50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Cicero

“Lakeshore is perfect every time! Very reasonably priced and the friendliest staff. The pizza and wings are chefs kiss 🧑‍🍳 💋 we always get the cheese and 24 wings deal, we like to keep it simple. But we love it and it’s perfect for our little family and hosting friends. You guys rock! 🎸“

“They are amazing and the food is great! The whole family loves it!!“

“Cicero Country Pizza is a standout pizza restaurant that delivers delicious, well‑crafted pies with a flavor that keeps customers coming back. The crust strikes a great balance — crisp on the outside yet tender inside — and toppings are generous and fresh, whether you choose classic pepperoni, veggie‑loaded options, or specialty pies with creative combinations.“

“My friend and I decided to try this place because our favorite pizza place was closed for vacation. This is our new FAVORITE pizza now. The sauce was delicious and the veggie pizza was loaded. We will definitely be back.“

“Had Sandy as our waitress today ! Only waitress there and she was amazing. She works harder than any one I’ve seen and she’s 74! Shoutout to sandy at the Cicero Pizza Hut!!“

“Cicero Wegmans I love you I really do but a member of your produce department really isn’t representing your brand well. On 2/4/23 I accidentally dropped one bunch of cilantro on the floor. It was a soggy snowy day and the cilantro landed in a muddy puddle. I picked it up and brought it to the nearest worker. Our conversation went like this…. Me: Hello I’m so sorry I dropped this cilantro on the floor. Her: Yea? Me: What would you like me to do with it? Her: You can put it back on the shelf. Me: Ummm It was on the soggy floor. Her: Yup! That’s why we tell you to wash your produce. She then takes the cilantro and puts it back!!!! 🤢🤷🏻‍♀️ After she walked away, I grabbed the floor cilantro (I can’t have someone buy that) and brought it to a manager at customer service. The manager fully agreed with me that it was disgusting to put it back. Not sure if that lady was having a bad day or if this is company policy but warning to all my Cicero shoppers……..wash that produce!!!“

“I have enjoyed several meals. I ordered from grubhub and they have never disappointed. It's one of the best since moving to Central Square. Thank you for going and above and with every order. You never let me down“

“Highlights: 1st friendly staff !! 2nd watching the workers hustle!! They we all very attentive including the dishwasher. 3rd my order was read back to me. 4th watching a worker walk through the dining area asking each table if everything was to our likings. 5th OUR FOOD WAS AMAZING!! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🍕“

“Best pizza around! Real Friendly and fast!“

“Kosta’s - what a great place for pizza , calzones, Kostas Delight specials. A friendly guy who owns/runs the place so every meal is consistent. A must try.“

“I just want to shout out my friends At Amore who never dissapoint we come every week every Friday. Their pizza wings so delicious Esp their chicken wing pizza I never go anywhere else 10/10 thank you guys you rock!!🇮🇹🇮🇹🇮🇹“

“I live between Syracuse and Rochester and was in Syracuse. I’ve passed by Apizza Regionale several times and finally stopped. I ordered an Apizza with sausage to go. I’ve heard of New Haven style and Apizza but have never had it. I must say I was pleasantly surprised. The crust had a slight blackening on the bottom and was still airy and tasty. The sauce was perfect as was the sauce. It was very delicious and will definitely be back again. I also want to say how great the service was. The waitress that took my order was very pleasant and professional. I had knee surgery a couple weeks ago and when I returned to pick up my order she carried it out to my car for me. Thank you Apizza Regionale for the great experience.“

“The deep dish Utica greenza pizza was amazing! It was cooked just right. The service was excellent too!!“

“Went to Nick’s on Thompson Rd. last night (always look forward to going there) and had a sausage, pepper and onion pie and a few wings. Great food, great owners, a MUST visit for all. (Open weekdays only)“

“I’m from Ohio, and we came to New York for business, and decided while we were here, we’d try some New York style pizza, nothing could have prepared us for how amazing this pizza was, the crust was crunchy and soft at the same time!! The flavor on the sauce was like nothing I have ever experienced, and the chicken on the Chicken Parmesan Pizza could be described as life changing, as it did mine. I don’t know who gave this any less than 5 stars, but they have no taste.“

“I run a tire shop down the rd from here, we eat here all the time food is always on point customer service is excellent I love coming here the workers are wonderful. Today our food was on them i couldn't believe it. Weather your in town or local go check this place out if you haven't already!!“

“The pizza was delicious—fresh, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. The staff were very nice and made us feel welcome. We’ll definitely be back!“

“been going there since i was a child pizza never failed me and wings are bomb i have a kid of my own there when i was a kid me and my dad would always come here after hiking so now i do that with my son“

“I can't say enough about how much we enjoy this restaurant.“

“Amazing food, even better desserts. Great friendly staff. Always clean and organized. Everything comes in big portions, definitely worth the price.“

“Their pizza is one of the best in the area. The crust is so good I never leave any of it..Their wing are great as well. This is only our second time ordering but we are looking forward to exploring more of their menu. Definitely worth every penny and the service is fast and friendly.“

“Amazing place and food!!!“

“Shout out to your staff and especially your delivery drivers! I hurriedly placed an order & ran into work, forgetting my wallet, your driver delivered my food & because he recognized my name said no worries just call & pay when you get a chance! I’ve been ordering from you for yrs & we’ve never had a single issue. Keep it up! 👌🏾 10/10“

“We just left Akropolis and the Gyros were amazing 👏 The lamb meat was so fresh, tasty, and tender. I am assuming the owners, they were the nicest people ever. Also, the restaurant was extremely clean! Thanks for meal ❤️❤️“

“DiLauro's bakery is # 1 to me and my family. my dad, Tommy Angarano baked bread for many years. he worked there when the founder, Mr. DiLauro ran it. that family was good to my dad. God bless all the DiLauro family“

“Excellent Chicago style pizza. The crust is amazing. I recommend and will be going back. Can't wait to try some of their other pizzas too.“

“Pavones has been a staple in my family for years, and it never disappoints. The pizza is true New York–style, with a perfectly crisp crust, rich and flavorful sauce, and a great variety of options to choose from. Everything is consistently fresh and well-made. If you’re looking for authentic, high-quality pizza, this place is definitely worth a visit.“

“Another anniversary dinner at Pastas, and it didn’t fail. Caleb at the bar is our go to, and is always top notch! From letting him pick our dessert, to casual chats, we won’t go to anyone else! Thanks for making our night just a bit more special! 5+ stars, always!“

“We chose this restaurant to celebrate after our courthouse wedding, and it honestly couldn’t have been more perfect. From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere felt special welcoming, and just the right place to soak in such an important day. The staff went above and beyond to make us feel celebrated without being over the top. Everyone was kind, attentive, and genuinely happy for us, which made the experience even more meaningful. The food was incredible as always. It felt like the perfect way to mark the start of our new chapter together. This will always be a special place for us. We come here for trivia and have built great relationships with the staff. We’re so grateful we chose to celebrate here and will definitely be back for anniversaries to come. Cecelia and Kevin Roskopf“

“Great, friendly service. Excellent food stopped there almost every time I go that way I just don’t go that way that much.“

“The staff were great, they went out of their way to make sure my nieces birthday was special. Highly recommend them! Desi the owner was awesome!“

“We used Bianchi's Catering for our Holiday Party and we couldn't have asked for anything more. Everything was hot and delicious or cold and delicious. Our menu was varied and everyone was happy. We would recommend Bianchi's Catering to anyone who'll listen!“

“Love Varsity Pizza! I remember when I was younger going to SU games but swinging by Varsity’s for a slice before the game.“

“very courteous, pleasant.“

“Awesome Awesome Awesome Customer Service and great food! First time trying Luna Pizza! It was delicious!“

“We have been patrons of T2 for love music inside and outside, enjoyed many a pizza and wings, had some great parties with graduations,work HH and retirements. This establishment also does so much for the community. These folks are too notch. In addition, they have a great volleyball area and outside bar and fire pit. I can’t say enough!“

“It’s clean, the bathroom is tiny and not accessible, food is pretty good. I keep coming back. Service above average but it’s a pizza shop. The flow of this restaurant is kinda backwards and creates crowding and hovering customers. I find it annoying when busy.“

“Great food! I don't get wings anywhere else. And when I do, I always regret it.“

“Such a great place! The owner is a really great guy and so helpful to all his customers! A great warm inviting place to enjoy family and friends ! Food is fantastic!“

“Friendly staff. The food was delicious hot fresh!!! Right around the corner from destiny USA“

“Ordered burgers, award wining pickle spice wings and Walter white pizza (with cauliflower crust) take out.

The staff packed up all the other food but just asked if we wanted to take the pizza to-go. Unexpectedly, they just handed us a box and left us to pack the pizza ourselves.

We suspected it might not be the cauliflower crust while we were packing it, but we gave them the benefit of the doubt. The receipt showed they charged us $23 ($20 for the pizza + a $3 upcharge for the cauliflower crust). However, it turns out it wasn't a cauliflower crust at all!

Very disappointing service there.

The wings were dry and disappointing. On the plus side, the Walter White pizza was really good with lots of cheese flavor, and the beer was fantastic! However, the poor service makes me doubt we will come back.“

“Fantastic all around. Great pizza, giant slices, and good people.“

“This is my go to late night place. The owner is such a nice man and their food is always incredible. I always get chicken over rice with extra meet and white sauce and an order of Falafel and I can feed myself for 24 hours. I hope they never close this place. <3“

“Very kind service! Excellent pizza!“

“Have known the Macri’s for almost 50 years and used to work here too! Great family and great pizza! Moved away in ‘96…and still my favorite pizza nationally…definite 5 stars…too bad Richard’s only blemish on here is some tool from NYC who calls the “traditional cut” some oblong rectangles…Another one of these NYC idiots trying to pretend to be something he isn’t to the “farmers” in Upstate and CNY“

“The pizza is great but there’s this guy Mike there that I just go to stare at. He’s fine af.“

“The pizza is good but I wish the garlic or artichokes would cook down better. Our favorite Blaze is in NJ and they always get the garlic to cook down really well and burst with flavor. Regardless, still some top tier pizza with a great price! Wish we had one in Camillus or Auburn.“

“After a hard day working on a house project I was too tired to cook so I called OIP Eastwood location and ordered 4 works steak subs with sides of marinara, 10 chargrilled mango habanero wings and a large sausage and mushroom pizza! We were starving obviously! Hillary got my order 100% correct and was super friendly! 25 minutes later the food was ready! When we got the food home and started devouring everything, all was prepared to perfection and tasted amazing! You now have 3 additional fans of your amazing food besides myself! Thank you all so much for making our hard day of work end so deliciously and making my difficult day so much easier come dinner time! ❤️“

“​Stopped by Wings In Cuse and overall had a great experience! The staff is super friendly, and the location itself is really cool. It is housed in a former bank, so the exterior has a solid, classic look, and there are still cool remnants of the old setup inside. Parking is easy and convenient too.

​The food was spot-on. Their potato wedges are fantastic, crispy, and delicious, and the wings are definitely the star of the show. The garlic knots are pretty solid, too. (They have pizza on the menu if you need to round out an order, but the wings and sides are where it is at for me)

​Definitely coming back again soon. Highly recommend checking them out!“

“My family and I had such an amazing experience last night at The Preserve. The service was EXCEPTIONAL, atmosphere was great, and the food was delicious.I am extremely grateful for the last minute accommodations(party of 20).We truly enjoyed our night, thank you for such a wonderful experience. Special thanks to Ms.K my granddaughter loved her❤️“