Awesome place to walk around and relax with a gorgeous view of the ocean
Alexa T
We had our dream wedding at Gatsby on the Ocean in June 2025 with 55 guests on a Sunday evening, and it was truly flawless. The location is iconic — right on the beach with sweeping views, yet still incredibly accessible for guests. From the food and drinks to the service and flexibility, everything was top-notch.
Even when sudden rain forced us to move our ceremony last-minute, the team handled it with grace and precision. The space transitions beautifully between tent and ballroom, and the entire day felt elegant without being overproduced.
Heather made wedding planning an absolute breeze. As someone who didn’t want to be overly involved in the tiny details, Heather’s expertise and responsiveness made me feel completely taken care of.
John is everything you want in a maître d’: professional, warm, sharp. He made the entire event feel seamless — especially when we had to pivot due to weather. He waited until the last moment to move the ceremony indoors (per my hopeful request!) and did so with calm, confident leadership. He kept us on schedule while allowing flexibility for those spontaneous wedding moments.
Ginger was the unsung hero of my wedding day as my bridal attendant. She never stopped moving, never stopped checking on me, and made every second in the bridal suite feel calm, supported, and joyful.
They never tried to nickel-and-dime us, and they truly worked with us every step of the way to create a smooth, stress-free event. As a laid-back bride, I appreciated their efficiency and reliability more than I can say.
Rick Rosa Photography
As a Long Island wedding photographer, Gatsby on the Ocean in Wantagh is consistently a dream to work at. This oceanfront wedding venue offers stunning elegance and incredible natural light, perfect for capturing breathtaking wedding photography. The diverse backdrops, from the beautiful ballrooms to the picturesque water views, provide endless opportunities for timeless wedding photos. Their professional team ensures a seamless day, making it a truly exceptional choice and of my favorite venues to work at. For any Long Island couple seeking a beautiful and well-managed venue, Gatsby on the Ocean is highly recommended for your big day!
GraspInsanity
My wife and I were celebrating our 10 year anniversary in Sep 2024 and we decided to use Gatsby as our venue. Now, I’m the groom so this review is going to come from a man’s perspective. Let’s start from the beginning because after months and months of going to venue after venue, I was growing tired of it all to be honest. None of the places we went to really clicked for me the way our original venue did back 10 years ago. And yes, we tried our original venue but the pricing was just way too expensive. Plus this was our 10 year so we wanted it a bit smaller, a bit more intimate, and we now had two beautiful children that we wanted involved. We wanted our kids to see mommy and daddy get married without going absolutely broke in the process. The first thing we noticed when arriving at Gatsby was just the beauty of it. To me, it looks like a Castle. And of course, it’s on the water which my wife loves.
We met up with Heather and she immediately hit me as “down to earth”. She didn’t bombard us with paperwork, instead she sat down at a table with us and we just talked. She made a formal situation feel very casual and I respect that. She also listened to what our desires and goals were and suggested any ideas to make that into a reality. To say that she was welcoming and friendly is a given. There was just something about the way she talked to us. I didn’t feel like business, it felt like talking to your best friend about your wedding date. Or in our case, a wedding renewal. I really liked that we get the venue to ourselves. This wasn’t a country club where your party would take place in one room while 4 more parties happened right next door. This was private for you and your guests.
Fast forward to the day of our event and I have no complaints. The staff were all amazing but in particular there is one staff member in that really stood out for me. See, I am the Groom, not the Bride and let’s be honest here, weddings are really all about the Bride. That’s just the way it is. 10 years ago when we first got married you’d be lucky if the venue had a Groom’s Suite let alone any of the staff to actually assist the Groom. But here at Gatsby, a staff member named Ginger whom is the bridal assistant really went out of her way to not only help my beautiful bride, but also me and our children. She was quite simply amazing to all of us and she actually introduced me to a new drink, (Gingerale and Jamison I believe it was) I was always more of a Jack and Coke type. Ginger went above and beyond to make sure we were all taken care of and having a great time. And just the fact that she was helping me and getting me anything I needed really spoke to me. I didn’t have anyone 10 years ago except my own groomsmen. But Ginger made me, the Groom, feel just as important as the Bride. I can’t express how that made me feel. Thank you Ginger.
The food was also amazing. We had no complaints and any of it and all of our guests complimented the quality and flavor.
Overall, we had a great time and so did our guests. Thank you to Gatsby, thank you to its staff, and thank you to Ginger for helping my wife and I create new memories that our children were able to be a part of. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone.
Connor McDermott
My wife and I recently got married at The Gatsby and I’m not even sure where to begin. Elyse was amazing to deal with. She made everything so easy and everything came out perfect. Next was the food! We did a cocktail style dinner instead of a traditional menu and it was the move! Everyone hasn’t stopped raving about it. My wife and I are big foodies and not a single item disappointed. And John was great as well. He kept everything on track and made the celebration seamless. Caitlin was super attentive. She even made our younger guests feel at home by setting them up with the TV in the grooms suite. All of this for a very affordable price to boot. Our deepest gratitude to all of the staff that made our wedding celebration so memorable.
Jenny Fort
We recently had our daughter's Sweet Sixteen at Gatsby on the Ocean and I cannot emphasize enough just how amazing the experience was – from the breathtaking room of windows with the sunset over the ocean as a backdrop, the incredible art deco decor – it was flawless and absolutely magical. Most importantly, the diligence and competence of the entire Gatsby team, especially Heather and John, made everything from the planning to the actual party so seamless and stress free it was a joy! They accommodated us at every turn, their expertise helping us with any challenge we encountered. Both of them are like family now. Every single person at Gatsby took such great, personal care of us; the party was a smash and the pictures stunning. Another plus? The event was actually affordable. My husband and I wish we had Gatsby for our wedding 25 years ago, it was truly that spectacular. We not only recommend this event space, but we also encourage you to take a look for yourself – you won't regret it.
Shiloh Piano and Cello Duo
Beautiful location and venue. The staff was amazing and the indoor and outdoor space was right on the beach!
leah
My cousin had a bat mitzvah here and it was PHENOMENAL. The drinks were incredibly strong, the food (both appetizers and entrees) were amazing and delicious, the MC and DJ were awesome, and it was like a wedding!
The interior is so nice, and a man greeted us at the door with champagne. We all felt like royalty and it was incredibly special. The food was really outstanding, I got the salmon entree and it was SO yummy.
Would definitely have my own event here one day!
Dallyce Stinton
We had our wedding here beginning of November and everything was just wonderful. The food was fantastic, the staff was so helpful and the setup was everything i could ask for! We were fortunate enough the weather was on our side and the ceremony and cocktail hour were outside, and the guests were all commenting how lovely it was! Elyse was fantastic throughout the whole process from booking to the fine details. Wedding of my dreams come true and Gatsby staff delivered! Shout out to Roy for being extra helpful and accommodating!
Tatianna and Rob were absolutely amazing! Their customer service was all that I could ask for. To me these things matter so thank you guys, I appreciate you!
Alan Merenstein
The Rosenberg/Brittman wedding was fabulous.
Elise Regina
We just had our wedding at The Gatsby, and we couldn't be happier with how it went. It was the first venue we toured, and we knew immediately that this was the place for us. Our experience began with Elyse, who instantly made us feel cared for and made the entire process easy. The venue includes almost everything we needed, and for the few vendors we had to book, they provided excellent recommendations. Elyse was very responsive at every step, assuring us that everything would run smoothly.
On the day of the wedding, everything was perfect from the moment we arrived. We were lucky to have beautiful weather for our beach ceremony, but the venue also has a solid contingency plan for rain. The reception area was absolutely stunning, and the food was incredible. Many guests told us it was the best food they've ever had at a wedding.
Elyse ensured that everything was the way we wanted, while John was there with us all day, expertly running the show. Our bridal attendant, Kaitlyn, was also amazing—she was incredibly kind and went above and beyond to help us with anything we needed. The entire staff was truly outstanding!
We decided to have our after-party outside on the patio, which was a fantastic choice. They arranged for a karaoke DJ, and everyone had a blast. Overall, our experience at The Gatsby exceeded our expectations, and we highly recommend it to anyone looking for a memorable wedding venue.
Andrew Ramadan
We had an amazing experience at our wedding. From the moment we toured The Gatsby, we knew it was a special place, but they truly go above and beyond to make your day even more extraordinary. Elyse and the entire staff were incredibly kind and helpful throughout the entire process and on the big day. They stay in lockstep with you from the moment you book the venue, ensuring that you’re on track while still enjoying the process. Thank you to John and Kaitlyn who were with us the entire day making sure everything ran smoothly.
The venue itself is stunning. You can’t beat a ceremony right by the ocean, and the photos you get from that setting are unbeatable. The food was delicious, and many of our guests made a point to tell us so. The cocktails were also fantastic. We couldn’t be happier or more grateful that we chose The Gatsby. We’ll be returning whenever we can to celebrate more big moments in our lives.
Trebor Yelhor
The food was great ..The service was horrible had to ask for a beer 3 drinks before We actually got it..I am not sure who the manager is but if the owner see this hopefully I would fired that person instantly Horrible.place wasn't that crowded to.wait that long..the band was great do.yourself a favor sit at the bar and order food
Awesome place to walk around and relax with a gorgeous view of the ocean
We had our dream wedding at Gatsby on the Ocean in June 2025 with 55 guests on a Sunday evening, and it was truly flawless. The location is iconic — right on the beach with sweeping views, yet still incredibly accessible for guests. From the food and drinks to the service and flexibility, everything was top-notch.
Even when sudden rain forced us to move our ceremony last-minute, the team handled it with grace and precision. The space transitions beautifully between tent and ballroom, and the entire day felt elegant without being overproduced.
Heather made wedding planning an absolute breeze. As someone who didn’t want to be overly involved in the tiny details, Heather’s expertise and responsiveness made me feel completely taken care of.
John is everything you want in a maître d’: professional, warm, sharp. He made the entire event feel seamless — especially when we had to pivot due to weather. He waited until the last moment to move the ceremony indoors (per my hopeful request!) and did so with calm, confident leadership. He kept us on schedule while allowing flexibility for those spontaneous wedding moments.
Ginger was the unsung hero of my wedding day as my bridal attendant. She never stopped moving, never stopped checking on me, and made every second in the bridal suite feel calm, supported, and joyful.
They never tried to nickel-and-dime us, and they truly worked with us every step of the way to create a smooth, stress-free event. As a laid-back bride, I appreciated their efficiency and reliability more than I can say.
As a Long Island wedding photographer, Gatsby on the Ocean in Wantagh is consistently a dream to work at. This oceanfront wedding venue offers stunning elegance and incredible natural light, perfect for capturing breathtaking wedding photography. The diverse backdrops, from the beautiful ballrooms to the picturesque water views, provide endless opportunities for timeless wedding photos. Their professional team ensures a seamless day, making it a truly exceptional choice and of my favorite venues to work at. For any Long Island couple seeking a beautiful and well-managed venue, Gatsby on the Ocean is highly recommended for your big day!
My wife and I were celebrating our 10 year anniversary in Sep 2024 and we decided to use Gatsby as our venue. Now, I’m the groom so this review is going to come from a man’s perspective. Let’s start from the beginning because after months and months of going to venue after venue, I was growing tired of it all to be honest. None of the places we went to really clicked for me the way our original venue did back 10 years ago. And yes, we tried our original venue but the pricing was just way too expensive. Plus this was our 10 year so we wanted it a bit smaller, a bit more intimate, and we now had two beautiful children that we wanted involved. We wanted our kids to see mommy and daddy get married without going absolutely broke in the process. The first thing we noticed when arriving at Gatsby was just the beauty of it. To me, it looks like a Castle. And of course, it’s on the water which my wife loves.
We met up with Heather and she immediately hit me as “down to earth”. She didn’t bombard us with paperwork, instead she sat down at a table with us and we just talked. She made a formal situation feel very casual and I respect that. She also listened to what our desires and goals were and suggested any ideas to make that into a reality. To say that she was welcoming and friendly is a given. There was just something about the way she talked to us. I didn’t feel like business, it felt like talking to your best friend about your wedding date. Or in our case, a wedding renewal. I really liked that we get the venue to ourselves. This wasn’t a country club where your party would take place in one room while 4 more parties happened right next door. This was private for you and your guests.
Fast forward to the day of our event and I have no complaints. The staff were all amazing but in particular there is one staff member in that really stood out for me. See, I am the Groom, not the Bride and let’s be honest here, weddings are really all about the Bride. That’s just the way it is. 10 years ago when we first got married you’d be lucky if the venue had a Groom’s Suite let alone any of the staff to actually assist the Groom. But here at Gatsby, a staff member named Ginger whom is the bridal assistant really went out of her way to not only help my beautiful bride, but also me and our children. She was quite simply amazing to all of us and she actually introduced me to a new drink, (Gingerale and Jamison I believe it was) I was always more of a Jack and Coke type. Ginger went above and beyond to make sure we were all taken care of and having a great time. And just the fact that she was helping me and getting me anything I needed really spoke to me. I didn’t have anyone 10 years ago except my own groomsmen. But Ginger made me, the Groom, feel just as important as the Bride. I can’t express how that made me feel. Thank you Ginger.
The food was also amazing. We had no complaints and any of it and all of our guests complimented the quality and flavor.
Overall, we had a great time and so did our guests. Thank you to Gatsby, thank you to its staff, and thank you to Ginger for helping my wife and I create new memories that our children were able to be a part of. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone.
My wife and I recently got married at The Gatsby and I’m not even sure where to begin. Elyse was amazing to deal with. She made everything so easy and everything came out perfect. Next was the food! We did a cocktail style dinner instead of a traditional menu and it was the move! Everyone hasn’t stopped raving about it. My wife and I are big foodies and not a single item disappointed. And John was great as well. He kept everything on track and made the celebration seamless. Caitlin was super attentive. She even made our younger guests feel at home by setting them up with the TV in the grooms suite. All of this for a very affordable price to boot. Our deepest gratitude to all of the staff that made our wedding celebration so memorable.
We recently had our daughter's Sweet Sixteen at Gatsby on the Ocean and I cannot emphasize enough just how amazing the experience was – from the breathtaking room of windows with the sunset over the ocean as a backdrop, the incredible art deco decor – it was flawless and absolutely magical. Most importantly, the diligence and competence of the entire Gatsby team, especially Heather and John, made everything from the planning to the actual party so seamless and stress free it was a joy! They accommodated us at every turn, their expertise helping us with any challenge we encountered. Both of them are like family now. Every single person at Gatsby took such great, personal care of us; the party was a smash and the pictures stunning. Another plus? The event was actually affordable. My husband and I wish we had Gatsby for our wedding 25 years ago, it was truly that spectacular. We not only recommend this event space, but we also encourage you to take a look for yourself – you won't regret it.
Beautiful location and venue. The staff was amazing and the indoor and outdoor space was right on the beach!
My cousin had a bat mitzvah here and it was PHENOMENAL. The drinks were incredibly strong, the food (both appetizers and entrees) were amazing and delicious, the MC and DJ were awesome, and it was like a wedding!
The interior is so nice, and a man greeted us at the door with champagne. We all felt like royalty and it was incredibly special. The food was really outstanding, I got the salmon entree and it was SO yummy.
Would definitely have my own event here one day!
We had our wedding here beginning of November and everything was just wonderful. The food was fantastic, the staff was so helpful and the setup was everything i could ask for! We were fortunate enough the weather was on our side and the ceremony and cocktail hour were outside, and the guests were all commenting how lovely it was! Elyse was fantastic throughout the whole process from booking to the fine details. Wedding of my dreams come true and Gatsby staff delivered! Shout out to Roy for being extra helpful and accommodating!
Excellent venue, beautiful sunsets.
Restaurantji Recommends
Tatianna and Rob were absolutely amazing! Their customer service was all that I could ask for. To me these things matter so thank you guys, I appreciate you!
The Rosenberg/Brittman wedding was fabulous.
We just had our wedding at The Gatsby, and we couldn't be happier with how it went. It was the first venue we toured, and we knew immediately that this was the place for us. Our experience began with Elyse, who instantly made us feel cared for and made the entire process easy. The venue includes almost everything we needed, and for the few vendors we had to book, they provided excellent recommendations. Elyse was very responsive at every step, assuring us that everything would run smoothly.
On the day of the wedding, everything was perfect from the moment we arrived. We were lucky to have beautiful weather for our beach ceremony, but the venue also has a solid contingency plan for rain. The reception area was absolutely stunning, and the food was incredible. Many guests told us it was the best food they've ever had at a wedding.
Elyse ensured that everything was the way we wanted, while John was there with us all day, expertly running the show. Our bridal attendant, Kaitlyn, was also amazing—she was incredibly kind and went above and beyond to help us with anything we needed. The entire staff was truly outstanding!
We decided to have our after-party outside on the patio, which was a fantastic choice. They arranged for a karaoke DJ, and everyone had a blast. Overall, our experience at The Gatsby exceeded our expectations, and we highly recommend it to anyone looking for a memorable wedding venue.
We had an amazing experience at our wedding. From the moment we toured The Gatsby, we knew it was a special place, but they truly go above and beyond to make your day even more extraordinary. Elyse and the entire staff were incredibly kind and helpful throughout the entire process and on the big day. They stay in lockstep with you from the moment you book the venue, ensuring that you’re on track while still enjoying the process. Thank you to John and Kaitlyn who were with us the entire day making sure everything ran smoothly.
The venue itself is stunning. You can’t beat a ceremony right by the ocean, and the photos you get from that setting are unbeatable. The food was delicious, and many of our guests made a point to tell us so. The cocktails were also fantastic. We couldn’t be happier or more grateful that we chose The Gatsby. We’ll be returning whenever we can to celebrate more big moments in our lives.
The food was great ..The service was horrible had to ask for a beer 3 drinks before
We actually got it..I am not sure who the manager is but if the owner see this hopefully I would fired that person instantly Horrible.place wasn't that crowded to.wait that long..the band was great do.yourself a favor sit at the bar and order food
Loading...