Abe's Pitaria

3045 Merrick Rd, Wantagh
(516) 221-8110

Recent Reviews

Scott

Used to be good. Prices went from $6.95 to $8.25 to $15 for a Gyro or falafel. Absolutely insane. And it would be nice if the cook wore gloves, considering he’s also handling money from customers. I don’t expect to see this place open in six months.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Brian McMillan

I didn’t even get to the food. I never give 1 stars, but the service here was so atrocious, that I gave up and left. There was one older, grumpy guy who I guess is the cashier and cook. He was so rude and obnoxious that after 1 min. of trying to put in an order, I left blown away that anyone would deal with someone like this.

Service: 1

Jamie Wellon

Had a great gyro, packed with meat and delicious.Parking: Small lot, and tight, but usually spots are available.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Afmidnight

Food very good - take

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Israeli Salad, Falafel

Mark Ehrlich

One star is being generous. No stars are accurate. Used to be a good place but now a dump with no real gyro meat. Avoid . For real gyros go to Gyro Palace Sunrisechwy Merrick or Stantorini Merrick Ave.

April Robinson

Horrible customer

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Megan G.

I have been coming here for years and it used to be my favorite, sadly it has gone downhill. I called in my order as I normally do, repeated it twice because when the guy (whom is the only person working here now) repeated it a back to me it was wrong. I repeated it again and he said OKAY. When I got there both drink fridges were practically empty. He said two sandwiches? I said no, three. He then raised his voice and said NO YOU SAID TWO. I replied no, I ordered three and repeated myself so if it is an issue I'll leave without the food. We haven't ordered in a while but I wish I had read the reviews before we did tonight. Food was slightly different than I remember it. Definitely different pitas but still good (however not worth the aggravation or the trip.) This will definitely be my last time coming here and honestly it would not surprise me if it closes in the near future.

The Czar

What ever happened to this place??? They’re literally just letting it go, outdated and dirty. Gyro was still good but the service and cleanliness leaves much to be desired.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Alaina H

Very good falafel pita!!! Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Francesca R.

The menu prices are not right so don't go by that. I was charged 18$ for a Greek salad with chicken. I got home and saw that my salad was made with ice burg lettuce and NO OLIVES OR GRAPE LEAVES. what a rip off. Chicken was cold and pitas were hard.

T G.

This is the 2nd time I had a problem with the chef that is the only employee working in this establishment.I asked for sauce on the chicken souvlaki and watched him squeeze red sauce out of tube all over the pita. I asked what is that? he said hot sauce. I asked why wouldnt you put the tzatziki sauce every Greek place uses and he responded because you didnt ask for the white sauce.....now, he prepares a greek salad for me and as he is putting the plastic cover on i ask dont you put greek olives on a greek salad? He responds sometimes olives, sometimes no. Needless to say i got a refund bit not before me inquiring if he was drunk because i cant i.agine a sober person being incompetent and rude luke him. STAY AWAY FOLKS, i just read other reviews about this employee and he is bad news.

Robert D.

the food was cold and way over priced.and the place was dirty! So sad I had been a customer for many years. will NEVER go back

Barbara M.

The food has always been excellant here. However, I am now Gluten Free. I wanted the Tomato Vegetable soup - they have not had any for months. I wanted the Hummus + Tahinin platter without the pita (I asked for it over lettuce) ....the guy said, "NO'. I repeated the order, you can't make the platter without the pita and put lettuce instead....he said, NO! Nothing more, nothing less. He was abrupt and rude. Shame on you. I will not return here because he was rude on the phone. Gluten Free Diets are on the rise and they will lose this entire client base. Such a Shame... they need to accomodate folks and be polite while doing so. Bye Bye Abes.

Theresa K.

Dont go by menu prices .. I paid 32$ for a chicken gyro and lg greek salad w/falaffel.THEN extra charge for yogurt sauce so make that 34$. Not only was the salad and falaffel horrible the "pita bread" was a pita pocket for the grocery store! Effin horrible.

Liliana Cardona

Great Food!The falafel taste delicious .

Load More