cicero Pizza Hut!!“

“I have enjoyed several meals. I ordered from grubhub and they have never disappointed. It's one of the best since moving to Central Square. Thank you for going and above and with every order. You never let me down“