Listen, I don’t say this lightly - these are THE BEST custom cookies on Long Island. Don’t bother going anywhere else. From the attention to customer service to the detail in every cookie, every step was A+/5 stars/10/10/Would Recommend. Not only were the cookies beautiful, they were also tasty. And to top it all off, they are reasonably priced. Too reasonably. I sent the baker a Pinterest photo and she exceeded my expectations!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custom Cookies
Disney Girl
I Have been using Mama’s Custom Cookies for years. They are by far the easiest to work with. They always make my visions into a reality and always exceed my expectations. The cookies are delicious and the art work is fabulous. Too amazing to eat. I cannot recommend this company enough. I use them multiple times a year and they always come thru and never ever disappoint. Thank you for always putting that huge smile on my kids faces as they look forward to seeing your creations and eating those delicious cookies. Thank you for my most recent Taylor Swift album cookies and the straight out of chemo set for my friend. Everyone is talking about these cookies all weekend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies Bouquet, Custom Cookies
Courtnie-Lue Morgan-Ledgister
I love Mama’s my go to for cookies for all my events. I’ve ordered here 3 times this year alone and have been happy with each experience. Would highly recommend
Lisa N.
what an absolute pleasure it is deal with rosemary at mama's custom cookies. they make every occasion that much more special! not only are the cookies delicious and beautiful; but the customer service is outstanding.
Sophia M
I wish I had better pictures… the cookies were not only beautiful they were sooooo delicious!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custom Cookies
Cristina Lopez
First time ordering cookies and I love them ❤️ they did a great job and cookies were delicious.
Jediel Carballo
Cookies were beautiful, and my boo loved every single one
Angela L.
The cutest fire truck cookies for my son's 4th birthday! Customer service was great and the whole process was super simple. Highly recommend!
Danielle
Mama's Custom Cookies created some of the most beautiful, intricate Earth Day cookies for the business I work for to send out to some of our community partners. There were 8 total orders shipped to different addresses and each of them was received before/on the anticipated date and the customer service was very lovely. I would absolutely recommend their business to anyone looking for custom cookies!
Danielle Corsan
Mama's Custom Cookies created some of the most beautiful, intricate Earth Day cookies for the business I work for to send out to some of our community partners. There were 8 total orders shipped to different addresses and each of them was received before/on the anticipated date and the customer service was very lovely. I would absolutely recommend their business to anyone looking for custom cookies!
Amazing cookies. They were delicious and the talent to decorate the cookies was incredible. I will definitely be ordering again for the next occasion.
Olivia Krauss
(note; the macaroons and cake pops in this picture are not made by mamas cookies - just the sugar cookies)I was very cautious about where I ordered these cookies because the design is complicated and I wanted them to be as close to the picture provided as possible. Needless to say I am so happy I ordered here. The cookies were absolutely perfect and they tasted amazing. From the beginning everyone was so helpful and the customer service was awesome. They answered all my questions via email very quickly. I will definitely order from here again for my next event!!
Loraine P.
I requested a custom made cookie for my daughters baby shower. The cookie mad for me was just perfect. Not only is the artistry beautiful but the cookie itself was delicious. I highly recommend Mama's Custom Cookies!
Diane
Threw my husband a Retirement Party and I am so happy I ordered cookies from Mama’s. They were decorated beautifully and tasted fabulous. Everyone LOvED them. If I need for other occasions, will definitely be a repeat customer. HIGHLY recommend. Thank you so much for the fantastic work.
Kristina Codi
Mama’s Custom Cookies can do anything. My aunt had a mastectomy so my sister and I sent over these inspiration photos with hot pink bras and the results blow them away! The pastel pink color pallet with the intricate detail blows the inspiration photo away. I am going back next week to pick up another order for a Halloween party. You won’t be disappointed!
Listen, I don’t say this lightly - these are THE BEST custom cookies on Long Island. Don’t bother going anywhere else. From the attention to customer service to the detail in every cookie, every step was A+/5 stars/10/10/Would Recommend. Not only were the cookies beautiful, they were also tasty. And to top it all off, they are reasonably priced. Too reasonably. I sent the baker a Pinterest photo and she exceeded my expectations!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custom Cookies
I Have been using Mama’s Custom Cookies for years. They are by far the easiest to work with. They always make my visions into a reality and always exceed my expectations. The cookies are delicious and the art work is fabulous. Too amazing to eat. I cannot recommend this company enough. I use them multiple times a year and they always come thru and never ever disappoint. Thank you for always putting that huge smile on my kids faces as they look forward to seeing your creations and eating those delicious cookies. Thank you for my most recent Taylor Swift album cookies and the straight out of chemo set for my friend. Everyone is talking about these cookies all weekend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies Bouquet, Custom Cookies
I love Mama’s my go to for cookies for all my events. I’ve ordered here 3 times this year alone and have been happy with each experience. Would highly recommend
what an absolute pleasure it is deal with rosemary at mama's custom cookies. they make every occasion that much more special! not only are the cookies delicious and beautiful; but the customer service is outstanding.
I wish I had better pictures… the cookies were not only beautiful they were sooooo delicious!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custom Cookies
First time ordering cookies and I love them ❤️ they did a great job and cookies were delicious.
Cookies were beautiful, and my boo loved every single one
The cutest fire truck cookies for my son's 4th birthday! Customer service was great and the whole process was super simple. Highly recommend!
Mama's Custom Cookies created some of the most beautiful, intricate Earth Day cookies for the business I work for to send out to some of our community partners. There were 8 total orders shipped to different addresses and each of them was received before/on the anticipated date and the customer service was very lovely. I would absolutely recommend their business to anyone looking for custom cookies!
Mama's Custom Cookies created some of the most beautiful, intricate Earth Day cookies for the business I work for to send out to some of our community partners. There were 8 total orders shipped to different addresses and each of them was received before/on the anticipated date and the customer service was very lovely. I would absolutely recommend their business to anyone looking for custom cookies!
Restaurantji Recommends
Amazing cookies. They were delicious and the talent to decorate the cookies was incredible. I will definitely be ordering again for the next occasion.
(note; the macaroons and cake pops in this picture are not made by mamas cookies - just the sugar cookies)I was very cautious about where I ordered these cookies because the design is complicated and I wanted them to be as close to the picture provided as possible. Needless to say I am so happy I ordered here. The cookies were absolutely perfect and they tasted amazing. From the beginning everyone was so helpful and the customer service was awesome. They answered all my questions via email very quickly. I will definitely order from here again for my next event!!
I requested a custom made cookie for my daughters baby shower. The cookie mad for me was just perfect. Not only is the artistry beautiful but the cookie itself was delicious. I highly recommend Mama's Custom Cookies!
Threw my husband a Retirement Party and I am so happy I ordered cookies from Mama’s. They were decorated beautifully and tasted fabulous. Everyone LOvED them. If I need for other occasions, will definitely be a repeat customer. HIGHLY recommend. Thank you so much for the fantastic work.
Mama’s Custom Cookies can do anything. My aunt had a mastectomy so my sister and I sent over these inspiration photos with hot pink bras and the results blow them away! The pastel pink color pallet with the intricate detail blows the inspiration photo away. I am going back next week to pick up another order for a Halloween party. You won’t be disappointed!