The Seafood Shop

356 Montauk Hwy, Wainscott
(631) 537-0633

Recent Reviews

Sort by
David Yablon

Fresh caught fish, excellent prepared foods along with top notch catering - lobster and clam bakes on the beach.

martha fritz

We had an outstanding experience with the Seafood Shop from start to finish. The staff was professional, efficient and a pleasure to have helping us throughout the party. The food was fresh and delicious. The bartender was knowledgeable and experienced.

Ivar Eilertsen

Great good and great service. Just amazing.

G A (TheFamous)

In addition to the seafood, they also sell some vegetables in this location.
But not if you’re on a budget.

Ira Nicanor Barnes

Favorite seafood place when I lived on Long Island. Their smoked Bluefish is top notch. I would get quarts of shucked quahog clams. The hen my mom would make Ceviche. Used get cull lobsters also.

Ashley \u0026 Michael Pantaleo

Always wanted to stop here and finally had the time! Had some of their Sea Scallop Chowder and it was delicious! Good size portion with lots of big scallop pieces- will definitely go back

Rhonda Rosenbaum

Lobster wrap was very good with a lot of big pieces of lobster.

Tracy Becker

Delicious! Not sure it is worth the traffic at that choke point and high prices of course, but awesome quality.

Kevin Riebe

Fresh seafood, great staff, and expensive just like everything else in the Hamptons

Manuel Condo

Good Place

Annabelle Torres

I can’t even begin to tell you how everything I tasted and sampled was amazingly delicious!!!! I’d have to stay a weekend to enjoy all their dishes!!!

Daniel Melo

Very well stocked... all kinds of sea species

Dave

OMG, I will be back there again when I’m around. It was referred to me by our friend and it fulfill our expectation! Portions are huge and super fresh!!!

Isabelle Dagum

Good generous lobster rolls

MrColdwatercanyon

Best of everything

Loading...