Rosario's Pizzeria East Utica

Place went downhill, pizza i ordered today was AWFUL! Called and talked to a young kid, has no idea what to do. Never giving this overpriced establishment my money again. I never leave reviews, but this was warranted

Rosario’s Pizzeria in East Utica has truly become a staple for me and my family — it’s hands down our favorite spot for delicious, hearty food served with genuine kindness. Their thick crust pizza is absolutely unmatched — golden, crispy on the outside, soft and pillowy on the inside, and loaded with flavor. Every bite is exactly what pizza should be.

But it doesn’t stop there. I’m also a huge fan of their cold subs — fresh bread, quality meats, and just the right amount of crunch and flavor. Their salads are fantastic too, especially the buffalo chicken salad — my personal favorite. Just thinking about it makes me want to head over and order one right now. It's the perfect balance of spicy, crispy chicken and fresh, cool greens.

The atmosphere at Rosario’s is always welcoming. The staff are incredibly friendly, and it’s clear that this attitude comes straight from the top. The owner and his daughter go out of their way to make you feel like family, and you can tell that same spirit extends to everyone they hire. It’s rare to find a place where kindness and great service are just as consistent as the food quality.

It’s a place I genuinely love visiting. My kids absolutely enjoy coming here — whether we’re dining in or picking up takeout, we always leave happy and full. Plus, there's plenty of parking, which makes things even more convenient.

I recommend Rosario’s to anyone looking for delicious food made with care, and a warm, community-centered atmosphere. It’s more than just a pizzeria — it’s a part of what makes East Utica feel like home. 👍👍

Visiting family in Utica for the first time and they recommended that we try Rosario’s as it was their favorite pizza restaurant. The pizza was delicious and the wings were awesome!

It was recommended that I try Rosario's and it did not disappoint. Ordered the crumbled sausage with onions upside down pizza which I never have had and it was delicious. Also wanted to try the Gabe special which was equally amazing. Grabbed a few canollis and a hand pie and both blew my mind. Thank you for the wonderful food. All of you surely work very hard to make great food and keep your customers coming back for more. Have a great 2025.

Nice little place, kids are great behind the counter. Food is good, pizza is great!

Ordered extra crispy wings and the skin has the consistency of wet toilet paper.
Spent over $50 on food for me and others after a very long/busy day and pretty disappointed.

First time back in over 20 years and still great as I remembered!

Classic Italian pizzeria. Great menu and food, big portions, lots of options. Clean and attentive service. Been here a few times. Love eating here

Best food I love this place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had a great meal! Staff tonight was very friendly and helpful. Pizza was piping hot and delicious. First time dining in, I wish the dining room was bigger.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Great spot to grab some lunch in east Utica. Close to the park.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Just like back in the 80s!

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings

Decent pizza. Not thin crust, which seems to get harder and harder to find, but sauce is really good. Many places put very little sauce on their pies

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Such a great experience. Yummy food...great service!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

7/9/2024. Delivery via grubhub
I've ordered delivery several times & this is 1st time I didn't care for something, I Ordered the large pepper & egg sub & paid additional $2.25 to add extra sweet fried peppers to my sub. Did not receive any extra peppers at all. Sub had very few peppers in it. Quite disappointed in this sub.. this large sub was the same size as the small steak Rosario sub, which is absolutely delicious & what i normally order.. doubt I'll order pepper & egg sub again.
the upside down pizza was received very hot & delicious. There appears no way to add toppings to the upside down pizza via grub hub.. next time I'm trying a different pizza with toppings.
Delivery was fast & prompt. Driver used a heat retaining bag.

Food: 5

Service: 5