Gateway Bagels & Deli

1875 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh
(516) 654-9785

Recent Reviews

Nora Gibbons

These bagels saved my

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sandra Bedell

Spent 19 bucks on miscellaneous stuff still insisted on charging me an extra quarter each to slice 2 of the bagels. Bagels not very good very little flavor texture more like bread than bagel. When I walked in counter person was gutting out someone's bagel without gloves. Once she noticed I was watching she put glove on. 3 people working behind counter no other customers at counter they were more engaged in a dialogue about one of there lives carefully listening to each other to the point you felt you were interrupting. Overall overpriced bagels hard flavorless

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

barrett emma walsh

Absolutely great bagels.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagel

Brian Whitaker

Great, awesome bagels. I'm a tough bagel critic because I'm from Queens, NYC, but wow!!The whole wheat everything bagel is so delicious.Bacon and egg with a touch of hot sauce was so good I wish it never ended. ?What's even better?The staff is so kind, so sweet and friendly I felt like I've known them my whole life.Stop in and eat here. You will not be disappointed.Parking: Big spots and close to the entrance.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagel

Andy Sanchez

Been stopping by here for a few years now. Always consistent and delicious bagels. Service is also very friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagel

Chris F.

Please be aware that they charge the completely unnecessary credit card surcharge when making any purchase.

roxanne wegman

Delicious bagels - good texture and size. If you’re hungry you won’t be disappointed. As a native New Yorker I’d say this is a great example of a NY bagel. Extremely friendly staff. I drove from Virginia for a race and this was the first place I came to eat. Left such a good impression! I will definitely be back.

Ryan V.

Came 10 min after they opened and ordered and was rang up immediately, upon paying was told it's gonna be a little bit bc the grill isn't hot yet, something I would have like to know before paying. When asked for the coffee I was told it takes 30 min for machines to start up.. left without the coffee bc I have to get to work.. maybe if u open at 6 u should come in a little earlier to prepare for 6 or not charge for things that u have no intention of giving your customers

Kat R.

Wish they didn’t change! maybe new owners or something I don’t know but service isn’t good and food isn’t the same. Which is a bummer cause I did liked them a lot

Kathleen Reilly

Wish they didn’t change! maybe new owners or something I don’t know but service isn’t good and food isn’t the same. Which is a bummer cause I did liked them a lot

June Tsang

This place satisfies the craving for a good NY bagel. Never disappoints!

Kay B.

I love coming here to get their bagels and sandwiches. Their bagels are hand roll which tastes so much better. The staffs are wonderful. I would definitely come back.

Kumail Kazmi

Got a lox cream cheese bagel and chicken cutlet on a hero with cheese. Loved both only thing I wished was they didn't use American cheese on it, I assumed it would be mozzarella or something else but next time I will specify. Otherwise 10/10

Ryan Gimenez

Best bagels around, Always fresh and soft. Good friendly service

Sylwia Popkin

First time getting bagels here, they were delicious but I got barely any cream cheese on mine so a bit disappointed

Load More